Comparison of LSLADEs and transnational LSLAs
| Dimension | LSLADEs | Transnational LSLAs |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership and financing | Initiated by medium-scale farmers, local entrepreneurs, traditional authorities and domestic programs | Driven by multinational corporations, foreign governments, or international investors |
| Land access | Acquired mainly through customary authorities and local negotiations; parcels often fragmented | Negotiated at national or intergovernmental levels; typically large, contiguous concessions |
| Technology and inputs | Relies on tractors, disc plows, bulldozers and herbicides, with heavy dependence on rental/service markets | Equipped with advanced mechanization, irrigation, and vertically integrated supply chains; machinery usually owned outright |
| Regulatory oversight | Governed by domestic institutions; enforcement of safeguards often weak or inconsistent | Subject to both host-country laws and international scrutiny (e.g., donor safeguards), though implementation is uneven |
| Environmental practices | Land clearing and agrochemical use often lack monitoring, increasing risks of soil degradation and biodiversity loss | Environmental management plans more likely to be required, but ecological impacts remain significant in practice |
| Spillover channels | Stimulates rural markets for mechanization and agro-inputs; potential benefits for smallholders, but with ecological costs | May create jobs and infrastructure but often operate as enclaves with weak local linkages |
| Scale and scope | Moderate in scale; embedded in domestic agricultural systems and local markets | Large in scale; integrated into global value chains and export markets |
| Dimension | LSLADEs | Transnational LSLAs |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership and financing | Initiated by medium-scale farmers, local entrepreneurs, traditional authorities and domestic programs | Driven by multinational corporations, foreign governments, or international investors |
| Land access | Acquired mainly through customary authorities and local negotiations; parcels often fragmented | Negotiated at national or intergovernmental levels; typically large, contiguous concessions |
| Technology and inputs | Relies on tractors, disc plows, bulldozers and herbicides, with heavy dependence on rental/service markets | Equipped with advanced mechanization, irrigation, and vertically integrated supply chains; machinery usually owned outright |
| Regulatory oversight | Governed by domestic institutions; enforcement of safeguards often weak or inconsistent | Subject to both host-country laws and international scrutiny (e.g., donor safeguards), though implementation is uneven |
| Environmental practices | Land clearing and agrochemical use often lack monitoring, increasing risks of soil degradation and biodiversity loss | Environmental management plans more likely to be required, but ecological impacts remain significant in practice |
| Spillover channels | Stimulates rural markets for mechanization and agro-inputs; potential benefits for smallholders, but with ecological costs | May create jobs and infrastructure but often operate as enclaves with weak local linkages |
| Scale and scope | Moderate in scale; embedded in domestic agricultural systems and local markets | Large in scale; integrated into global value chains and export markets |
Note(s): LSLADEs differ significantly from transnational land acquisitions in terms of ownership structures, institutional embeddedness and operational models. Domestic investors (medium-scale farmers, traditional leaders and government-backed schemes) often use locally embedded negotiation channels and intermediate-scale mechanization, creating both opportunities for technology spillovers and risks of biodiversity degradation (Jayne et al., 2016, 2019, 2022). In contrast, transnational acquisitions are typically large-scale, export-oriented and highly mechanized, producing enclave economies with more pronounced ecological consequences, including deforestation, monocropping and biodiversity loss (Pretty et al., 2018)
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.