Concept matrix with outlet and covered parts of the IOC framework
| Source | Outlet | Uncertainty sources | Per-formance | Coordination mechanisms | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E | P | T | Structural | Process | IT-mediated (coPM) | |||
| Aksu et al. (2016) | IEEE Conference on Business Informatics | X | X (Comparison) | |||||
| Azzini and Ceravolo (2013) | IEEE International Congress on Big Data | X (Data integration) | ||||||
| Bernardi et al. (2014) | IEEE Symposium on Computational Intelligence and Data Mining | X (Architecture including Discovery) | ||||||
| Bernardi et al. (2018) | Journal of Information and Knowledge Management | X (Architecture including Discovery) | ||||||
| Buijs and Reijers (2014) | Enterprise, Business Process and Information Systems Modeling | (X) | X (Analytical technique and visualization for process comparison) | |||||
| Buijs et al. (2012b) | International Conference on Business Process Management | (X) | X (Metrics identification) | |||||
| Buijs et al. (2013) | International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Canjels et al. (2019) | International Conference on Business Process Management | X | X (Three-step methodology) | |||||
| Claes and Poels (2014) | Expert Systems with Applications | X (Data integration) | ||||||
| Corradini et al. (2022) | Enterprise, Business Process and Information Systems Modeling | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| D'Iddio et al. (2016a) | IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X (Conformance Checking) | ||||||
| D'Iddio et al. (2016b) | IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X (Conformance Checking) | ||||||
| Deokar and Tao (2020) | Information Systems Frontiers | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Elkoumy et al. (2020a) | Enterprise, Business Process and Information Systems Modeling | X (Architecture including data anonymization and Discovery) | ||||||
| Elkoumy et al. (2020b) | International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Architecture including data anonymization and Discovery) | ||||||
| Engel and Bose (2014) | Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences | (X) | ||||||
| Engel et al. (2011) | International Conference on Electronic Commerce and Web Technologies | X (Architecture including data pre-processing and process mining analysis) | ||||||
| Engel et al. (2012) | International Conference on Advanced Information Systems Engineering | X | X (Data pre-processing) | |||||
| Engel et al. (2013a) | International Conference on Advanced Information Systems Engineering | X (Data pre-processing) | ||||||
| Engel et al. (2016) | Information Systems and e-Business Management | (X) | X (Architecture including data pre-processing and process mining analysis) | |||||
| Gerke et al. (2009b) | International Conference on Business Information Systems | X (Data pre-processing) | ||||||
| Gerke et al. (2009a) | IEEE Conference on Commerce and Enterprise Computing | X (Data pre-processing) | ||||||
| González and Delgado (2021) | Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences | X (Compliance formalization) | ||||||
| Helm and Küng (2016) | International Conference on Information Technology in Bio- and Medical Informatics | X (Extended L* lifecycle model) | ||||||
| Hernandez-Resendiz et al. (2021) | Studies in Computational Intelligence | X (Data pre-processing and Discovery) | ||||||
| Ho et al. (2009) | International Journal of Production Research | X | X (Process Mining cycle for global optimization) | X (Architecture including process mining analysis) | ||||
| Ivković and Luković (2021) | European Conference on Advances in Databases and Information Systems | X (Framework for smart contract validation) | ||||||
| Jacobi et al. (2020) | Logistics Journal | X | X | |||||
| Khan et al. (2021) | International Conference on Service-Oriented Computing | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Kim et al. (2020) | Applied Sciences | X (Colla-borative perspectives, success factors and KPIs) | X (Architecture) | |||||
| Klinkmüller et al. (2019) | International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Framework for Blockchain data pre-processing) | ||||||
| Krathu et al. (2014) | IEEE Conference on Business Informatics | (X) | X (Framework for process mining analysis) | |||||
| Lamghari et al. (2020) | International Conference Europe Middle East and North Africa Information Systems and Technologies to Support Learning | X (Framework including data pre-processing and Discovery) | ||||||
| Li (2010) | International Conference on Management and Service Science | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Liu (2020) | IEEE International Conference on Web Services | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Liu et al. (2019) | IEEE Transactions on Services Computing | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Liu et al. (2023a) | IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Liu et al. (2023b) | IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Mans et al. (2008) | Studies in Health Technology and Informatics | (X) | ||||||
| Maruster et al. (2003) | International Conference on Advances in Production Management Systems | X | X (Three-step methodology) | |||||
| Morales-Sandoval et al. (2021) | PeerJ Computer Science | X (Data pre-processing of blockchain data) | ||||||
| Mühlberger et al. (2019) | International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Data pre-processing of blockchain data) | ||||||
| Müller et al. (2022) | Lecture Notes in Business Information Processing | X (System architecture) | ||||||
| Partington et al. (2015) | ACM Transactions on Management Information Systems | X | (X) | |||||
| Pini et al. (2015) | Asia–Pacific Conference on Business Process Management | X (Visualization techniques for comparison) | ||||||
| Pourmasoumi et al. (2017) | Information Systems Frontiers | X (Discovery of process fragments) | ||||||
| Rafiei and Van Der Aalst (2023) | IEEE Access | X (Privacy-preserving abstraction-based discovery) | ||||||
| R'Bigui and Cho (2017) | International Journal of Business Process Integration and Management | |||||||
| Rott and Böhm (2022b) | Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems | X | X (Value distribution concepts) | |||||
| Rozsnyai et al. (2012) | Annual SRII Global Conference | X (Architecture) | ||||||
| Sun et al. (2011) | IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics - Part A: Systems and Humans | X (Framework) | ||||||
| Suriadi et al. (2014) | Asia–Pacific Business Process Management | (X) | ||||||
| Tajima et al. (2023) | IEEE Access | X (Data pre-processing) | ||||||
| Talamo et al. (2013a) | International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X (Conformance Checking) | ||||||
| Talamo et al. (2013b) | IEEE Conference on Communications and Network Security | X (Conformance Checking) | ||||||
| Talamo et al. (2015) | IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X | X (Conformance Checking) | |||||
| Talamo et al. (2015) | Lecture Notes in Business Information Processing | X (Usage of blockchain technology to create a cross-organizational event log) | ||||||
| van der Aalst et al. (2012) | International Conference on Business Process Management | |||||||
| van der Aalst et al. (2012) | OTM Confederated International Conferences “On the Move to Meaningful Internet Systems” | |||||||
| van der Aalst (2011a) | European Conference on Web Services | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| van der Aalst (2011b) | IFIP Working Conference on The Practice of Enterprise Modeling | |||||||
| van der Aalst (2021) | IEEE International Conference on Smart Data Services | X (Data pre-processing) | ||||||
| Wang et al. (2018) | International Conference on Digital Government Research | X | (Compliance monitoring framework) | |||||
| Yilmaz and Senkul (2015) | International Symposium on Data-Driven Process Discovery and Analysis | (X) | X (Enhancement and improvement recommendations) | |||||
| Zeng et al. (2013) | Decision Support Systems | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Zeng et al. (2020) | IEEE Access | X (Discovery) | ||||||
| Sum | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 (9) | 8 | 0 | 51 | |
| Source | Outlet | Uncertainty sources | Per-formance | Coordination mechanisms | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E | P | T | Structural | Process | IT-mediated (coPM) | |||
| IEEE Conference on Business Informatics | X | X (Comparison) | ||||||
| IEEE International Congress on Big Data | X (Data integration) | |||||||
| IEEE Symposium on Computational Intelligence and Data Mining | X (Architecture including Discovery) | |||||||
| Journal of Information and Knowledge Management | X (Architecture including Discovery) | |||||||
| Enterprise, Business Process and Information Systems Modeling | (X) | X (Analytical technique and visualization for process comparison) | ||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | (X) | X (Metrics identification) | ||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | X | X (Three-step methodology) | ||||||
| Expert Systems with Applications | X (Data integration) | |||||||
| Enterprise, Business Process and Information Systems Modeling | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X (Conformance Checking) | |||||||
| IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X (Conformance Checking) | |||||||
| Information Systems Frontiers | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| Enterprise, Business Process and Information Systems Modeling | X (Architecture including data anonymization and Discovery) | |||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Architecture including data anonymization and Discovery) | |||||||
| Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences | (X) | |||||||
| International Conference on Electronic Commerce and Web Technologies | X (Architecture including data pre-processing and process mining analysis) | |||||||
| International Conference on Advanced Information Systems Engineering | X | X (Data pre-processing) | ||||||
| International Conference on Advanced Information Systems Engineering | X (Data pre-processing) | |||||||
| Information Systems and e-Business Management | (X) | X (Architecture including data pre-processing and process mining analysis) | ||||||
| International Conference on Business Information Systems | X (Data pre-processing) | |||||||
| IEEE Conference on Commerce and Enterprise Computing | X (Data pre-processing) | |||||||
| Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences | X (Compliance formalization) | |||||||
| International Conference on Information Technology in Bio- and Medical Informatics | X (Extended L* lifecycle model) | |||||||
| Studies in Computational Intelligence | X (Data pre-processing and Discovery) | |||||||
| International Journal of Production Research | X | X (Process Mining cycle for global optimization) | X (Architecture including process mining analysis) | |||||
| European Conference on Advances in Databases and Information Systems | X (Framework for smart contract validation) | |||||||
| Logistics Journal | X | X | ||||||
| International Conference on Service-Oriented Computing | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| Applied Sciences | X (Colla-borative perspectives, success factors and KPIs) | X (Architecture) | ||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Framework for Blockchain data pre-processing) | |||||||
| IEEE Conference on Business Informatics | (X) | X (Framework for process mining analysis) | ||||||
| International Conference Europe Middle East and North Africa Information Systems and Technologies to Support Learning | X (Framework including data pre-processing and Discovery) | |||||||
| International Conference on Management and Service Science | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IEEE International Conference on Web Services | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IEEE Transactions on Services Computing | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| Studies in Health Technology and Informatics | (X) | |||||||
| International Conference on Advances in Production Management Systems | X | X (Three-step methodology) | ||||||
| PeerJ Computer Science | X (Data pre-processing of blockchain data) | |||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | X (Data pre-processing of blockchain data) | |||||||
| Lecture Notes in Business Information Processing | X (System architecture) | |||||||
| ACM Transactions on Management Information Systems | X | (X) | ||||||
| Asia–Pacific Conference on Business Process Management | X (Visualization techniques for comparison) | |||||||
| Information Systems Frontiers | X (Discovery of process fragments) | |||||||
| IEEE Access | X (Privacy-preserving abstraction-based discovery) | |||||||
| International Journal of Business Process Integration and Management | ||||||||
| Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems | X | X (Value distribution concepts) | ||||||
| Annual SRII Global Conference | X (Architecture) | |||||||
| IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics - Part A: Systems and Humans | X (Framework) | |||||||
| Asia–Pacific Business Process Management | (X) | |||||||
| IEEE Access | X (Data pre-processing) | |||||||
| International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X (Conformance Checking) | |||||||
| IEEE Conference on Communications and Network Security | X (Conformance Checking) | |||||||
| IEEE International Carnahan Conference on Security Technology | X | X (Conformance Checking) | ||||||
| Lecture Notes in Business Information Processing | X (Usage of blockchain technology to create a cross-organizational event log) | |||||||
| International Conference on Business Process Management | ||||||||
| OTM Confederated International Conferences “On the Move to Meaningful Internet Systems” | ||||||||
| European Conference on Web Services | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IFIP Working Conference on The Practice of Enterprise Modeling | ||||||||
| IEEE International Conference on Smart Data Services | X (Data pre-processing) | |||||||
| International Conference on Digital Government Research | X | (Compliance monitoring framework) | ||||||
| International Symposium on Data-Driven Process Discovery and Analysis | (X) | X (Enhancement and improvement recommendations) | ||||||
| Decision Support Systems | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| IEEE Access | X (Discovery) | |||||||
| Sum | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 (9) | 8 | 0 | 51 | |
Note(s): E: Environmental uncertainty; P: Partnership uncertainty; T: Task uncertainty
Source(s): Table by authors; Bensaou and Venkatraman (1996)
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.