Table 2. Analytical framework with... | Emerald Publishing

Table 2.

Analytical framework with definitions and examples

Categories	Subcategories	Definitions	Examples
Justice-related terms	1. Just, justice	Explicit use of the term “justice” or related forms in the text	Climate justice
	2. Inclus* (inclusive, inclusion, inclusivity)	Explicit use of the term “inclusion” or related forms in the text	Inclusive planning
	3. Equit* (equitable, equity)	Explicit use of the term “equity” or related forms in the text	Equitable outcome
	4. Equal* [equal, equality (-ies)]	Explicit use of the term “equality” or related forms in the text	Gender equality
	5. Fair, fairness	Explicit use of the term “fairness” or related forms in the text	Fair distribution
Justice dimensions	1. Distributive justice	Justice linked to the (mal)distribution/delivery of common goods such as mobility system, energy, funding, carbon budget or climate impacts	Fair distribution of climate funds, unfair distribution of climate impacts
	2. Participatory justice	Justice linked to participative processes including public participation, transparency, information sharing, etc.	Inclusive planning
	3. Recognition justice	Justice linked to recognition of vulnerable groups and identities including women, gender minorities, people of colour, youth, future generations, elderly, poor, ethnic minorities, etc.	Gender equality, just transition for youth
	4. Unspecified	Justice terms are used without specifying justice dimensions	Inclusive development for all
Contexts	1. Space	Justice linked to any kinds of geographical space such as urban space, city, community, and region	Inclusive city, spatial justice
	2. Economy	Justice linked to any activities related to economic issues such as finance, jobs, budget, etc.	Fair allocation of carbon budgets, inclusive economy
	3. Governance, policy, system	Justice references to policies, governance and political system of cities using terms such as governance, policy, politics and multilateral systems	A just recovery policy, inclusive planning process
	4. Pandemic	Justice linked to COVID-19 impacts and recovery	A just recovery policy, fair distribution of vaccines, inequitable impact of the pandemic
	5. Future	Justice linked to future, opportunities, outcomes, etc.	Creating cities’ future in a just and inclusive way
	6. Just transition	Justice linked to a just transition	Just transition, just and equitable transition for all
	7. Gender	Justice linked to any texts mentioning gender	Gender equality
	8. SDGs	Justice terms used in relation to SDGs and sustainable development agendas	SDG11 (Make cities inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable)
	9. Unspecified	Justice terms used without a clearly identifiable contextual category	The city innovates and starts taking inclusive action to address emissions and climate risk beyond…
	10. Others	Other contexts not captured by the above categories (e.g. resilience, culture, digital technology, mobility, migrant, specific projects by city networks not related to other contexts)	Digital transformation for inclusive city, an inclusive transportation

Categories	Subcategories	Definitions	Examples
Justice-related terms	1. Just, justice	Explicit use of the term “justice” or related forms in the text	Climate justice
	2. Inclus* (inclusive, inclusion, inclusivity)	Explicit use of the term “inclusion” or related forms in the text	Inclusive planning
	3. Equit* (equitable, equity)	Explicit use of the term “equity” or related forms in the text	Equitable outcome
	4. Equal* [equal, equality (-ies)]	Explicit use of the term “equality” or related forms in the text	Gender equality
	5. Fair, fairness	Explicit use of the term “fairness” or related forms in the text	Fair distribution
Justice dimensions	1. Distributive justice	Justice linked to the (mal)distribution/delivery of common goods such as mobility system, energy, funding, carbon budget or climate impacts	Fair distribution of climate funds, unfair distribution of climate impacts
	2. Participatory justice	Justice linked to participative processes including public participation, transparency, information sharing, etc.	Inclusive planning
	3. Recognition justice	Justice linked to recognition of vulnerable groups and identities including women, gender minorities, people of colour, youth, future generations, elderly, poor, ethnic minorities, etc.	Gender equality, just transition for youth
	4. Unspecified	Justice terms are used without specifying justice dimensions	Inclusive development for all
Contexts	1. Space	Justice linked to any kinds of geographical space such as urban space, city, community, and region	Inclusive city, spatial justice
	2. Economy	Justice linked to any activities related to economic issues such as finance, jobs, budget, etc.	Fair allocation of carbon budgets, inclusive economy
	3. Governance, policy, system	Justice references to policies, governance and political system of cities using terms such as governance, policy, politics and multilateral systems	A just recovery policy, inclusive planning process
	4. Pandemic	Justice linked to COVID-19 impacts and recovery	A just recovery policy, fair distribution of vaccines, inequitable impact of the pandemic
	5. Future	Justice linked to future, opportunities, outcomes, etc.	Creating cities’ future in a just and inclusive way
	6. Just transition	Justice linked to a just transition	Just transition, just and equitable transition for all
	7. Gender	Justice linked to any texts mentioning gender	Gender equality
	8. SDGs	Justice terms used in relation to SDGs and sustainable development agendas	SDG11 (Make cities inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable)
	9. Unspecified	Justice terms used without a clearly identifiable contextual category	The city innovates and starts taking inclusive action to address emissions and climate risk beyond…
	10. Others	Other contexts not captured by the above categories (e.g. resilience, culture, digital technology, mobility, migrant, specific projects by city networks not related to other contexts)	Digital transformation for inclusive city, an inclusive transportation

Source(s): Authors’ own work