Table 1

Reviewed AI maturity models

AuthorsName/AcronymDomainLevelsElementsDescription of elements/LevelsAssessment methodStudy groupDesign approachModel type
Alsheiabni et al. (2019) NoneGeneral5 (Initial, Assessing, Determined, Managed, Optimized)4 (AI Functions, Data Structure, People, Organizational)BriefNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Yablonsky (2019) Data-Driven AI Innovation Maturity FrameworkInnovation Management5 (Human Led; Human Led, Machine Supported; Machine Led, Human Supported; Machine Led, Human Governed; Machine Led and Machine Governed)4 (Who produces insight, Who decides and how, Who acts based on decision, Advanced analytics)DetailedNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Ellefsen et al. (2019) NoneLogistic Processes4 (AI Novice; AI Ready; AI Proficient; AI Advanced)5 (Strategy, Organization, Data, Technology, Operations)BriefQuestionnaireFour logistics sector companiesAdopted organizational modelDescriptive
Lichtenthaler (2020) NoneGeneral (AI Management)5 (Initial Intent, Independent Initiative, Interactive Implementation, Interdependent Innovation, Integrated Intelligence) or 7 (adding Level 0: Isolated Ignorance and Level +: Intuitive Ingenuity)3 (different types of AI, different types of human intelligence, meta-intelligence combining different types of intelligence)BriefNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Fukas et al. (2021) Auditing AI Maturity Model (A-AIMM)Auditing Firms5 (Initial, Assessing, Determined, Managed, Optimized)8 (Technologies, Data, People and Competencies, Organization and Processes, Strategy and Management, Budget, Products and Services, Ethics and Regulations)DetailedNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Yams et al. (2021) AI Innovation Maturity Index (AIMI)Innovation Management5 (Foundational, Experimenting, Operational, Inquiring, Integrated)7 (Data, Technology, Organization, Strategy, Ecosystems, Mindsets, Trustworthiness)BriefNoneNoneTop-downDescriptive
Holmström (2021) AI Readiness FrameworkGeneral5 (None, Low, Moderate, High, Excellent)4 (Technology, Activities, Boundaries, Goals)BriefQuestionnaireInsurance sector companyBottom-upDescriptive
Schuster et al. (2021) SME-focused AIMMSmall and Medium Enterprises5 (Novice, Explorer, User, Translator, Pioneer)7 (Culture, Data, Ethics, Organization, Privacy, Strategy, Technology)BriefNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Chen et al. (2021) I-AI Maturity ModelIntelligent Manufacturing Systems and Industrial Processes5 (Planning Level, Specification Level, Integration Level, Optimization Level, Leading Level)2 (Industry, AI)Very detailedQuestionnaireNoneBottom-upPartially prescriptive
Noymanee et al. (2022) AI MM for Government Administration and ServiceGovernment and Public Sector Organizations5 (Rookie Level, Beginner Level, Operational Level, Expert Level, Mastery Level)4 (Strategy, Organization, Information, Technology)BriefNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Das et al. (2023) Trustworthy AI System MM (TAS-MM)General4 (Level 0, Level 1, Level 2, Level 3)4 (Auditability, Explainability, Fairness, Safety)DetailedNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Sonntag et al. (2024) SMMT Maturity ModelManufacturing Sector Companies5 (Initial, Experimental, Practicing, Integrated, Transformed)5 (Culture and Competencies, Strategy, Data, Organization and Processes, Technology)DetailedQuestionnaireThree divisions of one manufacturing companyBottom-upPartially prescriptive
Chukhlomin (2024) EMERALD-GenAI-CMM-OALOnline Education and Adult Learning5 (Pre-generative AI Level, Foundational Level, Intermediate Level, Advanced Level, Expert Level)5 ((E) External Environment and Graduate Skill Expectations (M) Technological Means, Tools and Platforms (examples) (E) Essential Tasks and Use Cases (RA) Required Abilities, Skills, and Competencies (LD) Learning Designs and Strategies)DetailedNoneNoneBottom-upDescriptive
Source(s): Authors’ own work

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal