Literature streams integrated in the processual conceptualization of the actor
| Literature stream | Overview | Key insights for reconceptualizing the actor in service research | Key references | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Literature informing S-D logic's institutionally constituted account of the actor | Institutional theory (especially organizational studies) | A theory of enduring social structures, such as schemas, norms, rules, and the processes through which they come to constrain and enable social action, as well as become established as a shared basis for social behavior | 1) Social structures comprising institutional arrangements are highly institutionalized, that is, widely practiced, largely uncontested, and resistant to change 2) Institutional arrangements enable and constrain action, and they make social life predictable and meaningful 3) Social roles are essential parts of institutional arrangements | Greenwood et al. (2008) Scott (2005; 2014) |
| Structuration theory | A theory of society that considers structure and agency as mutually constitutive, that is, that neither the individual nor institutionalized social structures have causal priority in explaining social action | 4) Institutional arrangements are reproduced and changed through social action 5) Human beings are knowledgeable and reflexive; therefore, they are capable of adapting institutionalized patterns of activity | Giddens (1984) | |
| Additional literature informing the processual conceptualization of the actor developed in this paper | Social constructionism | A theory on the dialectic of the individual and society in the construction of knowledge. Departs from symbolic interactionism in examining how interacting individuals produce representations and mutual roles that institutionalize over time. The process of institutionalization joins shared conceptions with existing social structures, which, in turn, are the materials for the construction of individuals through socialization | 6) Institutional arrangements are socially constructed (humanly devised) 7) Identity is formed through social processes 8) Primary socialization is the first socialization through which a child comes to absorb the cultural assumptions, values, norms, and beliefs of her parents and the community she is brought up in 9) Secondary socialization inducts an individual to a particular institutional subworld and its specialized, distributed knowledge, including its specific social identities | Berger and Luckmann (1967) |
| Identity theory (structural symbolic interactionists) | A theory that uses identity to refer to the “parts of a self composed of the meanings that persons attach to the multiple roles they play in highly differentiated contemporary societies” (Stryker and Burke, 2000, p. 284). In this line of thought, identities constitute an essential component in understanding how social structures influence the development of a person and, in turn, how a person influences social structures | 10) Individuals draw their social identities from the distinct contexts in which they occupy positions and perform roles 11) An individual selectively integrates her internalized social identities and other self-descriptions drawn from her biography and experiences into a coherent and relatively continuous objectification of the self (i.e. personal identity) 12) Personal identity directs the interpretation and enactment of situated social roles | Stryker (1968; 1980) Burke (1980; 1991) MacKinnon and Heise (2010) | |
| Literature stream | Overview | Key insights for reconceptualizing the actor in service research | Key references | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Literature informing S-D logic's institutionally constituted account of the actor | Institutional theory (especially organizational studies) | A theory of enduring social structures, such as schemas, norms, rules, and the processes through which they come to constrain and enable social action, as well as become established as a shared basis for social behavior | 1) Social structures comprising institutional arrangements are highly institutionalized, that is, widely practiced, largely uncontested, and resistant to change | |
| Structuration theory | A theory of society that considers structure and agency as mutually constitutive, that is, that neither the individual nor institutionalized social structures have causal priority in explaining social action | 4) Institutional arrangements are reproduced and changed through social action | ||
| Additional literature informing the processual conceptualization of the actor developed in this paper | Social constructionism | A theory on the dialectic of the individual and society in the construction of knowledge. Departs from symbolic interactionism in examining how interacting individuals produce representations and mutual roles that institutionalize over time. The process of institutionalization joins shared conceptions with existing social structures, which, in turn, are the materials for the construction of individuals through socialization | 6) Institutional arrangements are socially constructed (humanly devised) | |
| Identity theory (structural symbolic interactionists) | A theory that uses identity to refer to the “parts of a self composed of the meanings that persons attach to the multiple roles they play in highly differentiated contemporary societies” ( | 10) Individuals draw their social identities from the distinct contexts in which they occupy positions and perform roles | ||