Table 1

Comparison of Three Automatic Essay Scoring Programs

Mi Write:Pro Writing AidPaper Rater
Overallscore/30 (e.g., 24.2)Score/100Percentage and letter grade (e.g., 87 B)
Age/grade of writerCan select grade bands (e.g., 7–8) of writerNo age/grade indicationCan select specific grade/education level of writer
Program organization6 sections, 5 points per section, bar graph scores followed by written feedback/suggestions for each sectionList of information to scroll through; combination of written, statistical, and visual feedback (charts)9 sections, combination of written and visual feedback
Kinds of information providedBased on 6 traits:
  • Development of Ideas

  • Organization

  • Style

  • Word Choice

  • Sentence Fluency

  • Conventions

  • Scores: Overall, grammar, spelling, style, terminology

  • Document Statistics: words, sentences, paragraphs, characters

  • Key actions to take for the paper overall

  • Vocabulary: List of unique words, word families, most used words

  • Readability measures: Flesch Reading Ease, Flesh-Kincaid Grade, Coleman-Liau, automated reading index, Dale-Chall Grade, readability by paragraph

  • Overused words

  • Sentence structure: Sentence variety, sentence length, long sentence

  • Writing style: passive index, hidden verbs, adverbs, repeated sentence starts, style suggestions

  • Grammar and spelling issues

  • Sticky sentences (contain too many common words)

  • Dialogue

  • Pacing

  • Transitions

  • Repeated phrases

  • Cliches and redundancies

  • Consistency (spelling, hyphenation, & capitalization)

  • Spelling (list of words misspelled with suggestions)

  • Grammar (list of words with suggestions)

  • Word choice (words underlined with possible suggestions)

  • Usage of bad phrases (identification of use of words and phrases to be avoided)

  • Usage of transitional phrases (score based on the quality of transitional phrases used within the paper and comparison to people in similar educational level)

  • Style: total sentences (number), average length (number of words per), short sentences (count and percentage), long sentences (count and percentage), sentence variation (count)

  • Passive voice (percentage and listing of sentences that have passive voice)

  • Sentence beginnings: Simple sentence starts (percentage and comparison to people in similar education level; identifies examples within the writing)

  • Vocabulary: Use of academic vocabulary (score and comparison percentage to others at similar education levels), vocabulary word count (#), percentage of vocabulary words, listing of vocabulary works in the paper

AccessPaid subscription; websiteFree Google add-on (premium paid version available)Free website (premium paid version available)

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal