Table A10

Manuscripts included in qualitative synthesis

AuthorPublication yearTitleField of studiesAcademic degree levelsMode of implementationLocation countryNumber of participantsDuration of the IaH initiative
Albá Duran, J. and Oggel, G2019Challenges of the Transatlantic Cross-Disciplinary ENVOIE-UFRUG ProjectHispanic Literature, and JournalismUndergraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeThe Netherlands and Chile1 to 20Two months
Asojo, A.; Kartoshkina, Y.; Amole, D. and Jaiyeoba, B2019Multicultural Learning and Experiences in Design through the Collaborative Online International Learning (COIL) FrameworkInterior Design, and ArchitectureUndergraduate and GraduateCOILUSA and Nigeria21 to 40Two months
Barbosa, B.; Santos, C.; Prado-MezaC.M.2020There is no one way to internationalization at home: Virtual mobility and student engagement through formal and informal approaches to curriculaMarketing, and International BusinessUndergraduateVirtual ExchangePortugal and Mexico21 to 40One month
Barbosa, B.; Santos, C.; Prado-MezaC.M.2020There is no one way to internationalization at home: Virtual mobility and student engagement through formal and informal approaches to curriculaLanguage LearningUndergraduateIn-campus activitiesPortugal21 to 40One semester
Bauk, S.; Fajardo-Flores, S2020Matching interaction design principles and integrated navigation systems in an electronic classroomMaritime Studies and EngineeringNACOILSouth Africa and Mexico21 to 40Two months
Bowen, K.; Barry, M.; Jowell, A.; Maddah, D.; AlamiN.H.2021Virtual Exchange in Global Health: an innovative educational approach to foster socially responsible overseas collaborationHuman Biology, Biochemistry, and Public HealthUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and Lebanon21 to 40Six weeks
Carlson, E.; Stenberg, M.; Lai, T.; Reisenhofer, S.; Chan, B.; Cruz, E.; Leung, D.; Wong, A.; ChanE.A.2019Nursing students' perceptions of peer learning through cross-cultural student-led webinars: A qualitative studyNursingUndergraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeAustralia, Hong Kong, and Sweeden21 to 40NA
Cheikhrouhou, N. and Ludwig, K2021Creating a Prototype for a Seawater Farm through an American-Tunisian Virtual ExchangeComputer Sciences, Mechanical Engineering, and PsychologyUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and Tunisia21 to 40Two months
Cheikhrouhou, N. and Marchewka, M2020Exploring Foreign Entrepreneurial Ecosystems through Virtual ExchangeManagement, International Business, Tourism, Recreation, and Computer System NetworksUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangePoland and Tunisia21 to 40Six weeks
Cioltan-Draghiciu, A. and Stanciu, D2020Virtual Exchange: Romania and Hungary 100 Years LaterHistoryUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeHungary and Romania1 to 20One semester
Dooly, M.; Sadler, R2020If you don’t improve, what’s the point? Investigating the impact of a flipped online exchange in teacher educationLanguage TeachingUndergraduateTelecollaborationUSA and Spain41 to 6010 weeks
Fernández-Raga, M. and Villard, T2020Multidisciplinary and International Virtual Collaboration on the “Shared Garden” between the Universities of Bordeaux and LeónApplied Physics and Measurement Engineering (APME), and Electrical EngineeringUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeFrance and Spain1 to 20Two semesters
Freiermuth, M.R.; Huang, H.-C2021Zooming across cultures: Can a telecollaborative video exchange between language learning partners further the development of intercultural competences?Language LearningUndergraduate and GraduateTelecollaborationTaiwan and Japan1 to 20NA
Fuchs, C2021Supporting Autonomy in an Exam-Based Context: Results from a Hong Kong-U.S. TelecollaborationEnglish majorsUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeHong Kong and USA61 to 8010 weeks
Fuchs, C2019Critical incidents and cultures-of-use in a Hong Kong-Germany telecollaborationLanguage TeachingGraduateTelecollaborationHong Kong and Germany61 to 80One semester
Gorman, T.; Kanninen, M. and Syrjä, T2020Immersive Telepresence in Theatre: Performing Arts Education in Digital SpacesTheatreNACOILUK and FinlandNALess than a month
Griggio, L. and Pittarello, S2020How a Multilingual Project Can Foster and Enhance International MobilityLanguages and LiteratureNAIn-campus activitiesItalyMore than 100Two months
Guadamillas GómezM.V.2018Developing soft skills in higher education foreign language programs. Initial insights into telecollaborationPrimary Education and different degree programsUndergraduateTelecollaborationSpain and UK21 to 40Six weeks
Guariento, W.; Rolinska, A. and Al-Masri, N2018Constructive content-based feedback in EAP contexts: lessons from a cross-border engineering-related pre-sessional courseElectrical, Civil or Mechanical Engineering, and UK-based international students taking different postgraduate coursesUndergraduate and GraduateTelecollaborationUK and Palestine41 to 60Less than a month
Háhn, J. and Radke, K2020Combining Expertise from Linguistics and Tourism: A Tale of Two CitiesLanguage Studies, Information and Communications Technology, and Management in TourismUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangePoland and Finland21 to 40Six weeks
Hilliker, S2020Virtual Exchange as a Study Abroad Alternative to Foster Language and Culture Exchange in TESOL Teacher EducationLinguistics majors, and TESOL teacher candidatesUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and Mexico1 to 20One month
Hilliker, S. and Loranc, B2022Development of 21st century skills through virtual exchangeLanguage Teaching and Language LearnersUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and Turkey41 to 60Six weeks
Hofmeyr, A2021Taking Advantage of a Multicultural Campus: Impact of At-Home Intercultural Initiatives on Japanese Students’ Skills and Future GoalsLanguage LearningUndergraduateIn-campus activitiesJapanMore than 100NA
Hofmeyr, A2021Intercultural Competence Development Through Co-Curricular and Extracurricular At-Home Programs in JapanEngineering, Area Studies, and ManagementNAIn-campus activitiesJapanMore than 100Two semesters
Hyett, N.; Lee, K.M.; Knevel, R.; Fortune, T.; Yau, M.K.; Borkovic, S2019Trialing Virtual Intercultural Learning With Australian and Hong Kong Allied Health Students to Improve Cultural CompetencyOccupational Therapy, and Oral HealthUndergraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeAustralia and Hong Kong1 to 20Six weeks
Ingram, L.A.; Monroe, C.; Wright, H.; Burrell, A.; Jenks, R.; Cheung, S.; FriedmanD.B.2021Fostering Distance Education: Lessons From a United States-England Partnered Collaborative Online International Learning ApproachPublic Health, and PsychologyUndergraduate and GraduateCOILUSA and UKMore than 100Six weeks
Jaramillo Chavez, N.; Gleason, B2022A virtual exchange experience: Preparing pre-service teachers for cultural diversityEducationNAVirtual ExchangeUSA and Turkey21 to 40Less than a month
Kanamori, Y.; Seki, N.; Foxton, R.; Moross, J.; Komagamine, Y.; Mizutani, K.; Hosaka, K.; Kanazawa, M.; Hatayama, T.; Komada, W.; Yonemitsu, I.; Akiyama, M.; Kaewmanee, P. Kaewsutha, Nathawut; N.; Wakabayashi, N.; Morio, I2022Fostering globally competent dental students through virtual team-working, problem-solving and person-centred multi-disciplinary care planningOdontologyUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeJapan and ThailandNAOne semester
Katre, A2020Creative Economy Teaching and Learning--A Collaborative Online International Learning CaseEconomicsUndergraduateCOILUSA and ChinaNAOne semester
Knysh, A.; Matochkina, A.; Ulanova, D.; Meechan, P.; Austin, T2019When Two Worldviews Meet: Promoting Mutual Understanding between 'Secular' and Religious Students of Islamic Studies in Russia and the United StatesReligionUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and Russia21 to 40One semester
Koris, R. and VuylstekeJ.F.2020Mission (Im)possible: Developing Students' International Online Business Communication Skills through Virtual TeamworkLanguage LearningGraduateVirtual ExchangeHungary and BelgiumNATwo months
Krengel, F2021“Glocal Education” through Virtual Exchange? Training Pre-Service EFL Teachers to Connect Their Local Classrooms to the World and BackLanguage TeachingUndergraduate and GraduateVirtual ExchangeGermany, Turkey and SwedenNAOne semester
Larrondo Ureta, A.; Peña Fernández, S.; Fernandes Teixeira, J2021Online Journalism Teaching and Learning Processes Beyond the Classroom and the University: Experiences in International Virtual Collaboration on Multimedia ProjectsJournalism media studies and communicationUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeSpain, Portugal and Brazil81 to 100One semester
Law, L.; Hafiz, M.; Kwong, T.; Wong, E2019Evaluating Students' Perceptions on the Effectiveness of Online Intercultural Learning Experience via a SPOCEducationGraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeHong Kong and Singapore81 to 100Less than a month
Lee, B.K.; Cai, H2019Evaluation of an Online “Internationalization at Home” Course on the Social Contexts of AddictionAddictions Counselling, Public Health, Psychology, Management, Psychology, Nursing, Traditional Chinese Medicine, Business, Hospital ManagementUndergraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeCanada and China (Hong Kong and Macau)41 to 60One semester
Leung, D.; Kumlien, C.; Bish, M.; Carlson, E.; Chan, P.; Chan, E2021Using internationalization-at-home activities to enhance the cultural awareness of health and social science research students: A mixed-method studyHealth Sciences, and Social SciencesUndergraduate and GraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeAustralia, Hong Kong and Sweeden1 to 2010 weeks
Limoges, J.; Nielsen, K.; MacMaster, L.; Kontni, R2019Globally networked learning: Deepening Canadian and Danish nursing students' understanding of nursing, culture and healthNursingUndergraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeCanada and Denmark21 to 40One semester
Liu, Y.; Shirley, T2021Without crossing a border: Exploring the impact of shifting study abroad online on students’ learning and intercultural competence development during the covid-19 pandemicBusiness, and Automobile EngineeringUndergraduateCOILUSA, Brazil, Germany and India1 to 20NA
Luo, H.; Gui, M2021Developing an effective Chinese-American telecollaborative learning program: an action research studyLanguage LearningUndergraduateOnline Intercultural ExchangeUSA and China41 to 60One semester
Marchewka, M. and Raina, R2019'FORE - UEK Telecollaboration 2017' -- Virtual Exchange in Business StudiesBusiness Management, and EconomicsUndergraduate and GraduateTelecollaborationIndia and Poland61 to 80One semester
Martins, C. and Werner, M2019Brazil and Colombia Virtual Exchange Project: The Brazilian ViewLanguage TeachingUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeColombia and Brazil61 to 80One semester
Matsui, H2020Collaborative Tasks in Telecollaboration: Their Challenges and PotentialsLanguage LearningNATelecollaborationUSA and Japan21 to 40One semester
Mestre-Segarra, M.A. and Ruiz-Garrido, M2022Examining students’ reflections on a collaborative online international learning project in an ICLHE contextBusinessGraduateCOILSpain and USA21 to 40Six weeks
Mittelmeier, J.; Rienties, B.; Tempelaar, D.; Hillaire, G.; Whitelock, D2018The influence of internationalised versus local content on online intercultural collaboration in groups: A randomised control trial study in a statistics courseStatisticsUndergraduateIoCThe NetherlandsMore than 100Six weeks
Moalla, A.; Abid, N.; Balaman, U2020Task-Enhanced Virtual Exchange between University of Sfax, Tunisia, and Hacettepe University, TurkeyLanguage TeachingUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeTurkey and Tunisia21 to 40One month
Mundel, J2020International Virtual Collaboration in Advertising Courses: Building International and Intercultural Skills from HomeCommunication, and International BusinessUndergraduateCOILUSA and The Netherlands21 to 40One month
Orsini-Jones, M.; Cerveró Carrascosa, A.; Zou, B2020The Trouble with Telecollaboration in BMELTETLanguage TeachingUndergraduate and GraduateCOILSpain, UK and China61 to 80One semester
Petropoulou, Z2021Virtual Classroom Experiences for Second Language Learning and Cultural ExchangeLanguage LearningUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and France1 to 20Two months
Polyakova, O.; Galstyan-Sargsyan, R2021Sustainable Higher Education via Telecollaboration: Improving Plurilingual and Pluricultural CompetenceThe participants were all drawn from different study courses, they had disparate subject area alignmentsNACOILSpain and Finland1 to 20One month
Pushkarna, N.; Daly, A.; Fan, A2021Teaching digital and global law for digital and global students: creating students as producers in a Hong Kong Internet Law classLawUndergraduateIoCHong Kong21 to 40One semester
Rauer, J.N.; Kroiss, M.; Kryvinska, N.; Engelhardt-Nowitzki, C.; Aburaia, M2021Cross-university virtual teamwork as a means of internationalization at homeMechatronics/Robotics; Management Information Systems, eBusiness and Service Science, and Systems for EnterprisesNATelecollaborationIt has been piloted with 150 students from across 26 nations and five universitiesMore than 100Less than a month
Silla, I.; Tordera, N.; Pérez-NebraA.R.2021Online intercultural exchange: A case study in work and organisational psychologyPsychologyUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeSpain and Brazil21 to 40NA
Stephens de Jonge, J.; Labrador, B2020Fostering Critical Thinking and Motivation through Digital Escape Rooms: Preliminary ObservationsLanguage LearningUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeSpain and USA41 to 60One semester
Turnbull, J.; Yazan, B.; Akayoglu, S.; Uzum, B.; Mary, L2022Teacher candidates’ ideological tensions and covert metaphors about Syrian refugees in Turkey: Critical discourse analysis of telecollaborationEducationUndergraduateTelecollaborationUSA, France and TurkeyMore than 100One semester
Vahed, A2021Factors enabling and constraining students’ collaborative online international learning experiencesDental Technology, and Business ManagementUndergraduateCOILUSA and South Africa21 to 40One month
Vicente, C.; Jacobs, F.; de Carvalho, D.; Chhaganlal, K.; de Carvalho, R.; Raboni, S.; Qosaj, F.; Dau, P.; Ferreira, M.; Brunetti, M.; Tanaka, L2022The Joint Initiative for Teaching and Learning on Global Health Challenges and One Health experience on implementing an online collaborative courseGlobal HealthUndergraduate and GraduateCOILBrazil, Germany, Mozambique and Kosovo21 to 40 
Vinagre, M2022Engaging with difference: Integrating the linguistic landscape in virtual exchangeLanguage LearningUndergraduateVirtual ExchangeUSA and Spain41 to 60Six weeks
West, H.; Goto, K.; Borja, S.A.N.; Trechter, S.; Klobodu, S2022Evaluation of a Collaborative Online International Learning (COIL): A food product analysis and development projectGlobal Nutrition, and Culinary Arts degreeUndergraduateCOILUSA and Ecuador41 to 60One semester
Wood, E.A.; Collins, S.L.; Mueller, S.; Stetten, N.E.; El-Shokry, M2022Transforming Perspectives Through Virtual Exchange: A US-Egypt Partnership Part 1Global HealthUndergraduateCOILUSA and EgyptMore than 100One month

Source(s): Authors’ own work

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal