Table 9. Evaluation of reshoring...

Table 9.

Evaluation of reshoring scenarios based on outputs from AHP and fuzzy-AHP

Scenarios	Cost	Quality	Time	Flexibility	Innovation	Sustainability	Expert opinion	AHP out-put (O₁)	Decision from AHP	Fuzzy-AHP output (O₂)	Decision from fuzzy-AHP	Absolute error e
1	−5	−1	−3	−2	−3	3	−5	−2.49	Do not evaluate	−2.87	Do not evaluate	0.38
2	2	5	−1	3	4	1	4	3.21	Evaluate	3.22	Evaluate	0.01
3	−3	−4	−3	−1	4	−1	−4	−2.56	Do not evaluate	−2.75	Do not evaluate	0.19
4	3	−4	−1	−3	−5	−3	−4	−1.67	Do not evaluate	−1.14	Do not evaluate	0.53
5	−4	−2	5	−1	−1	5	−4	−1.57	Do not evaluate	−2.10	Do not evaluate	0.53
6	4	2	−4	2	2	−5	4	1.84	Evaluate	2.32	Evaluate	0.48
7	−4	2	1	2	2	5	4	0.26	Evaluate	−0.34a	Do not evaluate	0.60
8	2	−1	3	−1	1	5	3	0.58	Evaluate	0.57	Evaluate	0.01
9	3	5	5	2	5	−3	5	3.92	Evaluate	4.03	Evaluate	0.11
10	−3	−5	3	−2	5	−2	−4	−2.47	Do not evaluate	−2.73	Do not evaluate	0.26
11	−3	5	5	3	5	−3	4	2.26	Evaluate	1.84	Evaluate	0.42
12	1	−5	1	1	1	−5	3	−1.66a	Do not evaluate	−1.43a	Do not evaluate	0.23
13	−5	1	−5	−5	−5	1	−3	−2.34	Do not evaluate	−2.57	Do not evaluate	0.23
14	5	−1	5	5	5	−1	3	2.34	Evaluate	2.57	Evaluate	0.23
15	−1	5	−1	−1	−1	5	−3	1.66^a	Evaluate	1.43^a	Evaluate	0.23
16	0	0	0	0	0	0	−3	0.00	Do not evaluate	0.00	Do not evaluate	0.00
17	3	−4	2	−2	−2	2	−3	−0.90	Do not evaluate	−0.66	Do not evaluate	0.24
18	−5	0	3	5	5	4	3	−0.18a	Do not evaluate	−0.94a	Do not evaluate	0.76
19	−5	4	2	−1	−4	3	−3	0.03^a	Evaluate	−0.48	Do not evaluate	0.51
20	−2	−5	−5	−2	−5	5	−5	−3.57	Do not evaluate	−3.65	Do not evaluate	0.08

Scenarios	Cost	Quality	Time	Flexibility	Innovation	Sustainability	Expertopinion	AHPout-put (O₁)	Decisionfrom AHP	Fuzzy-AHPoutput (O₂)	Decision fromfuzzy-AHP	Absoluteerror e
1	−5	−1	−3	−2	−3	3	−5	−2.49	Do not evaluate	−2.87	Do not evaluate	0.38
2	2	5	−1	3	4	1	4	3.21	Evaluate	3.22	Evaluate	0.01
3	−3	−4	−3	−1	4	−1	−4	−2.56	Do not evaluate	−2.75	Do not evaluate	0.19
4	3	−4	−1	−3	−5	−3	−4	−1.67	Do not evaluate	−1.14	Do not evaluate	0.53
5	−4	−2	5	−1	−1	5	−4	−1.57	Do not evaluate	−2.10	Do not evaluate	0.53
6	4	2	−4	2	2	−5	4	1.84	Evaluate	2.32	Evaluate	0.48
7	−4	2	1	2	2	5	4	0.26	Evaluate	−0.34a	Do not evaluate	0.60
8	2	−1	3	−1	1	5	3	0.58	Evaluate	0.57	Evaluate	0.01
9	3	5	5	2	5	−3	5	3.92	Evaluate	4.03	Evaluate	0.11
10	−3	−5	3	−2	5	−2	−4	−2.47	Do not evaluate	−2.73	Do not evaluate	0.26
11	−3	5	5	3	5	−3	4	2.26	Evaluate	1.84	Evaluate	0.42
12	1	−5	1	1	1	−5	3	−1.66a	Do not evaluate	−1.43a	Do not evaluate	0.23
13	−5	1	−5	−5	−5	1	−3	−2.34	Do not evaluate	−2.57	Do not evaluate	0.23
14	5	−1	5	5	5	−1	3	2.34	Evaluate	2.57	Evaluate	0.23
15	−1	5	−1	−1	−1	5	−3	1.66^a	Evaluate	1.43^a	Evaluate	0.23
16	0	0	0	0	0	0	−3	0.00	Do not evaluate	0.00	Do not evaluate	0.00
17	3	−4	2	−2	−2	2	−3	−0.90	Do not evaluate	−0.66	Do not evaluate	0.24
18	−5	0	3	5	5	4	3	−0.18a	Do not evaluate	−0.94a	Do not evaluate	0.76
19	−5	4	2	−1	−4	3	−3	0.03^a	Evaluate	−0.48	Do not evaluate	0.51
20	−2	−5	−5	−2	−5	5	−5	−3.57	Do not evaluate	−3.65	Do not evaluate	0.08

Note:

^aConflict in decision between output from the tool and the experts

Sharing Unavailable