Mapping construction site characteristics against workers’ MHW outcomes using theoretical dimensions
| No. | Article (author, year) | JDR theory | Salutogenesis theory | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Job Demands (JD-R) | Job resources (JD-R) | Comprehensibility | Manageability | Meaningfulness | ||
| 1 | (Omer et al., 2024a) | Workload, long hours, monitoring, poor conditions | Leadership, welfare, communication, transport | Structured workflow, feedback | Timely pay, safety systems | Respect, collaboration, team support |
| 2 | (Szer et al., 2022) | Heat, solar radiation, humidity, workload at height | Scaffolding covers, heat index tools (UTCI) | Weather monitoring, risk correlations | Breaks, forecast-based planning, shade/rest areas | Safer work, dignity under extreme heat |
| 3 | (Kwong et al., 2023) | Heat, noise, humidity, poor airflow | Fans, PPE, shade, rest breaks | Clear PPE use, routines | Breaks reduced strain | Safety, worker satisfaction |
| 4 | (Irfan et al., 2024) | – | Welfare (rest, hygiene, transport, safety) | Welfare improves predictability | Amenities support demand handling | Amenities enhance work value/satisfaction |
| 5 | (Radzi et al., 2023) | Workload, hours, deadlines, payment, safety risks | Welfare, food, transport, insurance, leadership, comms | Planning and communication improve task clarity | Leadership, job clarity, and welfare aid control | Leadership and welfare boost value/purpose |
| 6 | (Rani et al., 2022) | Long hours, project pressure, performance checks | Welfare facilities, site safety, health monitoring | Project planning, role clarity | Site planning, clear safety procedures | Safety support, adequate site amenities |
| 7 | (Radzi et al., 2024) | Long working hours, physical strain, site isolation | Site layout, rest areas, communication tools | Clear roles, signage, site updates | Work planning, break access | Site connection, purpose in physical work |
| 8 | (Bitencourt et al., 2021) | Extreme heat, heat waves, outdoor physical labour | – | Climate data and WBGT improve awareness | Limited mitigation mechanisms | General concern for health (policy level) |
| 9 | (Messeri et al., 2019) | Heat exposure, physical strain, migrant vulnerability | Training (formal/informal) | Varies by group – clearer for native workers | Migrants adapt despite fewer formal supports | Inferred through reporting of effort |
| 10 | (Umar and Egbu, 2020) | Excessive heat, physical strain, hypertension risks | Breaks, hydration, rescheduling, screening (suggested) | Workers aware of heat risks and related incidents | Task rescheduling, lighter clothing, shift planning (partial) | – |
| 11 | (Kurtzer et al., 2020) | Heat, weather extremes | Suggestions for environmental adjustments | Awareness of weather-related risks | Limited site-level control | Health linked to work ability |
| 12 | (Pogačar et al., 2019) | Heat waves, dehydration, physical exhaustion | Water access, peer discussion | Informal awareness of heat effects on work | Hydration, peer support | – |
| 13 | (Chan et al., 2016) | Heat, humidity, clothing discomfort | Cooling clothing, breathable fabrics | Design feedback, discomfort awareness | Prototype testing | Safety, performance |
| 14 | (Chinnadurai et al., 2016) | High heat, cardiovascular strain | PMV model, ISO standards, field interviews | Heart rate and PMV data interpretation | Indoor task adaptation | Health protection, climate planning |
| 15 | (Farshad et al., 2014) | Extreme heat, dehydration, solar radiation | No formal OHS, no rest/hydration system | Awareness via WBGT/TWL/USG indices | Lack of control, informal setting | Work necessity under poor conditions |
| 16 | (Zhang et al., 2023) | Workload, job pressure, physical strain | Welfare, PPE, safe worksite | Wellbeing dimensions, visual tools | Equipment, fair pay, team support | Fairness, support, family balance |
| 17 | (Liu et al., 2023) | Workload, task ambiguity | WHS practices | Task clarity | Work planning | – |
| 18 | (Onubi et al., 2024) | Site-level green practice requirements | On-site green skills, awareness | Clarity through SEM modeling | Support for green actions | Sustainability-oriented values |
| 19 | (Yi and Chan, 2015) | Heat, workload, solar radiation, clothing insulation, ventilation | WBGT model, heart rate data, PPE selection, rest cycle | Heat index model improves risk clarity | Index-based planning and PPE choice | Science-based care supports value of worker role |
| 20 | (Yi and Chan, 2017) | Heat, continuous physical labor, physiological strain | Smart work-rest model, WBGT thresholds, workload data | Visual tools and thresholds clarify risks | Real-time schedule adjustments possible | Personalized planning supports health and motivation |
| 21 | (Kawakami et al., 2024) | Heat, humidity, physical workload, long hours | Cooling jackets, shaded rest zones, scheduled breaks | Physiological and subjective fatigue assessment | Cooler break areas reduced heat strain | Recovery supports health, but fatigue remained |
| 22 | (Guo et al., 2019) | Heat, humidity, physical strain, risk of heat illness | Cooling vest with PCM, fans, UV-protection | Vest performance tested and explained | Reduced heat strain, improved recovery | Comfort and safety supported work performance |
| 23 | (Esmaeilifar et al., 2020) | Stress from recycle/reuse tasks, low-carbon pressure | Reduce practice, clear waste management plans | Waste impact modeled via PLS-SEM | Reduce practice easier to apply | Tension between sustainability targets and role meaning |
| 24 | (Omer et al., 2024b) | Long working hours, unsafe physical conditions | Rest areas, safety signage, site communication tools | Site-level hazards were observable and documented | Site layout and rest provisions supported control | Physical safety and visible improvements enhanced trust |
| 25 | (Carvajal-Arango et al., 2021) | Emotional demands, unsafe conditions, repetitive tasks, lack of recognition | Recognition, social support, growth opportunities, site-level support | Subjective feedback clarified wellbeing influences | Autonomy, interpersonal support, recognition improved control | Recognition and purpose increased connection to work |
| 26 | (Techera et al., 2019) | Long shifts, extreme temperatures, physical and mental strain, inter-site travel | Peer support, rest periods, hazard awareness | Task clarity maintained, mental fatigue affects focus | Fatigue limits control, especially during long tasks | Public service creates meaning, but burnout reduces motivation |
| 27 | (Jia et al., 2019) | Heat stress, deadlines, managerial pressure, productivity push | Cool zones, peer support, union input, site initiatives | Confusing leadership signals, risk awareness | Informal practices, limited formal authority | Peer dignity, blocked by top-down priorities |
| 28 | (Ahmed et al., 2020) | Radiant heat, WBGT, physical demand, heat stress risk | Shaded areas, acclimatization zones, shift adjustment | WBGT/HSI/TWL data, acclimatization awareness | Shift rescheduling, shaded rest, worker restriction | Safety concerns, heat impacts performance |
| 29 | (Yasmeen et al., 2020) | WBGT 31.5 °C, humidity, solar heat, physical exertion | Acclimatization, rest periods, fan, ventilation | Skin temp, heart rate patterns, physiological insight | Rest scheduling, airflow, short breaks | Endurance, work commitment |
| 30 | (Jia et al., 2016) | Heat, no acclimatization, site-induced stress | Engineering controls, symptom control | Risk awareness, hazard identification | On-site infrastructure, physical response measures | Safety concern, survival motivation |
| 31 | (Eaves et al., 2016) | Physical strain, age-related demands, musculoskeletal symptoms | Ergonomics, adapted PPE, tool redesign, lifting aids, peer input | High awareness of physical risks | Body strain control through design changes | Empowerment via involvement |
| 32 | (Hsu et al., 2016) | Height, narrow space, extreme climate, high-risk tasks | Experience, physiological monitoring (HRV) | Risk awareness with cognitive clarity | Stress harder to control at elevation | Essential, skilled work; stress normalized |
| 33 | (Bendak et al., 2022) | High heat, fatigue, impaired performance, accident risk | Task batteries, seasonal data, monitoring | Clear fatigue trends, easy interpretation | Hard to manage summer fatigue | Alertness, safety, performance valued |
| 34 | (Yang et al., 2021) | High noise, communication strain, auditory stress | Binaural tools, psychoacoustic analysis, feedback | Noise types understood; long-term risks unclear | Weak control; spatial zoning needed | Mixed: accepted by some; others feel unsafe |
| 35 | (Yosef et al., 2022) | High workload, poor PPE, no training, safety risks | Observations, injury prevention advice, analysis | Injury risks known; limited factor awareness | Poor without PPE/training; risks remain high | Safety perception strongly linked to satisfaction |
| 36 | (Jiang et al., 2020) | Air, water, food, waste, noise pollution | Risk perception, proactive orientation | Experience-based interpretation; varies by group | Lower for older/female workers; limited control | Meaning through hazard recognition, esp. young/males |
| 37 | (Kordmiri et al., 2023) | Hand-transmitted vibration, noise, tool repetition, neuromuscular strain | Controlled setup, EMG tools, rest intervals | Exposure and task structure clearly defined | Rest allowed, short tasks, monitored strain | Prevention focus, awareness of dual-exposure risks |
| 38 | (Al-Bouwarthan et al., 2020) | Outdoor heat, high WBGT, dehydration, cardiovascular strain | Self-pacing, shaded areas, hydration checks, WBGT tools | Risk education, global threshold alignment | Self-pacing helped, but low environmental control | Health study boosted agency, stressed protection needs |
| 39 | (Dutta et al., 2015) | High heat, low protection, physical overload | Cooling practices, basic PPE, personal strategies | Recognized symptoms, situational awareness | Self-protection used, low control over workload | Health concerns showed risk awareness and value on safety |
| 40 | (Zhao et al., 2017) | Extreme heat, PPE use, physical workload | Cooling vest, hydration, safety monitoring | Clear conditions, relatable outcomes | Passive cooling improved recovery and tolerance | Innovation supports health, safety, and job sustainability |
| 41 | (Tennakoon et al., 2025) | Task overload, bullying, macho culture, time pressure | Supportive supervision, communication | Lack of clear communication | Low control and coping capacity | Reduced sense of value under unsupportive culture |
| 42 | (Alruqi et al., 2025) | Role pressure, unclear responsibilities, excessive workload | Limited supervision support, job stability | Multicultural and linguistic barriers | Low control due to unstable contracts | Job alienation and reduced safety motivation |
| 43 | (Biggs et al., 2025) | Role ambiguity, conflict, isolation in FIFO/DIDO sites | Supervisor support, recognition, consultation (MATES) | Improved clarity via leadership and communication training | Greater access to peer and emotional support | Strengthened belonging and purpose through engagement |
| 44 | (Zhang et al., 2025) | Cognitive–emotional load in digitalised Construction 5.0 tasks | Psychosocial support, leadership, emotional resilience | Clearer understanding of safety roles | Better ability to manage tech-driven stress | Enhanced belonging through human-centric culture |
| 45 | (Ross et al., 2025) | Bullying, unsupportive work culture | Supervisor training, resilience, toolbox sessions | Awareness of bullying behaviour | Enhanced coping and communication | Inclusion and respect strengthen value perception |
| 46 | (Ofori et al., 2025) | Ergonomic and cognitive stress from exoskeleton use | Technological assistive tools, ethical assurance | Understanding of device operation and data use | Moderate control over device comfort | Trust and fairness increase motivation |
| 47 | (van Heerden et al., 2025) | Physical workload, interpersonal conflict, long hours | Training, supportive management, career development | Clearer job roles reduce confusion | Organisational support improves coping | Recognition fosters engagement |
| 48 | (Li et al., 2025) | High safety accountability, time pressure, uncertainty | Organisational and social support | Ambiguity reduces clarity | Support buffers burnout | Supportive culture enhances role meaning |
| 49 | (Guo et al., 2025) | Psychological distress, isolation, unsafe climate | Safety communication, supportive climate | Unclear risk communication | Improved coping via guidance | Family connection reinforces wellbeing |
| 50 | (Sun et al., 2025) | Environmental stress (noise, dust, confinement) | Rest areas, ventilation, exposure controls | Poor understanding of invisible hazards | Limited control in confined tunnels | Comfort and safety perception increase satisfaction |
| 51 | (Liu et al., 2025) | Long hours, stress, unsafe or inequitable sites | Income stability, safety assurance, welfare systems | Clear expectations and fair systems | Safety and pay improve stress management | Career growth and recognition enhance purpose |
| No. | Article (author, year) | Salutogenesis theory | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Job Demands (JD-R) | Job resources (JD-R) | Comprehensibility | Manageability | Meaningfulness | ||
| 1 | (Omer | Workload, long hours, monitoring, poor conditions | Leadership, welfare, communication, transport | Structured workflow, feedback | Timely pay, safety systems | Respect, collaboration, team support |
| 2 | (Szer | Heat, solar radiation, humidity, workload at height | Scaffolding covers, heat index tools ( | Weather monitoring, risk correlations | Breaks, forecast-based planning, shade/rest areas | Safer work, dignity under extreme heat |
| 3 | (Kwong | Heat, noise, humidity, poor airflow | Fans, PPE, shade, rest breaks | Clear | Breaks reduced strain | Safety, worker satisfaction |
| 4 | (Irfan | – | Welfare (rest, hygiene, transport, safety) | Welfare improves predictability | Amenities support demand handling | Amenities enhance work value/satisfaction |
| 5 | (Radzi | Workload, hours, deadlines, payment, safety risks | Welfare, food, transport, insurance, leadership, comms | Planning and communication improve task clarity | Leadership, job clarity, and welfare aid control | Leadership and welfare boost value/purpose |
| 6 | (Rani | Long hours, project pressure, performance checks | Welfare facilities, site safety, health monitoring | Project planning, role clarity | Site planning, clear safety procedures | Safety support, adequate site amenities |
| 7 | (Radzi | Long working hours, physical strain, site isolation | Site layout, rest areas, communication tools | Clear roles, signage, site updates | Work planning, break access | Site connection, purpose in physical work |
| 8 | (Bitencourt | Extreme heat, heat waves, outdoor physical labour | – | Climate data and | Limited mitigation mechanisms | General concern for health (policy level) |
| 9 | (Messeri | Heat exposure, physical strain, migrant vulnerability | Training (formal/informal) | Varies by group – clearer for native workers | Migrants adapt despite fewer formal supports | Inferred through reporting of effort |
| 10 | (Umar and Egbu, 2020) | Excessive heat, physical strain, hypertension risks | Breaks, hydration, rescheduling, screening (suggested) | Workers aware of heat risks and related incidents | Task rescheduling, lighter clothing, shift planning (partial) | – |
| 11 | (Kurtzer | Heat, weather extremes | Suggestions for environmental adjustments | Awareness of weather-related risks | Limited site-level control | Health linked to work ability |
| 12 | (Pogačar | Heat waves, dehydration, physical exhaustion | Water access, peer discussion | Informal awareness of heat effects on work | Hydration, peer support | – |
| 13 | (Chan | Heat, humidity, clothing discomfort | Cooling clothing, breathable fabrics | Design feedback, discomfort awareness | Prototype testing | Safety, performance |
| 14 | (Chinnadurai | High heat, cardiovascular strain | Heart rate and | Indoor task adaptation | Health protection, climate planning | |
| 15 | (Farshad | Extreme heat, dehydration, solar radiation | No formal OHS, no rest/hydration system | Awareness via WBGT/TWL/ | Lack of control, informal setting | Work necessity under poor conditions |
| 16 | (Zhang | Workload, job pressure, physical strain | Welfare, PPE, safe worksite | Wellbeing dimensions, visual tools | Equipment, fair pay, team support | Fairness, support, family balance |
| 17 | (Liu | Workload, task ambiguity | Task clarity | Work planning | – | |
| 18 | (Onubi | Site-level green practice requirements | On-site green skills, awareness | Clarity through | Support for green actions | Sustainability-oriented values |
| 19 | (Yi and Chan, 2015) | Heat, workload, solar radiation, clothing insulation, ventilation | Heat index model improves risk clarity | Index-based planning and | Science-based care supports value of worker role | |
| 20 | (Yi and Chan, 2017) | Heat, continuous physical labor, physiological strain | Smart work-rest model, | Visual tools and thresholds clarify risks | Real-time schedule adjustments possible | Personalized planning supports health and motivation |
| 21 | (Kawakami | Heat, humidity, physical workload, long hours | Cooling jackets, shaded rest zones, scheduled breaks | Physiological and subjective fatigue assessment | Cooler break areas reduced heat strain | Recovery supports health, but fatigue remained |
| 22 | (Guo | Heat, humidity, physical strain, risk of heat illness | Cooling vest with PCM, fans, UV-protection | Vest performance tested and explained | Reduced heat strain, improved recovery | Comfort and safety supported work performance |
| 23 | (Esmaeilifar | Stress from recycle/reuse tasks, low-carbon pressure | Reduce practice, clear waste management plans | Waste impact modeled via PLS-SEM | Reduce practice easier to apply | Tension between sustainability targets and role meaning |
| 24 | (Omer | Long working hours, unsafe physical conditions | Rest areas, safety signage, site communication tools | Site-level hazards were observable and documented | Site layout and rest provisions supported control | Physical safety and visible improvements enhanced trust |
| 25 | (Carvajal-Arango | Emotional demands, unsafe conditions, repetitive tasks, lack of recognition | Recognition, social support, growth opportunities, site-level support | Subjective feedback clarified wellbeing influences | Autonomy, interpersonal support, recognition improved control | Recognition and purpose increased connection to work |
| 26 | (Techera | Long shifts, extreme temperatures, physical and mental strain, inter-site travel | Peer support, rest periods, hazard awareness | Task clarity maintained, mental fatigue affects focus | Fatigue limits control, especially during long tasks | Public service creates meaning, but burnout reduces motivation |
| 27 | (Jia | Heat stress, deadlines, managerial pressure, productivity push | Cool zones, peer support, union input, site initiatives | Confusing leadership signals, risk awareness | Informal practices, limited formal authority | Peer dignity, blocked by top-down priorities |
| 28 | (Ahmed | Radiant heat, WBGT, physical demand, heat stress risk | Shaded areas, acclimatization zones, shift adjustment | WBGT/HSI/ | Shift rescheduling, shaded rest, worker restriction | Safety concerns, heat impacts performance |
| 29 | (Yasmeen | Acclimatization, rest periods, fan, ventilation | Skin temp, heart rate patterns, physiological insight | Rest scheduling, airflow, short breaks | Endurance, work commitment | |
| 30 | (Jia | Heat, no acclimatization, site-induced stress | Engineering controls, symptom control | Risk awareness, hazard identification | On-site infrastructure, physical response measures | Safety concern, survival motivation |
| 31 | (Eaves | Physical strain, age-related demands, musculoskeletal symptoms | Ergonomics, adapted PPE, tool redesign, lifting aids, peer input | High awareness of physical risks | Body strain control through design changes | Empowerment via involvement |
| 32 | (Hsu | Height, narrow space, extreme climate, high-risk tasks | Experience, physiological monitoring ( | Risk awareness with cognitive clarity | Stress harder to control at elevation | Essential, skilled work; stress normalized |
| 33 | (Bendak | High heat, fatigue, impaired performance, accident risk | Task batteries, seasonal data, monitoring | Clear fatigue trends, easy interpretation | Hard to manage summer fatigue | Alertness, safety, performance valued |
| 34 | (Yang | High noise, communication strain, auditory stress | Binaural tools, psychoacoustic analysis, feedback | Noise types understood; long-term risks unclear | Weak control; spatial zoning needed | Mixed: accepted by some; others feel unsafe |
| 35 | ( | High workload, poor PPE, no training, safety risks | Observations, injury prevention advice, analysis | Injury risks known; limited factor awareness | Poor without PPE/training; risks remain high | Safety perception strongly linked to satisfaction |
| 36 | (Jiang | Air, water, food, waste, noise pollution | Risk perception, proactive orientation | Experience-based interpretation; varies by group | Lower for older/female workers; limited control | Meaning through hazard recognition, esp. young/males |
| 37 | (Kordmiri | Hand-transmitted vibration, noise, tool repetition, neuromuscular strain | Controlled setup, | Exposure and task structure clearly defined | Rest allowed, short tasks, monitored strain | Prevention focus, awareness of dual-exposure risks |
| 38 | (Al-Bouwarthan | Outdoor heat, high WBGT, dehydration, cardiovascular strain | Self-pacing, shaded areas, hydration checks, | Risk education, global threshold alignment | Self-pacing helped, but low environmental control | Health study boosted agency, stressed protection needs |
| 39 | (Dutta | High heat, low protection, physical overload | Cooling practices, basic PPE, personal strategies | Recognized symptoms, situational awareness | Self-protection used, low control over workload | Health concerns showed risk awareness and value on safety |
| 40 | (Zhao | Extreme heat, | Cooling vest, hydration, safety monitoring | Clear conditions, relatable outcomes | Passive cooling improved recovery and tolerance | Innovation supports health, safety, and job sustainability |
| 41 | (Tennakoon | Task overload, bullying, macho culture, time pressure | Supportive supervision, communication | Lack of clear communication | Low control and coping capacity | Reduced sense of value under unsupportive culture |
| 42 | (Alruqi | Role pressure, unclear responsibilities, excessive workload | Limited supervision support, job stability | Multicultural and linguistic barriers | Low control due to unstable contracts | Job alienation and reduced safety motivation |
| 43 | (Biggs | Role ambiguity, conflict, isolation in FIFO/DIDO sites | Supervisor support, recognition, consultation ( | Improved clarity via leadership and communication training | Greater access to peer and emotional support | Strengthened belonging and purpose through engagement |
| 44 | (Zhang | Cognitive–emotional load in digitalised Construction 5.0 tasks | Psychosocial support, leadership, emotional resilience | Clearer understanding of safety roles | Better ability to manage tech-driven stress | Enhanced belonging through human-centric culture |
| 45 | (Ross | Bullying, unsupportive work culture | Supervisor training, resilience, toolbox sessions | Awareness of bullying behaviour | Enhanced coping and communication | Inclusion and respect strengthen value perception |
| 46 | (Ofori | Ergonomic and cognitive stress from exoskeleton use | Technological assistive tools, ethical assurance | Understanding of device operation and data use | Moderate control over device comfort | Trust and fairness increase motivation |
| 47 | (van Heerden | Physical workload, interpersonal conflict, long hours | Training, supportive management, career development | Clearer job roles reduce confusion | Organisational support improves coping | Recognition fosters engagement |
| 48 | (Li | High safety accountability, time pressure, uncertainty | Organisational and social support | Ambiguity reduces clarity | Support buffers burnout | Supportive culture enhances role meaning |
| 49 | (Guo | Psychological distress, isolation, unsafe climate | Safety communication, supportive climate | Unclear risk communication | Improved coping via guidance | Family connection reinforces wellbeing |
| 50 | (Sun | Environmental stress (noise, dust, confinement) | Rest areas, ventilation, exposure controls | Poor understanding of invisible hazards | Limited control in confined tunnels | Comfort and safety perception increase satisfaction |
| 51 | (Liu | Long hours, stress, unsafe or inequitable sites | Income stability, safety assurance, welfare systems | Clear expectations and fair systems | Safety and pay improve stress management | Career growth and recognition enhance purpose |
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.