Table 2 Interview quotations analysed...

Table 2

Interview quotations analysed

Quotation characteristics source		(1) Handling transcripts (Section 4.2.1)	(2) Selection of quotations (Section 4.2.2)	(3) Quotations (no.) (Section 4.2.3)	(4) Length of quotation (no. words) (Section 4.2.4)				(5) Placement of interview quotations findings (F); introduction (I); conclusions (C) (Section 4.2.5)
				No.	Total	Average	Longest	Shortest
1	Belal and Owen (2015)	Not clear	Justified	20	1,649	82	196	22	All in findings
2	Carungu et al., (2021)	Not clear	Not justified	24	343	14	30	5	All in findings
3	Compernolle (2018)	Interviewer	Quasi justified	19	1,460	77	201	29	All in findings
4	Dambrin and Lambert (2008)	Authors?	Justified	32	2,276	71	241	3	All in findings
5	Dewi et al. (2019)	One researcher	Justified	30	1,203	50	85	11	All in findings
6	Edgley et al. (2010)	Third party (named)	Not justified	59	2,960	50	293	1	All in findings
7	Haigh and Shapiro (2012)	Not mentioned	Not justified	9	473	53	105	18	F7+C2
8	Hayes and Jacobs (2017)	Not clear	Not justified	58	2,003	35	123	1	F56 + C2
9	Islam and Deegan (2008)	Not clear	Justified	17	1,578	93	287	48	All in findings
10	Khalifa et al. (2007)	Not clear	Not justified	9	816	91	198	25	All in findings
11	Kraus (2012)	Not clear	Not justified	59	2,349	40	208	3	All in findings
12	Kreander et al. (2004)	Not clear	Not justified	27	386	15	40	2	I3+F24
13	Kuruppu et al. (2019)	Third party	Not justified	25	1,033	41	111	2	All in findings
14	Manson et al. (2001)	Not clear	Not justified	23	919	40	74	21	All in findings
15	Rimmel and Jonäll (2013)	Not clear	Not justified	11	561	51	79	37	All in findings
16	Sinkovics et al. (2016)	Not clear	Not justified	13	959	74	103	42	All in findings
17	Skærbæk and Melander (2004)	Not clear	Justified	30	1,972	66	114	5	All in findings
18	Sweeney and Pierce (2004)	Not clear	Justified	69	2,943	43	120	3	All in findings
19	Tremblay et al. (2016)	Not clear	Justified	21	1,746	83	194	29	All in findings
20	Yang and Modell (2013)	N/A	Not justified	45	986	22	85	2	All in findings
		Total quotations (no./words)		600	28,615	48	293	1	F593 + I3+C4
		Sample average quotations		30

Quotation characteristics source		(1) Handling transcripts (Section 4.2.1)	(2) Selection of quotations (Section 4.2.2)	(3) Quotations (no.) (Section 4.2.3)	(4) Length of quotation (no. words) (Section 4.2.4)				(5) Placement of interview quotations findings (F); introduction (I); conclusions (C) (Section 4.2.5)
				No.	Total	Average	Longest	Shortest
1	Belal and Owen (2015)	Not clear	Justified	20	1,649	82	196	22	All in findings
2	Carungu et al., (2021)	Not clear	Not justified	24	343	14	30	5	All in findings
3	Compernolle (2018)	Interviewer	Quasi justified	19	1,460	77	201	29	All in findings
4	Dambrin and Lambert (2008)	Authors?	Justified	32	2,276	71	241	3	All in findings
5	Dewi et al. (2019)	One researcher	Justified	30	1,203	50	85	11	All in findings
6	Edgley et al. (2010)	Third party (named)	Not justified	59	2,960	50	293	1	All in findings
7	Haigh and Shapiro (2012)	Not mentioned	Not justified	9	473	53	105	18	F7+C2
8	Hayes and Jacobs (2017)	Not clear	Not justified	58	2,003	35	123	1	F56 + C2
9	Islam and Deegan (2008)	Not clear	Justified	17	1,578	93	287	48	All in findings
10	Khalifa et al. (2007)	Not clear	Not justified	9	816	91	198	25	All in findings
11	Kraus (2012)	Not clear	Not justified	59	2,349	40	208	3	All in findings
12	Kreander et al. (2004)	Not clear	Not justified	27	386	15	40	2	I3+F24
13	Kuruppu et al. (2019)	Third party	Not justified	25	1,033	41	111	2	All in findings
14	Manson et al. (2001)	Not clear	Not justified	23	919	40	74	21	All in findings
15	Rimmel and Jonäll (2013)	Not clear	Not justified	11	561	51	79	37	All in findings
16	Sinkovics et al. (2016)	Not clear	Not justified	13	959	74	103	42	All in findings
17	Skærbæk and Melander (2004)	Not clear	Justified	30	1,972	66	114	5	All in findings
18	Sweeney and Pierce (2004)	Not clear	Justified	69	2,943	43	120	3	All in findings
19	Tremblay et al. (2016)	Not clear	Justified	21	1,746	83	194	29	All in findings
20	Yang and Modell (2013)	N/A	Not justified	45	986	22	85	2	All in findings
		Total quotations (no./words)		600	28,615	48	293	1	F593 + I3+C4
		Sample average quotations		30

Quotation characteristics source		(6) Presentation of interview quotations block (B); interspersed (IS) tables (T) (Section 4.2.6)	(7) (Interviews) interviewees^a(Section 4.2.7)	(7) Interviewees quoted (Section 4.2.7)	(8) Language of interviews (Section 4.2.8)	(9) Protocols for editing quotations (Section 4.2.9)	(10) Transparency of quotation edits (Section 4.2.9)
			No.	No. (%)
1	Belal and Owen (2015)	All block	22	9 (41%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
2	Carungu et al., (2021)	B5+IS2+T17	10	8 (80%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
3	Compernolle (2018)	All block	53	17 (32%)	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
4	Dambrin and Lambert (2008)	B28 + IS4	24	16 (67%)	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
5	Dewi et al. (2019)	All block	51^b	17 (36%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
6	Edgley et al. (2010)	B52 + IS7	20	18 (90%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
7	Haigh and Shapiro (2012)	All block	(38) 30	9 (30%)	English	Not mentioned	Little evidence
8	Hayes and Jacobs (2017)	B17 + IS41	3	3 (100%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
9	Islam and Deegan (2008)	All block	12	8 (67%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
10	Khalifa et al. (2007)	All block	70	6 (9%)	English	Not mentioned	Evident
11	Kraus (2012)	B26 + IS33	30	29 (67%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
12	Kreander et al. (2004)	B4+IS23	5	N/A	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
13	Kuruppu et al. (2019)	B14 + IS11	26	9 (35%)	English	Mentioned	Not evident
14	Manson et al. (2001)	All block	33	N/A	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
15	Rimmel and Jonäll (2013)	All block	7	7 (100%)	Translated	Mentioned	Evident
16	Sinkovics et al. (2016)	All block	9	N/A	Not clear	Not mentioned	Some evidence
17	Skærbæk and Melander (2004)	B28 + IS2	35	N/A	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
18	Sweeney and Pierce (2004)	B51 + IS18	25	18 (72%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
19	Tremblay et al. (2016)	All block	31	13 (42%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
20	Yang and Modell (2013)	B14 + IS31	(112) 30	N/A	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
	Total quotations	B411 + IS172 + T17
	Sample average quotations

Quotation characteristics source		(6) Presentation of interview quotations block (B); interspersed (IS) tables (T) (Section 4.2.6)	(7) (Interviews) interviewees^a(Section 4.2.7)	(7) Interviewees quoted (Section 4.2.7)	(8) Language of interviews (Section 4.2.8)	(9) Protocols for editing quotations (Section 4.2.9)	(10) Transparency of quotation edits (Section 4.2.9)
			No.	No. (%)
1	Belal and Owen (2015)	All block	22	9 (41%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
2	Carungu et al., (2021)	B5+IS2+T17	10	8 (80%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
3	Compernolle (2018)	All block	53	17 (32%)	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
4	Dambrin and Lambert (2008)	B28 + IS4	24	16 (67%)	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
5	Dewi et al. (2019)	All block	51^b	17 (36%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
6	Edgley et al. (2010)	B52 + IS7	20	18 (90%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
7	Haigh and Shapiro (2012)	All block	(38) 30	9 (30%)	English	Not mentioned	Little evidence
8	Hayes and Jacobs (2017)	B17 + IS41	3	3 (100%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
9	Islam and Deegan (2008)	All block	12	8 (67%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
10	Khalifa et al. (2007)	All block	70	6 (9%)	English	Not mentioned	Evident
11	Kraus (2012)	B26 + IS33	30	29 (67%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
12	Kreander et al. (2004)	B4+IS23	5	N/A	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
13	Kuruppu et al. (2019)	B14 + IS11	26	9 (35%)	English	Mentioned	Not evident
14	Manson et al. (2001)	All block	33	N/A	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
15	Rimmel and Jonäll (2013)	All block	7	7 (100%)	Translated	Mentioned	Evident
16	Sinkovics et al. (2016)	All block	9	N/A	Not clear	Not mentioned	Some evidence
17	Skærbæk and Melander (2004)	B28 + IS2	35	N/A	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
18	Sweeney and Pierce (2004)	B51 + IS18	25	18 (72%)	English	Not mentioned	Not evident
19	Tremblay et al. (2016)	All block	31	13 (42%)	Translated	Not mentioned	Not evident
20	Yang and Modell (2013)	B14 + IS31	(112) 30	N/A	Not clear	Not mentioned	Not evident
	Total quotations	B411 + IS172 + T17
	Sample average quotations

Note(s): F = quotations in findings; I = quotations in introduction; C = quotations in conclusions; B = block quotation; IS = quotation interspersed within the paper's text; T = quotation in tables

^a: Some interviewees were interviewed more than once

^b: 46 interviews + 5 focus group participants

N/A: interviewees' quotations cannot be identified because interviewees are classified in groups, not individually

[ViewLarge]

Sharing Unavailable