Table 4 Common method bias analysis...

Table 4

Common method bias analysis

Construct	Indictor	Substantive factor loading (⁠ $R 1$ ⁠)	$R 1^{2}$	Method factor loading (⁠ $R 2$ ⁠)	$R 2^{2}$
	Ex1	0.862***	0.743	0.004	0.000016
Ex	Ex2	0.841***	0.707	−0.076	0.005776
	Ex3	0.841***	0.707	0.063	0.003969
	Ex4	0.856***	0.733	0.008	0.000064
	R1	0.849***	0.721	−0.016	0.000256
Re	R2	0.866***	0.750	0.026	0.000676
	R3	0.854***	0.729	−0.01	0.0001
	Pe1	0.849***	0.721	−0.016	0.000256
Pe	Pe2	0.853***	0.728	0.026	0.000676
	Pe3	0.850***	0.723	−0.011	0.000121
	En1	0.846***	0.716	−0.049	0.002401
En	En2	0.859***	0.738	0.057	0.003249
	En3	0.838***	0.702	−0.01	0.0001
	PT1	0.844***	0.712	0.07	0.0049
PT	PT2	0.781***	0.610	−0.049	0.002401
	PT3	0.821***	0.674	−0.02	0.0004
	PT4	0.820***	0.672	−0.007	0.000049
	PS1	0.824***	0.679	−0.051	0.002601
PS	PS2	0.833***	0.694	−0.01	0.0001
	PS3	0.794***	0.630	0.064	0.004096
	PI1	0.785***	0.616	−0.022	0.000484
	PI2	0.765***	0.585	−0.075	0.005625
PI	PI3	0.803***	0.645	0.035	0.001225
	PI4	0.788***	0.621	−0.043	0.001849
	PI5	0.825***	0.681	0.096	0.009216
Average		0.830	0.690	−0.00064	0.002024

Construct	Indictor	Substantive factor loading ( $R 1$ )	$R 1^{2}$	Method factor loading ( $R 2$ )	$R 2^{2}$
	Ex1	0.862***	0.743	0.004	0.000016
Ex	Ex2	0.841***	0.707	−0.076	0.005776
	Ex3	0.841***	0.707	0.063	0.003969
	Ex4	0.856***	0.733	0.008	0.000064
	R1	0.849***	0.721	−0.016	0.000256
Re	R2	0.866***	0.750	0.026	0.000676
	R3	0.854***	0.729	−0.01	0.0001
	Pe1	0.849***	0.721	−0.016	0.000256
Pe	Pe2	0.853***	0.728	0.026	0.000676
	Pe3	0.850***	0.723	−0.011	0.000121
	En1	0.846***	0.716	−0.049	0.002401
En	En2	0.859***	0.738	0.057	0.003249
	En3	0.838***	0.702	−0.01	0.0001
	PT1	0.844***	0.712	0.07	0.0049
PT	PT2	0.781***	0.610	−0.049	0.002401
	PT3	0.821***	0.674	−0.02	0.0004
	PT4	0.820***	0.672	−0.007	0.000049
	PS1	0.824***	0.679	−0.051	0.002601
PS	PS2	0.833***	0.694	−0.01	0.0001
	PS3	0.794***	0.630	0.064	0.004096
	PI1	0.785***	0.616	−0.022	0.000484
	PI2	0.765***	0.585	−0.075	0.005625
PI	PI3	0.803***	0.645	0.035	0.001225
	PI4	0.788***	0.621	−0.043	0.001849
	PI5	0.825***	0.681	0.096	0.009216
Average		0.830	0.690	−0.00064	0.002024

Note(s): ***p < 0.001, **p < 0.01, *p < 0.05

Source(s): Authors' own work

Sharing Unavailable