Obstacle value of China’s low-carbon competitiveness in index layer
| Indicators order | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | 2009 | 2011 | 2013 | ||||||||||
| Region | Item | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
| Beijing | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C17 | C22 | C20 | C17 | C12 | C12 | C20 | C17 | C12 | C17 | C20 |
| Tianjin | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C8 | C23 | C8 | C20 | C23 | C20 | C24 | C12 | C20 | C23 | C24 |
| Hebei | Obstacle indicators | C24 | C1 | C7 | C24 | C7 | C17 | C17 | C7 | C1 | C17 | C1 | C6 |
| Shanxi | Obstacle indicators | C4 | C10 | C25 | C4 | C10 | C24 | C10 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C2 | C18 |
| Inner Mongolia | Obstacle indicators | C10 | C7 | C23 | C10 | C7 | C17 | C10 | C17 | C12 | C2 | C10 | C17 |
| Liaoning | Obstacle indicators | C2 | C20 | C17 | C20 | C17 | C10 | C17 | C1 | C8 | C17 | C1 | C8 |
| Jilin | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C24 | C12 | C20 | C24 | C25 | C20 | C23 | C12 | C17 | C12 | C1 |
| Heilongjiang | Obstacle indicators | C14 | C24 | C23 | C14 | C23 | C7 | C23 | C14 | C12 | C7 | C17 | C24 |
| Shanghai | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C19 | C8 | C8 | C20 | C22 | C8 | C21 | C20 | C8 | C21 | C20 |
| Jiangsu | Obstacle indicators | C19 | C20 | C1 | C20 | C19 | C1 | C20 | C19 | C1 | C20 | C19 | C1 |
| Zhejiang | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C17 | C8 | C20 | C9 | C17 | C20 | C17 | C8 | C20 | C17 | C8 |
| Anhui | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C17 | C3 | C20 | C17 | C10 | C1 | C20 | C17 | C1 | C17 | C3 |
| Fujian | Obstacle indicators | C8 | C20 | C17 | C20 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C8 | C18 | C17 | C20 | C18 |
| Jiangxi | Obstacle indicators | C1 | C7 | C23 | C7 | C23 | C18 | C23 | C1 | C7 | C17 | C1 | C10 |
| Shandong | Obstacle indicators | C1 | C8 | C19 | C1 | C10 | C7 | C1 | C17 | C19 | C17 | C19 | C1 |
| Henan | Obstacle indicators | C1 | C17 | C10 | C1 | C10 | C17 | C1 | C21 | C17 | C1 | C17 | C10 |
| Hubei | Obstacle indicators | C23 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C23 | C7 | C23 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C1 | C21 |
| Hunan | Obstacle indicators | C21 | C23 | C17 | C23 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C12 | C18 | C17 | C18 | C7 |
| Guangdong | Obstacle indicators | C5 | C8 | C20 | C5 | C20 | C17 | C17 | C20 | C12 | C17 | C20 | C21 |
| Guangxi | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C3 | C8 | C17 | C7 | C3 | C17 | C1 | C10 | C17 | C1 | C10 |
| Hainan | Obstacle indicators | C21 | C12 | C23 | C21 | C25 | C23 | C21 | C23 | C24 | C15 | C21 | C25 |
| Chongqing | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C25 | C12 | C17 | C10 | C12 | C17 | C12 | C22 | C17 | C12 | C23 |
| Sichuan | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C23 | C7 | C17 | C7 | C23 | C17 | C23 | C1 | C17 | C1 | C3 |
| Guizhou | Obstacle indicators | C3 | C11 | C16 | C3 | C25 | C16 | C3 | C11 | C17 | C3 | C17 | C18 |
| Yunnan | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C25 | C3 | C17 | C3 | C18 | C17 | C3 | C18 | C17 | C3 | C18 |
| Tibet | Obstacle indicators | C7 | C9 | C12 | C7 | C23 | C12 | C23 | C12 | C13 | C7 | C21 | C15 |
| Shaanxi | Obstacle indicators | C24 | C17 | C23 | C17 | C13 | C18 | C17 | C12 | C18 | C17 | C1 | C18 |
| Gansu | Obstacle indicators | C23 | C2 | C18 | C18 | C25 | C23 | C14 | C23 | C18 | C14 | C3 | C17 |
| Qinghai | Obstacle indicators | C18 | C25 | C22 | C18 | C19 | C23 | C7 | C15 | C18 | C6 | C23 | C24 |
| Ningxia | Obstacle indicators | C6 | C9 | C2 | C6 | C22 | C23 | C2 | C4 | C6 | C4 | C22 | C23 |
| Xinjiang | Obstacle indicators | C19 | C25 | C17 | C2 | C19 | C17 | C19 | C18 | C12 | C19 | C17 | C12 |
| Indicators order | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | 2009 | 2011 | 2013 | ||||||||||
| Region | Item | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
| Beijing | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C17 | C22 | C20 | C17 | C12 | C12 | C20 | C17 | C12 | C17 | C20 |
| Tianjin | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C8 | C23 | C8 | C20 | C23 | C20 | C24 | C12 | C20 | C23 | C24 |
| Hebei | Obstacle indicators | C24 | C1 | C7 | C24 | C7 | C17 | C17 | C7 | C1 | C17 | C1 | C6 |
| Shanxi | Obstacle indicators | C4 | C10 | C25 | C4 | C10 | C24 | C10 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C2 | C18 |
| Inner Mongolia | Obstacle indicators | C10 | C7 | C23 | C10 | C7 | C17 | C10 | C17 | C12 | C2 | C10 | C17 |
| Liaoning | Obstacle indicators | C2 | C20 | C17 | C20 | C17 | C10 | C17 | C1 | C8 | C17 | C1 | C8 |
| Jilin | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C24 | C12 | C20 | C24 | C25 | C20 | C23 | C12 | C17 | C12 | C1 |
| Heilongjiang | Obstacle indicators | C14 | C24 | C23 | C14 | C23 | C7 | C23 | C14 | C12 | C7 | C17 | C24 |
| Shanghai | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C19 | C8 | C8 | C20 | C22 | C8 | C21 | C20 | C8 | C21 | C20 |
| Jiangsu | Obstacle indicators | C19 | C20 | C1 | C20 | C19 | C1 | C20 | C19 | C1 | C20 | C19 | C1 |
| Zhejiang | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C17 | C8 | C20 | C9 | C17 | C20 | C17 | C8 | C20 | C17 | C8 |
| Anhui | Obstacle indicators | C20 | C17 | C3 | C20 | C17 | C10 | C1 | C20 | C17 | C1 | C17 | C3 |
| Fujian | Obstacle indicators | C8 | C20 | C17 | C20 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C8 | C18 | C17 | C20 | C18 |
| Jiangxi | Obstacle indicators | C1 | C7 | C23 | C7 | C23 | C18 | C23 | C1 | C7 | C17 | C1 | C10 |
| Shandong | Obstacle indicators | C1 | C8 | C19 | C1 | C10 | C7 | C1 | C17 | C19 | C17 | C19 | C1 |
| Henan | Obstacle indicators | C1 | C17 | C10 | C1 | C10 | C17 | C1 | C21 | C17 | C1 | C17 | C10 |
| Hubei | Obstacle indicators | C23 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C23 | C7 | C23 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C1 | C21 |
| Hunan | Obstacle indicators | C21 | C23 | C17 | C23 | C17 | C18 | C17 | C12 | C18 | C17 | C18 | C7 |
| Guangdong | Obstacle indicators | C5 | C8 | C20 | C5 | C20 | C17 | C17 | C20 | C12 | C17 | C20 | C21 |
| Guangxi | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C3 | C8 | C17 | C7 | C3 | C17 | C1 | C10 | C17 | C1 | C10 |
| Hainan | Obstacle indicators | C21 | C12 | C23 | C21 | C25 | C23 | C21 | C23 | C24 | C15 | C21 | C25 |
| Chongqing | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C25 | C12 | C17 | C10 | C12 | C17 | C12 | C22 | C17 | C12 | C23 |
| Sichuan | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C23 | C7 | C17 | C7 | C23 | C17 | C23 | C1 | C17 | C1 | C3 |
| Guizhou | Obstacle indicators | C3 | C11 | C16 | C3 | C25 | C16 | C3 | C11 | C17 | C3 | C17 | C18 |
| Yunnan | Obstacle indicators | C17 | C25 | C3 | C17 | C3 | C18 | C17 | C3 | C18 | C17 | C3 | C18 |
| Tibet | Obstacle indicators | C7 | C9 | C12 | C7 | C23 | C12 | C23 | C12 | C13 | C7 | C21 | C15 |
| Shaanxi | Obstacle indicators | C24 | C17 | C23 | C17 | C13 | C18 | C17 | C12 | C18 | C17 | C1 | C18 |
| Gansu | Obstacle indicators | C23 | C2 | C18 | C18 | C25 | C23 | C14 | C23 | C18 | C14 | C3 | C17 |
| Qinghai | Obstacle indicators | C18 | C25 | C22 | C18 | C19 | C23 | C7 | C15 | C18 | C6 | C23 | C24 |
| Ningxia | Obstacle indicators | C6 | C9 | C2 | C6 | C22 | C23 | C2 | C4 | C6 | C4 | C22 | C23 |
| Xinjiang | Obstacle indicators | C19 | C25 | C17 | C2 | C19 | C17 | C19 | C18 | C12 | C19 | C17 | C12 |