Table A1 Code descriptors for feedback... | Emerald Publishing

Table A1

Code descriptors for feedback

Code	Descriptor	Example
Content: Insufficient details/information	Feedback on students’ inadequate details	Great work and I hope you can add 3–4 full sentences explaining these results in the diagram
Irrelevance of ideas	Feedback on students’ irrelevant ideas or details	Remove this sentence since it is not related to your topic
Clear expression of ideas	Feedback on the issue of lacking clarity of idea expression and redundancies	This sentence seems confusing: “This study will ……… inflectional morphemes”. Can u re-write it clearly about what morphological features u found in the data?
Organization: overall structure	Feedback on the structure of the assignment	Please where is your conclusion? You should have one section as a conclusion of your assignment
Paragraphing	Feedback on issues related to the logical transition of paragraphs, order of sentences and use of cohesion devices	One important point is to move this paragraph after the 1^st paragraph
Inaccurate grammar	Feedback on grammatical errors/mistakes, such as the use of tense, subject-verb agreement, aspect, prepositions, articles and so on	Sure “expresses”? Why so while the subject is plural? Please, check it
Inaccurate sentence structure	Feedback on inaccurate sentence structures	You have 2 sentences not one sentence. You should either separate them or combine them
Inappropriate vocabulary choice	Feedback on students’ choice of inappropriate vocabulary	Are you sure the grammatical function? or you mean the word class?
Misspelling	Feedback on inaccurate spelling	Correct spellings of this word
Inappropriate punctuation	Feedback on the misuse of punctuation	A missing full stop here
APA Formatting	Feedback on citation, references, quotations, headings, sub-headings, tables, space, page numbers, etc.	Change this sub-heading as Morphological Properties/Features Check your citation here (APA)

Code	Descriptor	Example
Content: Insufficient details/information	Feedback on students’ inadequate details	Great work and I hope you can add 3–4 full sentences explaining these results in the diagram
Irrelevance of ideas	Feedback on students’ irrelevant ideas or details	Remove this sentence since it is not related to your topic
Clear expression of ideas	Feedback on the issue of lacking clarity of idea expression and redundancies	This sentence seems confusing: “This study will ……… inflectional morphemes”. Can u re-write it clearly about what morphological features u found in the data?
Organization: overall structure	Feedback on the structure of the assignment	Please where is your conclusion? You should have one section as a conclusion of your assignment
Paragraphing	Feedback on issues related to the logical transition of paragraphs, order of sentences and use of cohesion devices	One important point is to move this paragraph after the 1^st paragraph
Inaccurate grammar	Feedback on grammatical errors/mistakes, such as the use of tense, subject-verb agreement, aspect, prepositions, articles and so on	Sure “expresses”? Why so while the subject is plural? Please, check it
Inaccurate sentence structure	Feedback on inaccurate sentence structures	You have 2 sentences not one sentence. You should either separate them or combine them
Inappropriate vocabulary choice	Feedback on students’ choice of inappropriate vocabulary	Are you sure the grammatical function? or you mean the word class?
Misspelling	Feedback on inaccurate spelling	Correct spellings of this word
Inappropriate punctuation	Feedback on the misuse of punctuation	A missing full stop here
APA Formatting	Feedback on citation, references, quotations, headings, sub-headings, tables, space, page numbers, etc.	Change this sub-heading as Morphological Properties/FeaturesCheck your citation here (APA)