Table 7 Summary of key findings Aspect... | Emerald Publishing

Table 7

Summary of key findings

Aspect	ChatGPT	Gamma	Autopilot
Ease of use	Highest rated; intuitive and user-friendly	More complex; lowest ease of use	Moderate; simple but limited in scope
Accuracy	Mixed results; sometimes less precise	Strongest in accuracy; multiple output options	Moderate; less precise than Gamma
Citation adherence	Weak; frequent APA-style errors	Limited; incomplete citations	Weak; minimal adherence
Arabic language handling	Struggled significantly with Arabic	Better performance with Arabic	Moderate handling of Arabic
Time/effort savings	Significant time savings reported	Effective but restricted by the free version limits	Significant time savings
Multimedia integration	Supports images/templates	Strong multimedia features	Very limited (primarily text-based)
Overall student view	Easy to use but unreliable for citations	Accurate and effective but less flexible to use	Simple and useful but less flexible

Aspect	ChatGPT	Gamma	Autopilot
Ease of use	Highest rated; intuitive and user-friendly	More complex; lowest ease of use	Moderate; simple but limited in scope
Accuracy	Mixed results; sometimes less precise	Strongest in accuracy; multiple output options	Moderate; less precise than Gamma
Citation adherence	Weak; frequent APA-style errors	Limited; incomplete citations	Weak; minimal adherence
Arabic language handling	Struggled significantly with Arabic	Better performance with Arabic	Moderate handling of Arabic
Time/effort savings	Significant time savings reported	Effective but restricted by the free version limits	Significant time savings
Multimedia integration	Supports images/templates	Strong multimedia features	Very limited (primarily text-based)
Overall student view	Easy to use but unreliable for citations	Accurate and effective but less flexible to use	Simple and useful but less flexible