Table 3. Operationalising concerned... | Emerald Publishing

Table 3.

Operationalising concerned market mapping as a transferable methodological framework

Stage	Focus	Guide	Issue mapping
Identify focal concern	Shared concern and obligatory passage point	Tracing how the issue framed and which actors, devices or discourses define the focal problem?	Initial mapping of key actors, devices, framings and discourses making visual the points of convergence
Trace problematisation	Construction of the problem	Tracing how harm or instability articulated and relations reframed?	Extend mapping to trace the emergence problem definitions and tensions
Trace interessement	Disruption and realignment	Follow efforts to weaken existing attachments and promote alternatives	Update mapping to reflect the shift in alignments and contested relations
Trace enrolment	Expansion of alignment	Follow recruitment, coordination, and mechanisms aligning actors and devices	Map the stabilisation of connections and the coordination across various actors and devices
Trace mobilisation	Enactment and diffusion	Trace how practices are stabilised and reproduced through behavioural or institutional uptake?	Refine maps to capture how practices spread and become patterned
Interpret translation	Reconfiguration	Trace how translation unfolds recursively and reshapes market formation?	Bring issue mappings together to make sense of the broader reconfiguration

Stage	Focus	Guide	Issue mapping
Identify focal concern	Shared concern and obligatory passage point	Tracing how the issue framed and which actors, devices or discourses define the focal problem?	Initial mapping of key actors, devices, framings and discourses making visual the points of convergence
Trace problematisation	Construction of the problem	Tracing how harm or instability articulated and relations reframed?	Extend mapping to trace the emergence problem definitions and tensions
Trace interessement	Disruption and realignment	Follow efforts to weaken existing attachments and promote alternatives	Update mapping to reflect the shift in alignments and contested relations
Trace enrolment	Expansion of alignment	Follow recruitment, coordination, and mechanisms aligning actors and devices	Map the stabilisation of connections and the coordination across various actors and devices
Trace mobilisation	Enactment and diffusion	Trace how practices are stabilised and reproduced through behavioural or institutional uptake?	Refine maps to capture how practices spread and become patterned
Interpret translation	Reconfiguration	Trace how translation unfolds recursively and reshapes market formation?	Bring issue mappings together to make sense of the broader reconfiguration

Source(s): Authors’ own work