Aggregate fuzzy opinion and defuzzified score
| Sustainability dimensions | Indicators (k) | Aggregate fuzzy opinion | Defuzzified score (Sk) | Selected | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Min (lk) | Optimum (mk) | Max (uk) | ||||
| Economic | Profit | 5.613 | 7.613 | 8.749 | 7.325 | Y |
| Revenue | 4.962 | 6.962 | 8.642 | 6.856 | Y | |
| R&D expenditure | 4.978 | 6.965 | 8.297 | 6.747 | Y | |
| Material cost | 4.463 | 6.448 | 8.229 | 6.380 | Y | |
| Labor cost | 4.618 | 6.618 | 8.230 | 6.488 | Y | |
| Energy cost | 4.024 | 6.024 | 7.871 | 5.973 | – | |
| Maintenance cost | 3.645 | 5.561 | 7.469 | 5.559 | – | |
| Packaging cost | 3.150 | 5.097 | 7.071 | 5.106 | – | |
| Inventory cost | 3.422 | 5.316 | 7.289 | 5.342 | – | |
| Product quality | 6.642 | 8.642 | 8.987 | 8.091 | Y | |
| Lead time | 6.167 | 8.167 | 8.885 | 7.740 | Y | |
| On-time delivery | 6.480 | 8.480 | 8.972 | 7.978 | Y | |
| Environmental | Water consumption | 2.852 | 4.265 | 5.954 | 4.357 | – |
| Recycled water use | 2.909 | 4.193 | 5.939 | 4.347 | – | |
| Energy consumption | 4.435 | 6.376 | 8.043 | 6.285 | Y | |
| Renewable energy use | 4.162 | 6.121 | 7.674 | 5.986 | – | |
| Energy efficiency | 4.945 | 6.912 | 8.209 | 6.688 | Y | |
| Energy intensity | 3.795 | 5.722 | 7.505 | 5.674 | – | |
| Material consumption | 5.186 | 7.186 | 8.460 | 6.944 | Y | |
| Recycled material use | 4.943 | 6.928 | 8.351 | 6.740 | Y | |
| Packaging material consumption | 4.337 | 6.251 | 7.949 | 6.179 | – | |
| Land use | 2.652 | 4.332 | 6.143 | 4.376 | – | |
| GHG emissions | 3.406 | 5.250 | 6.755 | 5.137 | – | |
| Wastewater discharge | 2.844 | 4.534 | 6.247 | 4.542 | – | |
| Solid waste disposal | 3.880 | 5.834 | 7.575 | 5.763 | – | |
| Recyclable waste | 3.946 | 5.897 | 7.419 | 5.754 | – | |
| Social | Employment/Job opportunity | 5.245 | 7.245 | 8.774 | 7.088 | Y |
| Fair salary | 5.642 | 7.642 | 8.773 | 7.352 | Y | |
| Employee turnover | 4.465 | 6.448 | 8.056 | 6.323 | Y | |
| Employee satisfaction | 5.993 | 7.993 | 8.902 | 7.630 | Y | |
| Occupational health and safety | 6.133 | 8.133 | 8.873 | 7.713 | Y | |
| Training and development | 5.161 | 7.161 | 8.737 | 7.020 | Y | |
| Working conditions | 6.376 | 8.376 | 8.903 | 7.885 | Y | |
| Work-related injuries | 6.029 | 8.029 | 8.873 | 7.644 | Y | |
| Working hours | 5.001 | 7.001 | 8.497 | 6.833 | Y | |
| Lost working days | 4.449 | 6.449 | 8.074 | 6.324 | Y | |
| Customer health and safety | 6.001 | 7.994 | 8.824 | 7.607 | Y | |
| Customer satisfaction | 6.838 | 8.838 | 8.988 | 8.221 | Y | |
| Customer complaints | 6.252 | 8.252 | 8.934 | 7.813 | Y | |
| Corruption | 4.544 | 6.278 | 7.669 | 6.164 | – | |
| Sustainability dimensions | Indicators (k) | Aggregate fuzzy opinion | Defuzzified score (Sk) | Selected | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Min (lk) | Optimum (mk) | Max (uk) | ||||
| Economic | Profit | 5.613 | 7.613 | 8.749 | 7.325 | Y |
| Revenue | 4.962 | 6.962 | 8.642 | 6.856 | Y | |
| R&D expenditure | 4.978 | 6.965 | 8.297 | 6.747 | Y | |
| Material cost | 4.463 | 6.448 | 8.229 | 6.380 | Y | |
| Labor cost | 4.618 | 6.618 | 8.230 | 6.488 | Y | |
| Energy cost | 4.024 | 6.024 | 7.871 | 5.973 | – | |
| Maintenance cost | 3.645 | 5.561 | 7.469 | 5.559 | – | |
| Packaging cost | 3.150 | 5.097 | 7.071 | 5.106 | – | |
| Inventory cost | 3.422 | 5.316 | 7.289 | 5.342 | – | |
| Product quality | 6.642 | 8.642 | 8.987 | 8.091 | Y | |
| Lead time | 6.167 | 8.167 | 8.885 | 7.740 | Y | |
| On-time delivery | 6.480 | 8.480 | 8.972 | 7.978 | Y | |
| Environmental | Water consumption | 2.852 | 4.265 | 5.954 | 4.357 | – |
| Recycled water use | 2.909 | 4.193 | 5.939 | 4.347 | – | |
| Energy consumption | 4.435 | 6.376 | 8.043 | 6.285 | Y | |
| Renewable energy use | 4.162 | 6.121 | 7.674 | 5.986 | – | |
| Energy efficiency | 4.945 | 6.912 | 8.209 | 6.688 | Y | |
| Energy intensity | 3.795 | 5.722 | 7.505 | 5.674 | – | |
| Material consumption | 5.186 | 7.186 | 8.460 | 6.944 | Y | |
| Recycled material use | 4.943 | 6.928 | 8.351 | 6.740 | Y | |
| Packaging material consumption | 4.337 | 6.251 | 7.949 | 6.179 | – | |
| Land use | 2.652 | 4.332 | 6.143 | 4.376 | – | |
| GHG emissions | 3.406 | 5.250 | 6.755 | 5.137 | – | |
| Wastewater discharge | 2.844 | 4.534 | 6.247 | 4.542 | – | |
| Solid waste disposal | 3.880 | 5.834 | 7.575 | 5.763 | – | |
| Recyclable waste | 3.946 | 5.897 | 7.419 | 5.754 | – | |
| Social | Employment/Job opportunity | 5.245 | 7.245 | 8.774 | 7.088 | Y |
| Fair salary | 5.642 | 7.642 | 8.773 | 7.352 | Y | |
| Employee turnover | 4.465 | 6.448 | 8.056 | 6.323 | Y | |
| Employee satisfaction | 5.993 | 7.993 | 8.902 | 7.630 | Y | |
| Occupational health and safety | 6.133 | 8.133 | 8.873 | 7.713 | Y | |
| Training and development | 5.161 | 7.161 | 8.737 | 7.020 | Y | |
| Working conditions | 6.376 | 8.376 | 8.903 | 7.885 | Y | |
| Work-related injuries | 6.029 | 8.029 | 8.873 | 7.644 | Y | |
| Working hours | 5.001 | 7.001 | 8.497 | 6.833 | Y | |
| Lost working days | 4.449 | 6.449 | 8.074 | 6.324 | Y | |
| Customer health and safety | 6.001 | 7.994 | 8.824 | 7.607 | Y | |
| Customer satisfaction | 6.838 | 8.838 | 8.988 | 8.221 | Y | |
| Customer complaints | 6.252 | 8.252 | 8.934 | 7.813 | Y | |
| Corruption | 4.544 | 6.278 | 7.669 | 6.164 | – | |
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.