Table 1

Paradoxes/tensions and responses in small-series production and high-cost contexts

Paradox category (Smith and Lewis, 2011)Key paradoxes/tensions and responsesa in small-series production and high-cost location decisions
  • -Elements/themes from supply chain management (adapted from Zhang et al., 2021)

Performing tensions
  • -Service (e.g. lead time)

  • -Specific (e.g. innovation)

  • -Sustainability (e.g. resource efficiency, well-being)

  • -Overall (e.g. value, supply chain performance)

  • -Cost

  • -Investment (e.g. IT investments)

  • -Forecast


  • -Cost vs Quality, Delivery, Flexibility (customization and/or high-cost location)

  • -Cost vs Service-lead time/enhanced value (customization and/or high-cost location)

Pal et al. (2018), Suzić et al. (2018) and Suzić and Forza (2021)
Macchion and Fornasiero (2020), Mirzaei et al. (2021) and Sandberg (2017) 
 Performing tension responses
  • -Synthesis-Mass customization

  • -Separation-Balancing local and global sourcing/production (customization and standard products)


Suzić et al. (2018), Suzić and Forza (2021) and Zhang et al. (2019)
Macchion and Fornasiero (2020) and Sandberg (2017) 
Performing-organizing tensions
  • -Cost/performance vs Unique/craft manufacturing product-processes (flexibility and customization enablers/antecedents)

Duray et al. (2000), Mirzaei et al. (2021), Pal et al. (2018) and Salvador et al. (2015) 
Performing-organizing tension responses
  • -Synthesis-Mass customization

Duray et al. (2000) 
Organizing tensions
  • -Collaboration (e.g. supply chain integration and coordination)

  • -Efficiency and control (e.g. automation, trust for control, supply chain transparency, traditional forms of organizing)

  • -Exploration (e.g. flexibility, creativity, new forms of organizing)

  • -Competition

  • -Other (e.g. unique/craft manufacturing)

  
Learning tensions
  • -New (e.g. knowledge in new relationships, product/process innovation)

  • -Present (e.g. analytics capabilities)

  • -Old (e.g. learning in old relationship)

  
Belonging tensions
  • -Single entity (e.g. individual preference or expertise)

  • -Multiple entities (e.g. collective/group, supply chain stakeholders)

  

a Categorized according to definitions from Poole and Van de Ven (1989) 

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal