Table A2

Summary of drones' potentials, challenges and solutions in LMD

PotentialsChallengesSolutions
Senders
Cost
  • Reaching 28–93% cost savings compared to conventional delivery methods

  • Low investment and operating costs (for single drones)

  • Improving efficiency by shortening travel distance/time and reducing reliance on fuels

  • Lowering drivers cost by reducing work shifts

  • Lowering storage cost by relieving amassed inventory volumes

  • Lowering cost of delayed/failed deliveries through speedy/timely deliveries

  • Difficulty in considering a myriad of factors impacting economic viability (e.g. scale economies, maintenance and depreciation rates, payload-to-energy ratio, time-window penalties, service coverage, population density, labor cost, battery charging/replacement, insurance, regulatory compliance, facility operation)

  • Large investment cost in drone fleets, depots, charging stations, and operating systems

  • Adopting a “system-thinking” approach for cost estimation

  • Sharing drones across multiple warehouses (via “sharing economy” schemes)

  • Operating drones with autonomous ground vehicles

  • Syncing drones with trucks along delivery routes

Applicability
  • Increasing flexibility by offering a variety of truck-drone configurations (Figure 8)

  • Lowering traffic congestions, transport cost, and emissions through distributing loads between drones and trucks

  • Enabling senders to choose suitable delivery configurations based on the LMD context at hand (e.g. trucks carrying drones to furthest launch points for humanitarian missions)

  • Challenge in selecting the right truck-drone configuration as it relies on several factors (e.g. cost, urgency of delivery, existent infrastructure)

  • Need of capital to invest in truck-drone fleets, their operating systems, and associated depots

  • Lack of policies to guide structuring warehouses, fleets, inventory allocation, and battery management

  • Deficient infrastructure to accommodate drone-truck setups

  • Utilizing deep learning (e.g. Q-learning) to aid the selection between drones and trucks

  • Selecting multiple truck-drone configurations to optimize the LMD process

  • Adopting airborne fulfillment centers (“flying warehouses”) to reduce dependency on land infrastructure

Capacity
  • Drones' flying capacity enables avoiding buildings, traffic, rivers, and other geographical/physical barriers

  • Improving LMD's overall capacity (e.g. speed, range, accessibility, payload) when combined with trucks

  • Enabling utilizing the capacity of each delivery mode (e.g. drones: reaching inaccessible zones; trucks: carrying heavier loads)

  • Limited capacity of drones (in terms of travel range, speed, battery, payload, and extreme weather resistance)

  • Difficulty in balancing between competing capacity tradeoffs (e.g. speed vs travel range, travel range vs battery capacity, battery capacity vs payload)

  • Meticulous planning requirements for boosting capacity (e.g. charging consumes times, replacing batteries demands human access)

  • Operating in tandem with trucks

  • Deploying battery charging/swapping points (or docking stations) along routes

  • Charging on trucks carrying drones

  • Hitchhiking on private/public vehicles

  • Scheduling deliveries based on drones' capacity

  • Adopting airborne fulfillment centers (“flying warehouses”)

  • Having multiple drones carry the payload

  • Equipping drones with multiple propellers or mini jet engines

Receivers
Time
  • Reaching 60–79% reductions in delivery time compared to conventional delivery methods

  • Drones' ability to avoid barriers (e.g. buildings, traffic, rivers) facilitates time reductions

  • Achieving time reductions is possible using drones only or in combination with trucks

  • Delivering vital items (e.g. blood products, organs, vaccines, drugs) to those in need in record time

  • Attaining substantial health benefits and success rates of urgent missions through speedy deliveries

  • Enhancing customer satisfaction in e-commerce by speedy deliveries (especially for consumables such as food)

  • Shortening delivery times requires operating dedicated drones for individual orders (which can increase LMD cost by increasing the number of drones and delivery centers)

  • Drones' limited payload/battery capacity can restrict time-savings to light-weight items and nearby receivers

  • Difficulty in balancing between several variables to achieve optimal time reductions (e.g. travel distance, weather conditions, geographical coverage, item's weight, drone's capacity)

  • Using simultaneous pick-up and delivery setups to reduce time and cost

  • Sharing workloads among drones based on their capacities

  • Allotting deliveries between drones and trucks

  • Using relaxed/strict delivery time slots based on item perishability and urgency of delivery

  • Applying penalty charges for exceeding delivery time slots to warrant arriving on time

Reach
  • Drones can skip physical barriers (e.g. mountains, hurricanes, poor transport infrastructure) to reach receivers in hard-to-access zones

  • Drones' reach potential can be enhanced in drone-only deliveries and drone-truck setups

  • If supplied with the right tools (e.g. AI), drones hold potentials to deliver to unknown delivery points

  • Limited applications in urban areas due to deficient landing space (especially amid high-rise buildings)

  • Restricted flights to rural areas to avoid interfering with other aircrafts or creating risks to residents

  • Most countries limit drone flights to VLOS zones (hence creating a need for human intervention)

  • Inability to reach people within no-fly-zones (e.g. near airports)

  • Installing “common delivery zones” in urban areas

  • Utilizing algorithms to reach receivers between no-fly-zones

  • Using different landing (on, e.g. ground, balconies, rooftops) and drop-off methods (by, e.g. cable, parachute) to increase accessibility

  • Supplying drones with AI, zooming and thermographic cameras to increase reach capacity

  • Equipping drones with fiducial markers, satellite/street imaging and precision drop algorithms to enhance accuracy

Item condition
  • Preserving items from perishability due to substantial savings in delivery time (especially medical items)

  • Ability to provide and monitor special temperature requirements using box attachments

  • Lowering wastage of medical items

  • Risk of damaging items due to drones' airborne maneuvers

  • Preservation remains limited to small/lightweight items due to drones' limited payload/battery capacity and restricting policies

  • Need to deliver close to depots for time-sensitive items

  • Placing items in reinforced boxes to lower damage risk

  • Using wet/dry ice, polystyrene foams and pre-calibrated thermal packs to maintain temperature requirements

  • Utilizing quick-release systems to expedite item detachments for time-sensitive deliveries

  • Using smart capsules with sensors for live monitoring of carried items

Regulators
Policies
  • Governing the airspace and reconciling competing interests

  • Ensuring safe drone operations (through specifying altitudes, proximity to people/property, maximum weight, flight zones, etc.)

  • Protecting privacy of individuals through laws for data collection and data use

  • Standardizing drone guidelines across operational, technical, infrastructural, risk, safety and environmental issues

  • Promoting innovations and investments in drones for LMD

  • Policies steered independently in each country (creating dissimilar/conflicting rules)

  • Drone registration processes can get tedious

  • Restricted drone flights to certain zones (e.g. VLOS) limits their utility

  • Difficulty in sponsoring overarching infrastructures (with comprehensive laws, UAV-dedicated frequencies, etc.)

  • Challenge in resolving competing interests of involved parties

  • Loopholes in current laws to accommodate drone deliveries

  • The EU passed a uniform set of rules across its 27 states to streamline drone delivery guidelines

  • The FAA started granting commercial companies licenses to operate drone deliveries in the US

  • Many countries (e.g. US, UK, China, Australia, Rwanda) are relaxing their aviation policies to accommodate drone deliveries over their territories

Infrastructure
  • Incubating drone deliveries by integrating live data into holistic transport systems (e.g. airborne traffic, number of people/objects on ground, geofences, physical obstacles, weather forecasts)

  • Promoting safe and collision-free drone operations through utilizing data transmitted by drones and surrounding objects

  • Ensuring uninterrupted drone-to-drone and drone-to-pilot communications

  • Instituting fairness to all parties involved

  • Challenge in expanding UAV-dedicated frequencies across large areas of land

  • Difficulty in maintaining uninterrupted signals in complex environments with high interferences

  • Challenge in gathering and streamlining live data from all involved units (e.g. drone operators, airports, weather forecast centers, satellites, etc.)

  • Most cities' infrastructures are unprepared to accommodate drone deliveries

  • Having drones act as a means of delivery and data transmission simultaneously

  • In absence of signal: utilizing deep learning to aid drones auto allocate deliveries using visual information

  • Adopting pre-flight conflict detection and resolution systems

  • Sponsoring the adoption of digitized automated control systems (e.g. UTM, U-Space)

Public acceptance
  • Supporting and expediting drone adoption in LMD (especially for urgent applications such as medical deliveries)

  • Shedding light on critical considerations such as safety, privacy, security, sustainability and usefulness

  • Needed to circumvent chaos upon launch

  • Public skepticism about the need for the technology and its usefulness

  • Safety, privacy and noise pollution concerns are voiced extensively by the public (especially in urban areas)

  • Challenge in alleviating the “stigma” of drones after misguided military applications

  • Drivers' fear of losing their jobs to the technology

  • Defining clear guidelines and codes of ethics

  • Enforcing strict aviation safety measures

  • Educating and training pilots

  • Applying stringent violation penalties

  • Familiarizing the public with drones' usefulness via various channels (e.g. word of mouth, marketing campaigns, TV/radio channels)

Societies
Safety
  • Minimizing road accidents by substituting traditional delivery vehicles

  • Reducing health risks from air- and noise pollution associated with traditional vehicles

  • Enabling “contactless” deliveries to limit spread of disease

  • Saving lives of patients/endangered persons due to substantial savings in delivery times

  • Preserving delivered items from theft, loss, or damage

  • Creating physical/mental stress to societies through overcrowding the airspace

  • Accidents can happen both in-flight (drone crash; package falling) and take-off/landing events (exposed propellers; drone crash)

  • Drone accidents can harm people, animals and objects

  • Intensified safety risks in urban areas (esp. at lower altitudes)

  • Susceptibility to communication interference, computer disturbances, operator errors and drone component failures

  • Equipping drones with redundant systems (e.g. additional motors, sensors) to avoid accidents

  • Adopting collision free paths based on space congestion and battery status

  • Utilizing deep learning to allocate safe landing spots based on remaining battery level

  • Installing event-based emergency detection systems

  • Ordaining dedicated airways and standardized routing protocols

Privacy
  • Drones' recording of videos and images of public areas during flights could help preventing crime and reducing reliance on potentially more intrusive surveillance methods (e.g. police patrols, fixed cameras)

  • Using drones in rescue missions can lower the need for potentially more intrusive search methods (e.g. helicopters, dogs)

  • Drones capture large amount of data (e.g. locations, identities), posing privacy concerns if shared with third parties without their consent

  • Capturing videos and images via drones' cameras can make them a means of undesired surveillance to people and their private space

  • Risk of accessing, stealing, or tampering with drones' collected data by malicious actors through cyberattacks

  • Operating drones in LMD might violate laws that prohibit recording the interiors of private property

  • Adopting secure data-encryption methods (e.g. blockchain) for drone-related transactions

  • Giving landowners the rights to allow, lease, or prohibit drones from entering their private airspace (especially at low altitudes)

  • Incorporating the case of drone deliveries under national privacy laws (e.g. Data Protection Act, GDPR)

Environment
  • Relieving traffic congestion and emissions through substituting traditional vehicles

  • Reducing air- and noise pollution associated with traditional vehicles

  • Lowering CO2 emissions due to drones' reliance on electric batteries

  • Reducing energy consumption due to drones' light weight

  • Most promising environmental performance in rural areas

  • Challenge to lower emissions in urban areas due to stricter policies, circumventing buildings, need for depots and higher receiver density

  • Drones' limited payload/battery capacity make them always in need of traditional vehicles (along with their emissions)

  • Tradeoffs between lowering CO2 emissions and costs (in terms of, e.g. equipment, charging, insurance)

  • High energy consumption during drones' production phase

  • Drones can interfere with wildlife (especially birds)

  • Emitting debris from potential drone collisions

  • Installing depots closer to receivers in urban areas to increase environmental friendliness

  • Lowering number of stops the drones make

  • Relying on clean energy courses (e.g. solar, wind) for charging drones

  • Operating drones through underground subways to alleviate environmental challenges in urban areas

  • Integrating drones with (electric) trucks in LMD

Source(s): Created by authors

or Create an Account

Close subscription notice
Close access options