Table I

EMS medical direction/ambulance service clinical governance (2000-2016)

CitationDesignCountryFocus of paperMajor findings (strengths and weaknesses)
Cushman et al. (2010)Retrospective cohortUSARapid-sequence intubationConcluded that close concurrent and retrospective physician oversight is associated with improved cognitive skills, although the observed changes were not causally linked to the intervention
Lee and Kim (2015) Surveys to EMS personnelSouth KoreaRecognition of medical direction in EMS personnel according to qualification levelEMT-basics and first responders have higher need for medical direction in an under-developed EMS system
Kim et al. (2015) Descriptive analysisSouth KoreaReport on the process and results of the newly implemented medical direction system“Patient evaluation” was the most common reason for EMTs to request medical direction
Fitzgerald (2014) Rhetorical genre theoryCanadaChallenges medical direction of paramedicsHidden values and assumptions (medical dominance) have delayed the adoption of a paramedic self-regulation model in Ontario
Millin et al. (2011) Literature reviewUSAPhysician roles in EMSClaimed that evidence for medical direction is evolving. Review of USA literature, excluded other countries
Nutbeam (2011) CommentaryUKClinical governance for out-of-hospital providers other than paramedicsNeed for clinicians supporting Ambulance Trusts to participate in clinical governance activities
Cunningham et al. (2010) CommentaryUSABenchmarking medical directionLimited snapshot of medical direction
Webb et al. (2010) DescriptiveUKClinical governance in a correctional institution where doctors, nurses and paramedics provide clinical careRisk management, with a regular review of clinical incidents is an essential part of clinical governance
Munk et al. (2009) Comparative studyUSAImprovement in EMS quality indicatorsMedical direction associated with improved clinical indicators and quality of care
Slifkin et al. (2009) SurveyUSAAssessment of rural-urban differences in medical directionRecruitment of medical directors is challenging in rural areas
Studnek et al. (2009) Survey of EMS professionalsUSAQuantifies the amount of direct contact between EMS professionals and medical directorsOne third of EMS providers had limited medical director contact
Busko et al. (2006) CommentaryUSAExamination of different models of medical directionMedical direction has not changed to reflect the needs of modern EMS. Non-refereed
Barnett et al. (2006) CommentaryWest IndiesPotential physician roles in the Caribbean EMS systemDerivative document
Mason et al. (2006) Survey and interviewsUKDescribes the development of Extended Care Practitioner programsAppropriate clinical governance is required
Porter (2005) DescriptiveUKCodes of practice for immediate care doctors in NHSMedical practitioners, working in the prehospital setting will be under the direction and clinical governance of paramedic services
Walker (2005) Case studyAustraliaParamedic response to meningococcal septicemiaImportance of strong clinical governance processes in a rural paramedic service
Tang and Fabbri (2003) CommentaryUSATactical EMS medical directionContinued development of physician leadership is apparent
Knott (2003) Telephone survey of rural EMS medical directorsUSAIdentification of issues faced by rural EMSMedical direction identified as an issue with integration in EMS seen as a possible solution. Survey restricted to medical directors
Baker (2003) ViewpointUKImplementation of clinical governanceAmbulance NHS Trusts may find introducing clinical governance necessary to avoid potential system failure
Gausche-Hill et al. (2003) Policy resource and education paperUSAGuidance to medical directorsDescribes the development of the federal EMS for Children Program, the importance of the integration, and discussed the role of the emergency physician in the Program
Benitez and Pepe (2002) Descriptive paperUSATrauma managementDescriptive account of the role of EMS medical directors in the USA and Canada
Peterson (2002) CommentaryUSARole of medical directorsDerivative document that provides a clear view on how out-of-hospital EMS fits into the overall emergency medical system in the USA non-refereed
O’Meara et al. (2001) DescriptiveAustraliaFormation of a new model for the recruitment and retention of rural paramedic service medical officersRecommended a more integrated approach to the paramedic service medical officer role. Restricted to one region in rural Australia
Stone et al. (2000) Interviews of medical directorsUSABaseline of EMS medical oversight in MarylandIncrease in medical director involvement required to meet national job description
Robertson-Steele et al. (2000) EvaluationUKState of prehospital care and how clinical governance can address problems of fragmentationMakes recommendations to improve quality and projects a future course of action
Cone et al. (2000) EMS medical directors in populous cities surveyed.USAAssess the availability of physician medical directors for field responseWide variability in the availability, training and scope of practice of physician field response units

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal