Table 2 Concept matrix including the...

Table 2

Concept matrix including the type of coPM, the evaluation data, the investigated process, and the data acquisition description

Source	E	C	Evaluation data			Type of process analyzed or used for evaluation	Description of data acquisition
Source	E	C	A	R	Origin	Type of process analyzed or used for evaluation	Description of data acquisition
Mans et al. (2008)	X			X	Italian hospitals	Handling of stroke patients	Yes (Electronic clinical chart + interviews)
Gerke et al. (2009a)		X	X		Car manufacturer	Make-to-order production process
Ho et al. (2009)		X		X	Not stated if the data is cross-organizational	Manufacturing process	–
Sun et al. (2011)		X	X		–	Product packaging process	–
Buijs et al. (2012b)	X			X	Dutch municipalities	Building permits process + Handling citizen complaints on housing tax process	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Engel et al. (2012)		X		X	Automotive supplier company	Purchase order process + supply chain management process	–
Rozsnyai et al. (2012)	X	X	X		–	Order to cash process
Buijs et al. (2013)	X			X	Dutch municipalities	Building permits process (Real)	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Engel et al. (2013a)		X		X	Austrian consumer goods company	Purchase order process	–
Zeng et al. (2013)		X	X		Multi-modal transportation Hospital	Multi-modal transportation process Health care process	–
Bernardi et al. (2014)	X		X		Dutch municipalities	Acknowledging an unborn child process	–
Buijs and Reijers (2014)	X			X	Dutch municipalities	Building permits process	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Claes and Poels (2014)	Establishes pre-conditions		X	X	No cross-organizational data. A: Accounting and warehouse software for order handling R: Volvo, Ghent University	Order handling (A), call center support process (artificially divided real) Factory and customer orders (R) Payroll process (R)	Yes (provided by Volvo)
Engel and Bose (2014)		X		X	German consumer goods manufacturing company	Process of ordering, dispatching, and invoicing of goods	–
Krathu et al. (2014)		X		X	Beverage manufacturing company	Purchasing process
Suriadi et al. (2014)	X			X	Australian hospitals	Health care process (Patients with chest pain symptoms)	Yes (central repository in each clinic)
Partington et al. (2015)	X			X	Australian hospitals	Health care process (Patients with chest pain symptoms)	Yes (central repository in each clinic)
Pini et al. (2015)	X			X	Australian hospitals
Talamo et al. (2015)		X		X	–	IT services (Help desk process)	–
Yilmaz and Senkul (2015)	X		X	X	Dutch municipalities	(A) Loan application process (R) Environmental Permit Application Process	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Aksu et al. (2016)	X			X	ERP Software vendor (But data not described and shown)	Sales process	Yes
Engel et al. (2016)		X		X	German consumer goods manufacturing company	Delivery process	–
Pourmasoumi et al. (2017)	X		X	X	–	Purchase order process + generic process	Yes (IBM BIT library)
Bernardi et al. (2018)	X			X	Online shops	Online products selling process	–
Wang et al. (2018)		X	X	X	A: R: Manufacturer in electronic equipment (no cross-organizational data)	A: Supply chain process R: Customs supervision	–
Canjels et al. (2019)		X		X	Dutch hospitals	Care process of knee osteoarthritis patients	Yes (hospital information system; list)
Klinkmüller et al. (2019)		X		X	Crypto Kitty	Cat lifecycle process
Liu et al. (2019)		X	X		–	Multi-modal transportation process	–
Mühlberger et al. (2019)		X		X	–	Incident management process
Deokar and Tao (2020)		X		X	No cross-organizational data (Electronics company)	Repair process of phones	–
Elkoumy et al. (2020a)		X		X	(1) Car company (2) Dutch ban (3) Italian police office	(1) Incident and problem management (2) Credit card background check (3) Collection of payment fines	Yes (publicly available)
Kim et al. (2020)		X	X		Supply chain	Supply chain process	–
Liu (2020)		X	X	X	Dutch financial institute	Loan application process, Hotel booking process	Yes (Publicly available)
Zeng et al. (2020)		X	X		–	Multi-modal transportation process
González and Delgado (2021)		X			Exemplary real-world scenario without explicitly stating the data used (Uruguayan e-Government Interoperability Platform)	Passport application process
Hernandez-Resendiz et al. (2021)		X		X	Telecommunication industry	Purchase order process
Morales-Sandoval et al. (2021)		X	X		–	Supply chain process, Rehabilitation process, Incident management
van der Aalst (2021)		X		X	Italian information system managing road traffic fines	Road traffic fine management	Yes (Publicly available)
Corradini et al. (2022)		X	X		Hospital	Healthcare process	–
Liu et al. (2023a)		X		X	Hospital (Cross-department data)	Healthcare process	Yes (Publicly available)
Liu et al. (2023b)		X	X	X	A: R: Dutch financial institute, NASA	R: Loan application process, Hotel booking process, NASA Crew Exploration Vehicle Unit test process	Yes (Publicly available)
Rafiei and Van Der Aalst (2023)		X		X	Hospital (Cross-department data)	Healthcare process	Yes (Publicly available)
Tajima et al. (2023)		X		X	Dutch financial institute	Loan application process	Yes (Publicly available)

Source	E	C	Evaluation data			Type of process analyzed or used for evaluation	Description of data acquisition
Source	E	C	A	R	Origin	Type of process analyzed or used for evaluation	Description of data acquisition
Mans et al. (2008)	X			X	Italian hospitals	Handling of stroke patients	Yes (Electronic clinical chart + interviews)
Gerke et al. (2009a)		X	X		Car manufacturer	Make-to-order production process
Ho et al. (2009)		X		X	Not stated if the data is cross-organizational	Manufacturing process	–
Sun et al. (2011)		X	X		–	Product packaging process	–
Buijs et al. (2012b)	X			X	Dutch municipalities	Building permits process + Handling citizen complaints on housing tax process	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Engel et al. (2012)		X		X	Automotive supplier company	Purchase order process + supply chain management process	–
Rozsnyai et al. (2012)	X	X	X		–	Order to cash process
Buijs et al. (2013)	X			X	Dutch municipalities	Building permits process (Real)	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Engel et al. (2013a)		X		X	Austrian consumer goods company	Purchase order process	–
Zeng et al. (2013)		X	X		Multi-modal transportation Hospital	Multi-modal transportation process Health care process	–
Bernardi et al. (2014)	X		X		Dutch municipalities	Acknowledging an unborn child process	–
Buijs and Reijers (2014)	X			X	Dutch municipalities	Building permits process	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Claes and Poels (2014)	Establishes pre-conditions		X	X	No cross-organizational data. A: Accounting and warehouse software for order handling R: Volvo, Ghent University	Order handling (A), call center support process (artificially divided real) Factory and customer orders (R) Payroll process (R)	Yes (provided by Volvo)
Engel and Bose (2014)		X		X	German consumer goods manufacturing company	Process of ordering, dispatching, and invoicing of goods	–
Krathu et al. (2014)		X		X	Beverage manufacturing company	Purchasing process
Suriadi et al. (2014)	X			X	Australian hospitals	Health care process (Patients with chest pain symptoms)	Yes (central repository in each clinic)
Partington et al. (2015)	X			X	Australian hospitals	Health care process (Patients with chest pain symptoms)	Yes (central repository in each clinic)
Pini et al. (2015)	X			X	Australian hospitals
Talamo et al. (2015)		X		X	–	IT services (Help desk process)	–
Yilmaz and Senkul (2015)	X		X	X	Dutch municipalities	(A) Loan application process (R) Environmental Permit Application Process	- (Part of CoSeLog project)
Aksu et al. (2016)	X			X	ERP Software vendor (But data not described and shown)	Sales process	Yes
Engel et al. (2016)		X		X	German consumer goods manufacturing company	Delivery process	–
Pourmasoumi et al. (2017)	X		X	X	–	Purchase order process + generic process	Yes (IBM BIT library)
Bernardi et al. (2018)	X			X	Online shops	Online products selling process	–
Wang et al. (2018)		X	X	X	A: R: Manufacturer in electronic equipment (no cross-organizational data)	A: Supply chain processR: Customs supervision	–
Canjels et al. (2019)		X		X	Dutch hospitals	Care process of knee osteoarthritis patients	Yes (hospital information system; list)
Klinkmüller et al. (2019)		X		X	Crypto Kitty	Cat lifecycle process
Liu et al. (2019)		X	X		–	Multi-modal transportation process	–
Mühlberger et al. (2019)		X		X	–	Incident management process
Deokar and Tao (2020)		X		X	No cross-organizational data (Electronics company)	Repair process of phones	–
Elkoumy et al. (2020a)		X		X	(1) Car company(2) Dutch ban(3) Italian police office	(1) Incident and problem management(2) Credit card background check(3) Collection of payment fines	Yes (publicly available)
Kim et al. (2020)		X	X		Supply chain	Supply chain process	–
Liu (2020)		X	X	X	Dutch financial institute	Loan application process, Hotel booking process	Yes (Publicly available)
Zeng et al. (2020)		X	X		–	Multi-modal transportation process
González and Delgado (2021)		X			Exemplary real-world scenario without explicitly stating the data used (Uruguayan e-Government Interoperability Platform)	Passport application process
Hernandez-Resendiz et al. (2021)		X		X	Telecommunication industry	Purchase order process
Morales-Sandoval et al. (2021)		X	X		–	Supply chain process, Rehabilitation process, Incident management
van der Aalst (2021)		X		X	Italian information system managing road traffic fines	Road traffic fine management	Yes (Publicly available)
Corradini et al. (2022)		X	X		Hospital	Healthcare process	–
Liu et al. (2023a)		X		X	Hospital (Cross-department data)	Healthcare process	Yes (Publicly available)
Liu et al. (2023b)		X	X	X	A: R: Dutch financial institute, NASA	R: Loan application process, Hotel booking process, NASA Crew Exploration Vehicle Unit test process	Yes (Publicly available)
Rafiei and Van Der Aalst (2023)		X		X	Hospital (Cross-department data)	Healthcare process	Yes (Publicly available)
Tajima et al. (2023)		X		X	Dutch financial institute	Loan application process	Yes (Publicly available)

Note(s): E (Exploiting commonality); C (Collaboration); A (Artificial data); R (Real-world data)

Source(s): Table by authors

[ViewLarge]

Sharing Unavailable