Table 1 Success criteria and measurement... | Emerald Publishing

Table 1

Success criteria and measurement approaches by adaptation pattern

Pattern	Primary success indicators	How to measure	Red flags
Full replication	Compliance rate Implementation speed Process consistency	Audit scores Time-to-implementation metrics Process variance analysis	High compliance but poor outcomes Fast implementation but low adoption Consistency without effectiveness
Selective adoption	Practice effectiveness Employee acceptance Local relevance	Performance improvement data Engagement surveys Stakeholder feedback	Cherry-picking without strategy Excessive customisation Inability to demonstrate value
Integration	Strategic alignment Local-global balance Cross-pollination of ideas	Strategic goal achievement Innovation sharing metrics Knowledge transfer documentation	Local dominance without global input HQ dominance without local input Hybrid complexity without value

Pattern	Primary success indicators	How to measure	Red flags
Full replication	Compliance rate Implementation speed Process consistency	Audit scores Time-to-implementation metrics Process variance analysis	High compliance but poor outcomes Fast implementation but low adoption Consistency without effectiveness
Selective adoption	Practice effectiveness Employee acceptance Local relevance	Performance improvement data Engagement surveys Stakeholder feedback	Cherry-picking without strategy Excessive customisation Inability to demonstrate value
Integration	Strategic alignment Local-global balance Cross-pollination of ideas	Strategic goal achievement Innovation sharing metrics Knowledge transfer documentation	Local dominance without global input HQ dominance without local input Hybrid complexity without value

Source(s): Author’s own construct