A summary of our research methodology and data analysis
| Year and sequence | Theoretical arguments | External structure and change | Internal structure and change | Agency (action) | Political accountability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Up–2007 | Argument 1 | Independent | Unreflective Habitus | Routine | Intended but ceremonial |
| Sequence 1 | Enabling | ||||
| 2007–2011 | Argument 2 | Irresistible | Unreflective | Non-routine (somehow disorganised) | Unintended, ceremonial, and problematic |
| Sequence 2 | Constraining | Habitus failure | |||
| 2012–2013 | Argument 3 | Enabling (Subsequence 1) | Reflective | Strategic (but not yet routine) | Intended and instrumental |
| Sequence 3 | Irresistible (Subsequence 2) | Critical | Strategic (but not yet routine) | Non-intended and instrumental | |
| 2015 | Follow-up of | Independent | Reflective | Strategic | Intended, instrumental, and gradually stable |
| Sequence 4 | argument 3 | Enabling | Critical | (but not yet routine) |
| Year and sequence | Theoretical arguments | External structure and change | Internal structure and change | Agency (action) | Political accountability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Up–2007 | Argument 1 | Independent | Unreflective Habitus | Routine | Intended but ceremonial |
| Sequence 1 | Enabling | ||||
| 2007–2011 | Argument 2 | Irresistible | Unreflective | Non-routine (somehow disorganised) | Unintended, ceremonial, and problematic |
| Sequence 2 | Constraining | Habitus failure | |||
| 2012–2013 | Argument 3 | Enabling (Subsequence 1) | Reflective | Strategic (but not yet routine) | Intended and instrumental |
| Sequence 3 | Irresistible (Subsequence 2) | Critical | Strategic (but not yet routine) | Non-intended and instrumental | |
| 2015 | Follow-up of | Independent | Reflective | Strategic | Intended, instrumental, and gradually stable |
| Sequence 4 | argument 3 | Enabling | Critical | (but not yet routine) |
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.