Table 5 Outcomes of hypothesis testing... | Emerald Publishing

Table 5

Outcomes of hypothesis testing

Hypothesis		Estimate (path coefficient)	p value	Supported (Yes/No/Partial)	Comparative findings	Contrasting findings
H1a	SC visibility → SC Resilience	0.163	0.003*	Yes	Dubey et al. (2017)
H2a	SC flexibility → SC Resilience	0.216	0.005*	Yes	Piprani et al. (2022)
H3a	SC collaboration → SC Resilience	0.197	0.010*	Yes	Belhadi et al. (2021)
H4a	SC Control → SC Resilience	0.165	0.025*	Yes	Gupta et al. (2022)
H5a	SC Circularity → SC Resilience	0.022	0.716	No		Zhang et al. (2021)
H6a	SC Network Design → SC Resilience	0.097	0.070*	Yes	Aman and Seuring (2023)
H7a	SC Digitalisation → SC Resilience	0.187	0.007*	Yes	Shi et al. (2023)
H1b	SC Visibility → SC Sustainability Performance	0.156	0.019*	Yes	Dubey et al. (2019)
H2b	SC Flexibility → SC Sustainability Performance	−0.007	0.940	No		Edwin Cheng et al. (2022)
H3b	SC Collaboration → SC Sustainability Performance	0.462	***	Yes	Nayal et al. (2022)
H4b	SC Control → SC Sustainability Performance	0.027	0.755	No		Hamprecht et al. (2005)
H5b	SC Circularity → SC Sustainability Performance	0.138	0.057*	Yes	Le (2023)
H6b	SC Network Design → SC Sustainability Performance	−0.127	0.046*	Partial	Joshi (2022)
H7b	SC Digitalisation → SC Sustainability Performance	−0.117	0.156	No		Oubrahim et al. (2023)
H8	SC Resilience → SC Sustainability Performance	0.291	***	Yes	Shan et al., (2023), Zhu and Wu (2022)

Hypothesis		Estimate (path coefficient)	p value	Supported (Yes/No/Partial)	Comparative findings	Contrasting findings
H1a	SC visibility → SC Resilience	0.163	0.003*	Yes	Dubey et al. (2017)
H2a	SC flexibility → SC Resilience	0.216	0.005*	Yes	Piprani et al. (2022)
H3a	SC collaboration → SC Resilience	0.197	0.010*	Yes	Belhadi et al. (2021)
H4a	SC Control → SC Resilience	0.165	0.025*	Yes	Gupta et al. (2022)
H5a	SC Circularity → SC Resilience	0.022	0.716	No		Zhang et al. (2021)
H6a	SC Network Design → SC Resilience	0.097	0.070*	Yes	Aman and Seuring (2023)
H7a	SC Digitalisation → SC Resilience	0.187	0.007*	Yes	Shi et al. (2023)
H1b	SC Visibility → SC Sustainability Performance	0.156	0.019*	Yes	Dubey et al. (2019)
H2b	SC Flexibility → SC Sustainability Performance	−0.007	0.940	No		Edwin Cheng et al. (2022)
H3b	SC Collaboration → SC Sustainability Performance	0.462	***	Yes	Nayal et al. (2022)
H4b	SC Control → SC Sustainability Performance	0.027	0.755	No		Hamprecht et al. (2005)
H5b	SC Circularity → SC Sustainability Performance	0.138	0.057*	Yes	Le (2023)
H6b	SC Network Design → SC Sustainability Performance	−0.127	0.046*	Partial	Joshi (2022)
H7b	SC Digitalisation → SC Sustainability Performance	−0.117	0.156	No		Oubrahim et al. (2023)
H8	SC Resilience → SC Sustainability Performance	0.291	***	Yes	Shan et al., (2023), Zhu and Wu (2022)

Source(s): Authors’ own creation