Methods used in AI-driven hospitality personalization
| Document | Sample area | Period of study | Sample size | Sampling techniques | Methods/techniques |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lin et al. (2025) Study 1 | Instagram posts tagged with Saguaro National Park | Collected March 2022– March 2023 | 14,906 | Preprocessed using LIWC-22 for keyword frequency and tone scoring | |
| Study 2 | U.S. adults (18+ years) who visited a natural area in the past 12 months | 2023 | 400 surveyed → 357 valid responses | Prolific (using demographic balancing) | Fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) |
| Chen et al. (2025) | Social media posts from Xiaohongshu and Dianping, using hashtags like #HongKongTravel, #HongKongTour | February 28, 2018, to October 18, 2023 | 10,261 | UGC (user-generated content) collected via octopus collector and python scraping | Python (octopus collector, jieba), PaddlePaddle (deep learning), BERT embeddings, K-means, TF-IDF, dynamic McKinsey matrix modeling |
| Mahmoud et al. (2024) | Social media comments scraped (Reddit, TikTok, YouTube) → filtered down to 2,650 high-quality, English-language, nonduplicate comments | January- 2020-December 2022 | 15,461 | Big-data, nonprobabilistic | Python (scraping, VADER sentiment), NVivo (qualitative coding), matplotlib (visuals) |
| Pitakaso et al. (2025) | Thailand: case study in Ubon Ratchathani Province | NA | 316 hotel guests, 16 chambermaids, five managers | Case study-based purposive sampling in a real-world hotel environment | AI framework: Artificial multiple intelligence system (AMIS) combining GA, DE, PSO, ACO, and VaNSAS to solve a multi-objective scheduling problem |
| Mensah et al. (2025) | 10 most popular African destinations (e.g. Nairobi, Marrakesh, Cape Town, Arusha) | August 2018 – August 2023 | 5,043 Tripadvisor reviews | Purposeful selection of top-ranked destinations based on Tripadvisor Travelers’ Choice (2023) | Quantitative sentiment analysis using python, TextBlob, pandas, and seaborn. Keyword frequency analysis. Content analysis using tourist reviews for theme generation |
| Zhang et al. (2025) | TripAdvisor, Houston, Texas market | Sep-23 | 32,129 hotel reviews with managerial responses | Purposive sampling (only reviews with hotel staff responses were selected | GPT-3.5 response generation (Temp 0,1,2), BERT-based cosine similarity, t-SNE visualization, Negative Binomial Regression |
| Tan et al. (2025) | Chengdu, China (6 districts) | January 2014 – January 2023 | 23,138 valid reviews from 243 stores | Random selection of stores; exclusion of manipulated/incomplete reviews | Web scraping, sentiment analysis (dictionary + bayesian model), fsQCA (fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis), machine learning |
| Yi et al. (2024) | AI-themed hotels in China (12 hotels across seven brands) | Jun-22 | 7,431 online customer reviews | Purposive sampling (based on hotel names and descriptions explicitly referencing AI) | Topic modeling (LDA), fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) |
| Guidotti et al. (2025) | European castles, U.S. hotels, global restaurants (from Google reviews) | Not explicitly mentioned (datasets are pre-existing from Kaggle) | 13,650 reviews (2,550 castles, 1,100 restaurants, 10,000 hotels) | Purposive sampling (publicly available datasets selected for tourism context) | Zero-shot learning with LLMs (DeBERTa, RoBERTa, BART); Sentiment analysis; Keyword extraction; NLI-based prompting; Statistical analysis (accuracy, precision, recall, F1, IQR, median) |
| Félix et al. (2025) | TripAdvisor reviews from users worldwide (seeded from 5 cities: Tiradentes, Ouro Preto, San Gimignano, Cannes, Ibiza) | October 2001 to May 2020 | 420,987 labeled English reviews (from 65,812 users, 29,176 cities) | Snowball sampling starting from seed cities | Text classification using ML (Logistic Regression, LGBM), Transformers (BERT, RoBERTa, BART), LLMs (LLama2, Bloom); TF-IDF, contextual embeddings, domain-specific feature extraction |
| Kirilenko and Stepchenkova (2025) | TripAdvisor (arenal and corcovado), YouTube (Li Ziqi videos), Weibo (Li Ziqi posts) | 2011–2022 | ∼26,000+ user-generated documents (6 datasets) | Purposive sampling of tourism-related UGC from 3 platforms | Topic modeling using LDA (sklearn), BERTopic (MiniLM), and GPT-4 (OpenAI API); Manual validation and comparative analysis across five performance dimensions |
| Anguera-Torrell and Nicolau (2025) | Barcelona, Spain | 2018–2022 | 22,326 reservations | Purposive sampling (hotel bookings via booking.com) | Linear probability model (LPM), logit and probit models, interaction analysis, fixed effects regression |
| Chotisarn and Phuthong (2025) | Western Thailand’s coastal tourism destinations | August–September 2024 | 186 | Purposive sampling | PLS-SEM (SmartPLS 4), Descriptive Statistics (SPSS 27), Harman’s single-factor test |
| Kourtit et al. (2025) | London | Pre-COVID and during-COVID | 458,078 Airbnb + 20,417 hotel reviews | Listings with ≥10 reviews per period | Text Analysis, Sentiment Analysis (sentimentr in R), Multilevel Analysis (3-level), Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR) |
| Piriyakul et al. (2024) | Amari Phuket hotel, Thailand | Year 2022 | 250 customer reviews (randomly selected from TripAdvisor) | Random sampling from publicly available review data | Text mining, sentiment analysis, K-Means clustering, naive bayes, SEM (structural equation modeling) |
| Yu et al. (2024) | Sichuan province, China | Reviews collected from 2012 to 2023 across platforms | 1,003,501 valid reviews from Meituan + 1,596,398 texts from Sogou News, Wikipedia, Ctrip | Purposive filtering of hospitality-related content and de-duplication | Dictionary-based Sentiment Analysis, Word2Vec, HowNet Similarity, Manual Validation |
| Li et al. (2024) | 5 cities in China (Beijing, Shanghai, Hangzhou, Shenzhen, Chengdu) | Not explicitly mentioned (data from Dianping.com up to 2023) | 67,060 reviews collected; 1,994 reviews manually analyzed | Purposeful selection of spacelab restaurant chains | Text mining (ROST CM), Co-word clustering (gephi), sentiment analysis (SnowNLP), logistic regression |
| Blanco-Moreno et al. (2024) | Camino de Santiago (UNESCO WHS) | 2010–2022 | 27,088 posts | Web scraping (targeted sampling) | AI-based content analysis (ML for text, DL for images), generalized linear model (UGLM) |
| Camatti et al. (2025) | Venice, Italy (15 fortress sites) | Early 2024 | 15 fortresses; 2 expert groups (GE1 and GE2); 40 experts in GE2 | Purposive sampling of experts (academics, planners, community stakeholders) | Fuzzy expert systems (FES), Self-Organizing maps (SOM), MCDA |
| Firza et al. (2024) | Italian provinces | 2004–2020 | 107 provinces | Census | Canonical correlation analysis (CCA), fuzzy C-Means clustering (FCM), random Forest classification (supervised ML), SHAP (XAI) |
| Gupta and Jaiswal (2024) | Online hotel review platforms | Not explicitly mentioned | 23,806 reviews | Web scraping | TextBlob and VADER LDA, GSDMM (gibbs sampling dirichlet mixture model), logistic regression, naïve bayes, random Forest, AdaBoost, SVM, neural networks |
| Document | Sample area | Period of study | Sample size | Sampling techniques | Methods/techniques |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instagram posts tagged with Saguaro National Park | Collected March 2022– March 2023 | 14,906 | Preprocessed using LIWC-22 for keyword frequency and tone scoring | ||
| Study 2 | U.S. adults (18+ years) who visited a natural area in the past 12 months | 2023 | 400 surveyed → 357 valid responses | Prolific (using demographic balancing) | Fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) |
| Social media posts from Xiaohongshu and Dianping, using hashtags like #HongKongTravel, #HongKongTour | February 28, 2018, to October 18, 2023 | 10,261 | Python (octopus collector, jieba), PaddlePaddle (deep learning), | ||
| Social media comments scraped (Reddit, TikTok, YouTube) → filtered down to 2,650 high-quality, English-language, nonduplicate comments | January- 2020-December 2022 | 15,461 | Big-data, nonprobabilistic | Python (scraping, | |
| Thailand: case study in Ubon Ratchathani Province | 316 hotel guests, 16 chambermaids, five managers | Case study-based purposive sampling in a real-world hotel environment | |||
| 10 most popular African destinations (e.g. Nairobi, Marrakesh, Cape Town, Arusha) | August 2018 – August 2023 | 5,043 Tripadvisor reviews | Purposeful selection of top-ranked destinations based on Tripadvisor Travelers’ Choice (2023) | Quantitative sentiment analysis using python, TextBlob, pandas, and seaborn. Keyword frequency analysis. Content analysis using tourist reviews for theme generation | |
| TripAdvisor, Houston, Texas market | Sep-23 | 32,129 hotel reviews with managerial responses | Purposive sampling (only reviews with hotel staff responses were selected | GPT-3.5 response generation (Temp 0,1,2), BERT-based cosine similarity, t-SNE visualization, Negative Binomial Regression | |
| Chengdu, China (6 districts) | January 2014 – January 2023 | 23,138 valid reviews from 243 stores | Random selection of stores; exclusion of manipulated/incomplete reviews | Web scraping, sentiment analysis (dictionary + bayesian model), fsQCA (fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis), machine learning | |
| AI-themed hotels in China (12 hotels across seven brands) | Jun-22 | 7,431 online customer reviews | Purposive sampling (based on hotel names and descriptions explicitly referencing | Topic modeling ( | |
| European castles, U.S. hotels, global restaurants (from Google reviews) | Not explicitly mentioned (datasets are pre-existing from Kaggle) | 13,650 reviews (2,550 castles, 1,100 restaurants, 10,000 hotels) | Purposive sampling (publicly available datasets selected for tourism context) | Zero-shot learning with LLMs (DeBERTa, RoBERTa, | |
| TripAdvisor reviews from users worldwide (seeded from 5 cities: Tiradentes, Ouro Preto, San Gimignano, Cannes, Ibiza) | October 2001 to May 2020 | 420,987 labeled English reviews (from 65,812 users, 29,176 cities) | Snowball sampling starting from seed cities | Text classification using | |
| TripAdvisor (arenal and corcovado), YouTube (Li Ziqi videos), Weibo (Li Ziqi posts) | 2011–2022 | ∼26,000+ user-generated documents (6 datasets) | Purposive sampling of tourism-related | Topic modeling using | |
| Barcelona, Spain | 2018–2022 | 22,326 reservations | Purposive sampling (hotel bookings via booking.com) | Linear probability model ( | |
| Western Thailand’s coastal tourism destinations | August–September 2024 | 186 | Purposive sampling | PLS-SEM (SmartPLS 4), Descriptive Statistics ( | |
| London | Pre-COVID and during-COVID | 458,078 Airbnb + 20,417 hotel reviews | Listings with ≥10 reviews per period | Text Analysis, Sentiment Analysis (sentimentr in R), Multilevel Analysis (3-level), Geographically Weighted Regression ( | |
| Amari Phuket hotel, Thailand | Year 2022 | 250 customer reviews (randomly selected from TripAdvisor) | Random sampling from publicly available review data | Text mining, sentiment analysis, K-Means clustering, naive bayes, | |
| Sichuan province, China | Reviews collected from 2012 to 2023 across platforms | 1,003,501 valid reviews from Meituan + 1,596,398 texts from Sogou News, Wikipedia, Ctrip | Purposive filtering of hospitality-related content and de-duplication | Dictionary-based Sentiment Analysis, Word2Vec, HowNet Similarity, Manual Validation | |
| 5 cities in China (Beijing, Shanghai, Hangzhou, Shenzhen, Chengdu) | Not explicitly mentioned (data from Dianping.com up to 2023) | 67,060 reviews collected; 1,994 reviews manually analyzed | Purposeful selection of spacelab restaurant chains | Text mining ( | |
| Camino de Santiago ( | 2010–2022 | 27,088 posts | Web scraping (targeted sampling) | AI-based content analysis ( | |
| Venice, Italy (15 fortress sites) | Early 2024 | 15 fortresses; 2 expert groups (GE1 and GE2); 40 experts in GE2 | Purposive sampling of experts (academics, planners, community stakeholders) | Fuzzy expert systems ( | |
| Italian provinces | 2004–2020 | 107 provinces | Census | Canonical correlation analysis ( | |
| Online hotel review platforms | Not explicitly mentioned | 23,806 reviews | Web scraping | TextBlob and |
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.