Table 1 Coding methodology Area Codes... | Emerald Publishing

Table 1

Coding methodology

Area	Codes	Comment	Major issue/Precision
Field of Research	– Big Data – Business Process Management (BPM) – Information and Communication Technology (ICT) – Information Systems (IS) – Organization – Other	Inductive category	This category was created in an inductive procedure, adhering to thematic analysis (Squires, 2023)
Process Type	– Operational Process – Support Process – Management Process – Research process – added by the authors	Deductive category (Porter, 1998)	This category categorizes the different types of processes. The authors added a fourth type of process, which subsumes information about research processes and a meta-perspective on BPM research
Process Perspective	– Internal Process (I) – External Process (E)	Deductive category based on Hammer and Champy (2001)	This category was used to determine if the processes are intra-organizational or inter-organizational
Socio-technical Systems Perspective	– Organization – Individual – Technology	Deductive category based on Orlikowski (2007) and Leonardi (2012)	This category was used to determine which socio-technical perspective was employed in the respective research paper. One paper could include several perspectives
Ethical Values	– Accountability – Autonomy – Community – Dignity – Education – Efficiency – Equality – Freedom – Human Health – Human Capabilities – Human Productivity – Human Welfare – Human Wellbeing – Justice – Knowledge – Maintainability – Privacy – Property – Relationship – Reliability – Respect for Norms – Security – Simplicity – Transparency – Trust – Usability – Environment – Meta Perspective on Values – Added by the authors	Deductive category based on Winkler (2018)	This category is based on the overarching values for sustainable software development as proposed by Winkler (ibid.). These overarching values include other subordinate partial values. We have taken the liberty of adding the category of the meta-perspective on values. We have applied this when a publication discusses the significance of values for a specific application area. One paper could include several values

Area	Codes	Comment	Major issue/Precision
Field of Research	– Big Data – Business Process Management (BPM) – Information and Communication Technology (ICT) – Information Systems (IS) – Organization – Other	Inductive category	This category was created in an inductive procedure, adhering to thematic analysis (Squires, 2023)
Process Type	– Operational Process – Support Process – Management Process – Research process – added by the authors	Deductive category (Porter, 1998)	This category categorizes the different types of processes. The authors added a fourth type of process, which subsumes information about research processes and a meta-perspective on BPM research
Process Perspective	– Internal Process (I) – External Process (E)	Deductive category based on Hammer and Champy (2001)	This category was used to determine if the processes are intra-organizational or inter-organizational
Socio-technical Systems Perspective	– Organization – Individual – Technology	Deductive category based on Orlikowski (2007) and Leonardi (2012)	This category was used to determine which socio-technical perspective was employed in the respective research paper. One paper could include several perspectives
Ethical Values	– Accountability – Autonomy – Community – Dignity – Education – Efficiency – Equality – Freedom – Human Health – Human Capabilities – Human Productivity – Human Welfare – Human Wellbeing – Justice – Knowledge – Maintainability – Privacy – Property – Relationship – Reliability – Respect for Norms – Security – Simplicity – Transparency – Trust – Usability – Environment – Meta Perspective on Values – Added by the authors	Deductive category based on Winkler (2018)	This category is based on the overarching values for sustainable software development as proposed by Winkler (ibid.). These overarching values include other subordinate partial values. We have taken the liberty of adding the category of the meta-perspective on values. We have applied this when a publication discusses the significance of values for a specific application area. One paper could include several values

Source(s): Table by authors