Table 5 Evaluating the CSFs against... | Emerald Publishing

Table 5

Evaluating the CSFs against existing SETA program effectiveness literature

Phase	CSF	Alshaikh et al. (2018)	Alshaikh et al. (2021)	Kirova and Baumöl (2018)	Silic and Lowry (2020)
Design	CSF-DS1: Conduct an Initial Assessment of Employee Security Awareness	X	X
	CSF-DS2: Know Your Audiences to Ensure Content Suitability		X	X
	CSF-DS3: Make a Yearly Plan to Align Goals and Objectives	X	X
	CSF-DS4: Design for Cultural Context and Employee Cultural Diversity			X
	CSF-DS5: Adhere to Organizational Security Policy and the “Law of the Land”	X
	CSF-DS6: Build Security Awareness Campaigns	X	X
Development	CSF-DV1: Sustained Communication of Relevant Messages			X
Implementation	CSF-IM1: Apply Diverse Methods to Deliver Security Awareness Messages	X	X		X
Implementation	CSF-IM2: Motivate Employees to Engage in Security Awareness	X		X	X
Evaluation	CSF-EV1: Maintain Quarterly Evaluation of Employee Performance	X		X
Evaluation	CSF-EV2: Measure Employee Reporting of Security Incidents	X
	*Total*	8	5	5	2

Phase	CSF	Alshaikh et al. (2018)	Alshaikh et al. (2021)	Kirova and Baumöl (2018)	Silic and Lowry (2020)
Design	CSF-DS1: Conduct an Initial Assessment of Employee Security Awareness	X	X
	CSF-DS2: Know Your Audiences to Ensure Content Suitability		X	X
	CSF-DS3: Make a Yearly Plan to Align Goals and Objectives	X	X
	CSF-DS4: Design for Cultural Context and Employee Cultural Diversity			X
	CSF-DS5: Adhere to Organizational Security Policy and the “Law of the Land”	X
	CSF-DS6: Build Security Awareness Campaigns	X	X
Development	CSF-DV1: Sustained Communication of Relevant Messages			X
Implementation	CSF-IM1: Apply Diverse Methods to Deliver Security Awareness Messages	X	X		X
Implementation	CSF-IM2: Motivate Employees to Engage in Security Awareness	X		X	X
Evaluation	CSF-EV1: Maintain Quarterly Evaluation of Employee Performance	X		X
Evaluation	CSF-EV2: Measure Employee Reporting of Security Incidents	X
	Total	8	5	5	2

Source(s): Authors' own creation/work