Results of stationarity tests
| Country | Stationarity | GEG | IQ | NIC | FD | TR | GVE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brunei | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −4.277*** | −0.589 | −1.565 | −2.997** | −1.061 | −2.634* |
| In the first difference | −3.330** | −2.964** | −2.866** | −3.919*** | −2.675* | −3.652*** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −2.894** | −0.627 | −1.612 | −2.095 | −0.792 | −2.340 |
| In the first difference | −3.728** | −4.523*** | −5.100*** | −3.381*** | −3.719*** | −5.707*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −4.882** | −3.077 | −4.137* | −4.411 | −3.193 | −3.487 |
| In the first difference | −4.899** | −5.467*** | −5.726*** | −4.705* | −4.824** | −6.610*** | |
| Cambodia | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −1.994 | −2.716* | 1.234 | −0.940 | −2.722* | −2.381 |
| In the first difference | −2.668* | −3.330** | −4.314*** | −2.697* | −2.915** | −3.407** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −2.358 | −2.350 | 1.292 | 2.324 | −2.341 | −2.295 |
| In the first difference | −2.687* | −4.325*** | −8.737*** | −8.844*** | −4.067*** | −4.505*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.336 | −3.052 | −5.673*** | −2.684 | −5.285** | −2.889 |
| In the first difference | −4.814** | −5.043** | −8.464*** | −6.487*** | −4.841* | −5.382*** | |
| Indonesia | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −1.402 | −0.743 | 1.569 | −2.348 | −2.322 | −2.311 |
| In the first difference | −3.281** | −4.629*** | −3.127** | −3.773*** | −6.612*** | −3.371** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −1.285 | −0.636 | 2.129 | −1.553 | −2.219 | −2.302 |
| In the first difference | −3.274** | −4.436*** | −4.612*** | −3.391** | −4.836*** | −4.324*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.618 | −4.177 | −3.583 | −3.346 | −6.244*** | −1.396 |
| In the first difference | −4.652* | −4.937** | −6.968*** | −5.689*** | −7.145*** | −5.544*** | |
| Malaysia | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −0.940 | −3.013** | −2.046 | −1.984 | −1.064 | −2.531 |
| In the first difference | −4.972*** | −3.933*** | −3.678*** | −3.353** | −3.460*** | −3.825*** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −0.662 | −2.656* | −1.988 | −1.974 | −1.634 | −3.384** |
| In the first difference | −5.025*** | −4.489*** | −3.840*** | −4.718*** | −3.960*** | −4.819*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −3.571 | −4.156 | −4.388* | −2.991 | −2.802 | −5.143** |
| In the first difference | −5.585*** | −4.747* | −4.405* | −6.269*** | −4.764* | −4.751* | |
| Singapore | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −2.113 | −2.013 | −0.296 | −0.595 | −0.896 | −2.748* |
| In the first difference | −4.536*** | −3.674*** | −3.817*** | −5.424*** | −3.263** | −4.844*** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −1.482 | −3.316** | −0.310 | −1.130 | −1.282 | −2.468 |
| In the first difference | −4.554*** | −7.639*** | −5.353*** | −5.269*** | −5.963*** | −5.472*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.365 | −4.962** | −3.131 | −4.077 | −3.656 | −4.191 |
| In the first difference | −4.842** | −8.480*** | −5.338*** | −7.982*** | −7.243*** | −4.597* | |
| Thailand | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −2.873* | −2.309 | −0.989 | −0.847 | −2.626* | −1.425 |
| In the first difference | −3.486*** | −2.954** | −3.529*** | −2.618* | −4.677*** | −2.936** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −3.086** | −2.102 | −1.159 | −0.777 | −2.412 | −1.156 |
| In the first difference | −3.491*** | −7.304*** | −5.299*** | −4.766*** | −4.636*** | −3.292** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.447 | −4.987** | −3.009 | −2.925 | −3.603 | −4.684* |
| In the first difference | −5.085** | −4.904** | −5.678*** | −5.263** | −5.080** | −4.848** | |
| Vietnam | |||||||
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −2.681* | −1.767 | −0.871 | −3.410** | −3.266** | −1.681 |
| In the first difference | −5.710*** | −3.875*** | −3.985** | −5.300*** | −5.820*** | −3.160** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −2.284 | −2.143 | −0.862 | −2.701* | −2.613* | −1.666 |
| In the first difference | −2.722* | −5.301*** | −2.974** | −2.906** | −3.248** | −4.041*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.680* | −5.506*** | −3.205 | −5.078** | −5.260** | −4.317 |
| In the first difference | −5.708*** | −6.027*** | −4.554** | −5.893*** | −7.439*** | −6.236*** |
| Country | Stationarity | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −4.277*** | −0.589 | −1.565 | −2.997** | −1.061 | −2.634* |
| In the first difference | −3.330** | −2.964** | −2.866** | −3.919*** | −2.675* | −3.652*** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −2.894** | −0.627 | −1.612 | −2.095 | −0.792 | −2.340 |
| In the first difference | −3.728** | −4.523*** | −5.100*** | −3.381*** | −3.719*** | −5.707*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −4.882** | −3.077 | −4.137* | −4.411 | −3.193 | −3.487 |
| In the first difference | −4.899** | −5.467*** | −5.726*** | −4.705* | −4.824** | −6.610*** | |
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −1.994 | −2.716* | 1.234 | −0.940 | −2.722* | −2.381 |
| In the first difference | −2.668* | −3.330** | −4.314*** | −2.697* | −2.915** | −3.407** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −2.358 | −2.350 | 1.292 | 2.324 | −2.341 | −2.295 |
| In the first difference | −2.687* | −4.325*** | −8.737*** | −8.844*** | −4.067*** | −4.505*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.336 | −3.052 | −5.673*** | −2.684 | −5.285** | −2.889 |
| In the first difference | −4.814** | −5.043** | −8.464*** | −6.487*** | −4.841* | −5.382*** | |
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −1.402 | −0.743 | 1.569 | −2.348 | −2.322 | −2.311 |
| In the first difference | −3.281** | −4.629*** | −3.127** | −3.773*** | −6.612*** | −3.371** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −1.285 | −0.636 | 2.129 | −1.553 | −2.219 | −2.302 |
| In the first difference | −3.274** | −4.436*** | −4.612*** | −3.391** | −4.836*** | −4.324*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.618 | −4.177 | −3.583 | −3.346 | −6.244*** | −1.396 |
| In the first difference | −4.652* | −4.937** | −6.968*** | −5.689*** | −7.145*** | −5.544*** | |
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −0.940 | −3.013** | −2.046 | −1.984 | −1.064 | −2.531 |
| In the first difference | −4.972*** | −3.933*** | −3.678*** | −3.353** | −3.460*** | −3.825*** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −0.662 | −2.656* | −1.988 | −1.974 | −1.634 | −3.384** |
| In the first difference | −5.025*** | −4.489*** | −3.840*** | −4.718*** | −3.960*** | −4.819*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −3.571 | −4.156 | −4.388* | −2.991 | −2.802 | −5.143** |
| In the first difference | −5.585*** | −4.747* | −4.405* | −6.269*** | −4.764* | −4.751* | |
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −2.113 | −2.013 | −0.296 | −0.595 | −0.896 | −2.748* |
| In the first difference | −4.536*** | −3.674*** | −3.817*** | −5.424*** | −3.263** | −4.844*** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −1.482 | −3.316** | −0.310 | −1.130 | −1.282 | −2.468 |
| In the first difference | −4.554*** | −7.639*** | −5.353*** | −5.269*** | −5.963*** | −5.472*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.365 | −4.962** | −3.131 | −4.077 | −3.656 | −4.191 |
| In the first difference | −4.842** | −8.480*** | −5.338*** | −7.982*** | −7.243*** | −4.597* | |
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −2.873* | −2.309 | −0.989 | −0.847 | −2.626* | −1.425 |
| In the first difference | −3.486*** | −2.954** | −3.529*** | −2.618* | −4.677*** | −2.936** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −3.086** | −2.102 | −1.159 | −0.777 | −2.412 | −1.156 |
| In the first difference | −3.491*** | −7.304*** | −5.299*** | −4.766*** | −4.636*** | −3.292** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.447 | −4.987** | −3.009 | −2.925 | −3.603 | −4.684* |
| In the first difference | −5.085** | −4.904** | −5.678*** | −5.263** | −5.080** | −4.848** | |
| Augmented-Dickey-Fuller | In level | −2.681* | −1.767 | −0.871 | −3.410** | −3.266** | −1.681 |
| In the first difference | −5.710*** | −3.875*** | −3.985** | −5.300*** | −5.820*** | −3.160** | |
| Phillip-Perron | In levels | −2.284 | −2.143 | −0.862 | −2.701* | −2.613* | −1.666 |
| In the first difference | −2.722* | −5.301*** | −2.974** | −2.906** | −3.248** | −4.041*** | |
| Structural breaks | In levels | −2.680* | −5.506*** | −3.205 | −5.078** | −5.260** | −4.317 |
| In the first difference | −5.708*** | −6.027*** | −4.554** | −5.893*** | −7.439*** | −6.236*** |
*, ** and *** significance at 10, 5 and 1% level, respectively.
GEG denotes green economic growth; IQ represents institutional quality; NIC refers to national intellectual capital; IQ*NIC is the interaction term between institutional quality and national intellectual capital; FD denotes financial development; TR indicates trade openness, and GVE refers to government expenditure on education
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.