Table 6

Analysis of time symmetry (ROE)

ROE06ROE07ROE08ROE09ROE10ROE11ROE12ROE13ROE14ROE15ROE16ROE17
Slack2006CR5.265***
(1.606)
10.792+
(6.036)
14.151*
(5.766)
−2.509
(6.959)
−5.830
(6.889)
−1.098
(1.230)
2.970
(1.904)
2.736+
(1.644)
6.237***
(1.865)
3.692
(2.518)
7.681**
(2.452)
0.181
(1.076)
D/E3.625***
(0.416)
15.987***
(1.563)
8.126***
(1.494)
3.024+
(1.802)
−12.752***
(1.784)
−0.167
(0.318)
0.803
(0.493)
1.855***
(0.426)
4.676***
(0.483)
3.154***
(0.652)
7.777***
(0.635)
1.764***
(0.278)
PE/I−0.889***
(0.152)
0.150
(0.573)
−1.290*
(0.547)
−0.393
(0.660)
0.005
(0.653)
−0.199+
(0.116)
−0.383*
(0.180)
0.091
(0.156)
0.041
(0.177)
−0.680**
(0.239)
−0.338
(0.232)
−0.315**
(0.102)
Slack2007CR −3.901
(6.026)
−1.774
(5.466)
−4.109
(6.444)
2.872
(6.683)
−0.236
(1.136)
2.215
(1.715)
1.776
(1.530)
3.158+
(1.836)
1.193
(2.369)
2.308
(2.465)
−1.126
(1.018)
D/E −5.193***
(1.009)
2.571**
(0.915)
0.932
(1.079)
−2.545*
(1.119)
0.190
(0.190)
1.485***
(0.287)
0.949***
(0.256)
1.736***
(0.307)
1.181**
(0.396)
3.186***
(0.412)
0.753***
(0.170)
PE/I −0.378
(0.627)
−0.881
(0.569)
−0.508
(0.671)
−0.837
(0.696)
−0.196+
(0.118)
−0.245
(0.178)
0.132
(0.159)
0.179
(0.191)
−0.507*
(0.246)
−0.056
(0.256)
−0.225*
(0.106)
Slack2008CR  0.603
(2.683)
−1.641
(3.198)
0.185
(2.568)
0.048
(0.547)
0.837
(0.868)
0.333
(0.751)
0.744
(0.928)
0.874
(1.151)
0.951
(1.252)
−0.279
(0.503)
D/E  −2.792***
(0.626)
1.544*
(0.747)
−10.521***
(0.599)
0.684***
(0.127)
0.731***
(0.202)
0.946***
(0.175)
0.996***
(0.216)
1.503***
(0.268)
1.864***
(0.292)
0.590***
(0.117)
PE/I  −1.444**
(0.526)
−0.640
(0.627)
−1.305**
(0.504)
−0.240*
(0.107)
−0.351*
(0.170)
0.059
(0.147)
0.046
(0.182)
−0.517*
(0.226)
−0.233
(0.245)
−0.269**
(0.098)
Slack2009CR   −2.218
(2.765)
1.407
(3.572)
0.020
(0.600)
0.305
(0.929)
−0.117
(0.820)
0.536
(1.007)
−0.171
(1.268)
0.708
(1.385)
−0.682
(0.550)
D/E   −6.667***
(0.438)
0.012
(0.566)
0.154
(0.095)
0.374*
(0.147)
0.294*
(0.130)
0.248
(0.159)
0.314
(0.201)
0.344
(0.219)
0.046(0.087)
PE/I   −1.055*
(0.452)
−0.327
(0.584)
−0.264**
(0.098)
−0.402**
(0.151)
−0.098
(0.134)
−0.116
(0.164)
−0.473*
(0.207)
−0.414+
(0.226)
−0.273**
(0.090)
Slack2010CR    −1.318
(2.014)
−0.094
(0.890)
0.193
(1.386)
−0.493
(1.210)
0.864
(1.505)
−0.970
(1.891)
1.613
(2.073)
−0.758
(0.820)
D/E    −7.152***
(0.139)
0.171**
(0.061)
0.253**
(0.095)
0.325***
(0.083)
0.073
(0.104)
0.151
(0.130)
0.075
(0.143)
0.002
(0.056)
PE/I    −0.833***
(0.212)
−0.262**
(0.094)
−0.369*
(0.146)
−0.055
(0.127)
−0.122
(0.159)
−0.494*
(0.199)
−0.355
(0.219)
−0.307***
(0.086)
Slack2011CR     0.241
(0.690)
0.192
(1.028)
−0.346
(0.933)
0.544
(1.151)
−0.292
(1.455)
1.044
(1.594)
−0.233
(0.630)
D/E     0.032
(0.136)
1.292***
(0.202)
0.698***
(0.184)
0.576*
(0.226)
0.265
(0.286)
0.339
(0.314)
−0.125
(0.124)
PE/I     −0.328***
(0.100)
−0.335*
(0.149)
−0.015
(0.135)
−0.121
(0.167)
−0.576**
(0.211)
−0.403+
(0.231)
−0.369***
(0.091)
Slack2012CR      0.730
(1.062)
−0.493
(0.942)
1.117
(1.147)
−1.517
(1.403)
1.821
(1.579)
−0.407
(0.628)
D/E      −0.471
(0.647)
−0.923
(0.573)
1.496*
(0.698)
−4.784***
(0.854)
2.304*
(0.961)
−0.592
(0.382)
PE/I      −0.587***
(0.154)
−0.153
(0.137)
−0.250
(0.167)
−0.652**
(0.204)
−0.479*
(0.230)
−0.353***
(0.091)
Slack2013CR       −1.310
(0.942)
1.268
(1.258)
−1.678
(1.540)
2.833
(1.722)
−0.250
(0.688)
D/E       −5.569***
(0.591)
−0.522
(0.789)
−5.210***
(0.966)
2.795**
(1.081)
−0.502
(0.432)
PE/I       −0.347**
(0.127)
−0.385*
(0.170)
−0.743***
(0.209)
−0.598*
(0.233)
−0.388***
(0.093)
Slack2014CR        1.489
(1.128)
−0.934
(1.419)
3.014*
(1.468)
−0.119
(0.616)
D/E        0.622
(0.676)
−2.148*
(0.849)
6.557***
(0.879)
0.558
(0.369)
PE/I        −0.405*
(0.177)
−0.730***
(0.223)
−0.528*
(0.230)
−0.400***
(0.096)
Slack2015CR         −1.444
(1.265)
2.507+
(1.334)
−0.228
(0.567)
D/E         −4.909***
(0.672)
6.477***
(0.709)
1.070***
(0.301)
PE/I         −0.691***
(0.199)
−0.497*
(0.210)
−0.401***
(0.089)
Slack2016CR          3.600*
(1.464)
0.253
(0.602)
D/E          7.221***
(1.005)
1.384***
(0.413)
PE/I          −0.641**
(0.225)
−0.484***
(0.092)
Slack2017CR           −0.226
(0.486)
D/E           −3.839***
(0.349)
PE/I           −0.550***
(0.083)

Note(s): Standard errors in parentheses; +p < 0.10, *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001

or Create an Account

Close subscription notice
Close access options