Literature review on the effects of SA8000 certification
| Operational | Market | |||||||||
| + | + | + | + | – | – | + | + | |||
| Underpinning theory | Improvement of working conditions | Increase of personnel productivity | Improvement of product quality | Cost reduction | Higher cost (obtaining and maintaining the certification) | Constrains in supplier selection | Improvement of firm reputation | Increase of customer satisfaction | ||
| (1) Battaglia et al. (2014) | Sustainability | Stakeholder | Ta | Ta | ||||||
| (2) Beschorner and Müller (2007) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (3) Beske et al. (2008) | Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management | CO | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||
| (4) Castka and Balzarova (2008) | International Journal of Production Economics | CO | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||
| (5) Christmann and Taylor (2006) | Journal of International Business Studies | TCE | CO | |||||||
| (6) Ciliberti et al. (2009) | Supply Chain Management: An International Journal | CS | CS | CS | CS | |||||
| (7) Ciliberti et al. (2011) | Journal of Cleaner Production | PAT | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | ||
| (8) De Magistris et al. (2015) | The Journal of Consumer Affairs | |||||||||
| (9) Fuentes-García et al. (2008) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (10) Gilbert and Rasche (2007) | Business Ethics Quarterly | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| (11) Gilbert and Rasche (2008) | Journal of Business Ethics | Stakeholder | CO | CO | ||||||
| (12) Henkle (2005) | Journal of Organisational Excellence | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (13) Koerber (2010) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (14) Koplin et al. (2007) | Journal of Cleaner Production | CS | ||||||||
| (15) Meehan et al. (2006) | International Journal of Social Economics | |||||||||
| (16) Merli et al. (2015) | Sustainability | T | T | |||||||
| (17) Miles and Munilla (2004) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||
| (18) Miles et al. (2006) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (19) Rasche and Esser (2006) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | CO | |||||||
| (20) Rasche (2009) | Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (21) Rasche (2010a) | Business Ethics: A European Review | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (22) Rasche (2010b) | Corporate Governance | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (23) Reynolds and Yuthas (2008) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (24) Rohitratana (2002) | Managerial Auditing Journal | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | |||
| (25) Ruževičius et al. (2007) | Engineering Economics | CS | CS | CS | CS | |||||
| (26) Salomone (2008) | Journal of Cleaner Production | CSa | CSa | |||||||
| (27) Stigzelius and Mark-Herbert (2009) | Scandinavian Journal of Management | CS | CS | CS | CS | |||||
| (28) Tencati and Zsolnai (2009) | Journal of Business Ethics | CS | CS | CS | CS | |||||
| (29) Wang (2008) | Asian Social Science | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| (30) Werre (2003) | Journal of Business Ethics | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (31) Zhao et al. (2012) | Journal of Cleaner Production | Stakeholder | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||
| (32 ) Zutshi et al. (2009) | European Business Review | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| Market | Innovation | Others | ||||||||
| – | + | + | + | + | + | |||||
| Underpinning theory | Poor knowledge of the standard by the customers | Willingness to pay | Sales increase | Increase of the level of technical products innovation | Increase of the level of organisational innovation | Easier access to credit | Improvement of the relationships with the stakeholders | |||
| (1) Battaglia et al. (2014) | Sustainability | Stakeholder | Ta | Ta | Ta | Ta | Ta | |||
| (2) Beschorner and Müller (2007) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (3) Beske et al. (2008) | Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management | CO | CO | |||||||
| (4) Castka and Balzarova (2008) | International Journal of Production Economics | CO | CO | |||||||
| (5) Christmann and Taylor (2006) | Journal of International Business Studies | TCE | CO | |||||||
| (6) Ciliberti et al. (2009) | Supply Chain Management: An International Journal | |||||||||
| (7) Ciliberti et al. (2011) | Journal of Cleaner Production | PAT | CS | CS | ||||||
| (8) De Magistris et al. (2015) | The Journal of Consumer Affairs | T | ||||||||
| (9) Fuentes-García et al. (2008) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (10) Gilbert and Rasche (2007) | Business Ethics Quarterly | CO | ||||||||
| (11) Gilbert and Rasche (2008) | Journal of Business Ethics | Stakeholder | ||||||||
| (12) Henkle (2005) | Journal of Organisational Excellence | |||||||||
| (13) Koerber (2010) | Journal of Business Ethics | |||||||||
| (14) Koplin et al. (2007) | Journal of Cleaner Production | |||||||||
| (15) Meehan et al. (2006) | International Journal of Social Economics | CO | ||||||||
| (16) Merli et al. (2015) | Sustainability | T | T | |||||||
| (17) Miles and Munilla (2004) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | CO | |||||||
| (18) Miles et al. (2006) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | CO | |||||||
| (19) Rasche and Esser (2006) | Journal of Business Ethics | |||||||||
| (20) Rasche (2009) | Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| (21) Rasche (2010a) | Business Ethics: A European Review | CO | CO | |||||||
| (22) Rasche (2010b) | Corporate Governance | CO | CO | |||||||
| (23) Reynolds and Yuthas (2008) | Journal of Business Ethics | CO | ||||||||
| (24) Rohitratana (2002) | Managerial Auditing Journal | CS | ||||||||
| (25) Ruževičius et al. (2007) | Engineering Economics | CS | CS | |||||||
| (26) Salomone (2008) | Journal of Cleaner Production | CSa | ||||||||
| (27) Stigzelius and Mark-Herbert (2009) | Scandinavian Journal of Management | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (28) Tencati and Zsolnai (2009) | Journal of Business Ethics | CS | CS | |||||||
| (29) Wang (2008) | Asian Social Science | CO | ||||||||
| (30) Werre (2003) | Journal of Business Ethics | CS | ||||||||
| (31) Zhao et al. (2012) | Journal of Cleaner Production | Stakeholder | CO | CO | ||||||
| (32 ) Zutshi et al. (2009) | European Business Review | CO | CO | |||||||
| Operational | Market | |||||||||
| + | + | + | + | – | – | + | + | |||
| Underpinning theory | Improvement of working conditions | Increase of personnel productivity | Improvement of product quality | Cost reduction | Higher cost (obtaining and maintaining the certification) | Constrains in supplier selection | Improvement of firm reputation | Increase of customer satisfaction | ||
| (1) | Stakeholder | Ta | Ta | |||||||
| (2) | CO | |||||||||
| (3) Beske | CO | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (4) | CO | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (5) | TCE | CO | ||||||||
| (6) | CS | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (7) | PAT | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | |||
| (8) De Magistris | ||||||||||
| (9) | CO | |||||||||
| (10) | CO | CO | CO | |||||||
| (11) | Stakeholder | CO | CO | |||||||
| (12) | CS | CS | CS | |||||||
| (13) | CO | |||||||||
| (14) | CS | |||||||||
| (15) | ||||||||||
| (16) | T | T | ||||||||
| (17) | CO | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (18) | CO | |||||||||
| (19) | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (20) | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| (21) | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| (22) | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| (23) Reynolds and Yuthas (2008) | CO | |||||||||
| (24) | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | CS | ||||
| (25) Ruževičius | CS | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (26) | CSa | CSa | ||||||||
| (27) | CS | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (28) | CS | CS | CS | CS | ||||||
| (29) | CO | CO | CO | |||||||
| (30) | CS | CS | CS | |||||||
| (31) | Stakeholder | CO | CO | CO | CO | |||||
| (32 ) | CO | CO | CO | CO | ||||||
| Market | Innovation | Others | ||||||||
| – | + | + | + | + | + | |||||
| Underpinning theory | Poor knowledge of the standard by the customers | Willingness to pay | Sales increase | Increase of the level of technical products innovation | Increase of the level of organisational innovation | Easier access to credit | Improvement of the relationships with the stakeholders | |||
| (1) | Stakeholder | Ta | Ta | Ta | Ta | Ta | ||||
| (2) | CO | |||||||||
| (3) Beske | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (4) | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (5) | TCE | CO | ||||||||
| (6) | ||||||||||
| (7) | PAT | CS | CS | |||||||
| (8) De Magistris | T | |||||||||
| (9) | CO | |||||||||
| (10) | CO | |||||||||
| (11) Gilbert and Rasche (2008) | Stakeholder | |||||||||
| (12) | ||||||||||
| (13) | ||||||||||
| (14) | ||||||||||
| (15) | CO | |||||||||
| (16) | T | T | ||||||||
| (17) | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (18) | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (19) | ||||||||||
| (20) | CO | CO | CO | |||||||
| (21) | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (22) | CO | CO | ||||||||
| (23) | CO | |||||||||
| (24) | CS | |||||||||
| (25) Ruževičius | CS | CS | ||||||||
| (26) | CSa | |||||||||
| (27) | CS | CS | CS | |||||||
| (28) | CS | CS | ||||||||
| (29) | CO | |||||||||
| (30) | CS | |||||||||
| (31) | Stakeholder | CO | CO | |||||||
| (32 ) | CO | CO | ||||||||
Notes: TCE, transaction cost economics; PAT, principal agency theory; Stakeholder, stakeholder theory; CO, conceptual hypothesis; CS, case study-based hypothesis; T, empirically tested hypothesis. +, positive effect; –, negative effect. aSA8000 considered with other ethical standards/management systems
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.