In-sample predictability (Brent as proxy for oil uncertainty)
| Sample period | Model-1 | Model-2 | Model-3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stock market uncertainty | Stock market uncertainty | Oil (Brent) market uncertainty | Stock market uncertainty | Oil (Brent) market uncertainty | Other global uncertainties | |
| Brazil | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0005*** [0.0001] | 0.0000 [0.0003] | 0.0030*** [0.0004] | 0.0009* [0.0005] | 0.0044*** [0.0006] | 0.0964*** [0.0064] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0071*** [0.0012] | 0.0043*** [0.0011] | 0.0153*** [0.0018] | 0.0009*** [0.0002] | 0.0154*** [0.0006] | 0.2810*** [0.0063] |
| COVID | 0.0057*** [0.0018] | 0.0091* [0.0046] | 0.0041*** [0.0010] | −0.0002 [0.0056] | 0.0046*** [0.0007] | 0.0741 [0.0591] |
| RUW | 0.0829*** [0.0076] | 0.1648*** [0.0343] | 0.1438*** [0.0139] | 0.1310*** [0.0220] | 0.0346 [0.0261] | 1.9378*** [0.5281] |
| China | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0015 [0.0010] | 0.0009 [0.0007] | 0.0003*** [0.0001] | 0.0014** [0.0006] | 0.0003* [0.0002] | 0.0394*** [0.0149] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0017* [0.0009] | 0.0113*** [0.0021] | 0.0064*** [0.0010] | 0.0139*** [0.0015] | 0.0058*** [0.0009] | 0.2976*** [0.0068] |
| COVID | −0.0449*** [0.0047] | −0.0603*** [0.0053] | −0.0020*** [0.0001] | −0.0473*** [0.0034] | 0.0003 [0.0003] | −0.4668*** [0.0267] |
| RUW | 0.0154 [0.0131] | 0.1377*** [0.0162] | −0.0292*** [0.0040] | 0.1617*** [0.0353] | −0.0533*** [0.0145] | 0.1540 [0.2228] |
| India | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0041*** [0.0008] | 0.0059*** [0.0011] | −0.0008** [0.0003] | 0.0031*** [0.0005] | −0.0003 [0.0003] | 0.0300*** [0.0035] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0026*** [0.0009] | 0.0066*** [0.0015] | −0.0055*** [0.0003] | 0.0099*** [0.0015] | −0.0065*** [0.0003] | 0.1285*** [0.0126] |
| COVID | −0.0200 [0.0135] | 0.0124 [0.0148] | −0.0015*** [0.0004] | −0.0528*** [0.0094] | −0.0004 [0.0010] | 0.3872*** [0.0803] |
| RUW | −0.0627 [0.0738] | 0.0822*** [0.0283] | 0.0860*** [0.0055] | −0.0167 [0.0298] | 0.0723*** [0.0050] | 0.5149*** [0.1454] |
| Indonesia | ||||||
| FULL | 0.5114*** [0.0201] | 0.5205*** [0.0206] | 0.0005*** [0.0002] | 0.5151*** [0.0205] | 0.0015*** [0.0003] | 0.1983*** [0.0096] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.5338*** [0.0275] | 0.5354*** [0.0239] | 0.0051*** [0.0011] | 0.5383*** [0.0247] | 0.0093*** [0.0023] | 0.1022*** [0.0221] |
| COVID | 0.4310*** [0.0383] | 0.4240*** [0.0392] | 0.0005 [0.0003] | 0.4177*** [0.0360] | 0.0004 [0.0004] | −0.1404** [0.0575] |
| RUW | 0.3158*** [0.0300] | 0.3587*** [0.0440] | 0.0106 [0.0125] | 0.1354*** [0.0421] | −0.0310*** [0.0047] | 2.0389*** [0.1765] |
| Russia | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0002 [0.0007] | −0.0004 [0.0011] | 0.0010*** [0.0001] | −0.0002 [0.0007] | 0.0009*** [0.0002] | 0.0956*** [0.0038] |
| Pre-COVID | −0.0015** [0.0006] | 0.0042*** [0.0014] | 0.0010 [0.0014] | 0.0007 [0.0015] | −0.0018* [0.0010] | 0.2155*** [0.0045] |
| COVID | −0.0207 [0.0142] | −0.0956*** [0.0162] | 0.0014*** [0.0002] | −0.0697*** [0.0157] | 0.0015*** [0.0001] | −0.0897* [0.0522] |
| RUW | 0.0529*** [0.0076] | 0.0563*** [0.0063] | −0.0139*** [0.0024] | 0.2312*** [0.0311] | −0.0365** [0.0141] | −5.4211*** [0.4801] |
| South Africa | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0057*** [0.0004] | 0.0068*** [0.0006] | 0.0010*** [0.0003] | 0.0055*** [0.0006] | 0.0024*** [0.0004] | 0.0564*** [0.0027] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0037*** [0.0012] | 0.0063*** [0.0007] | −0.0035*** [0.0011] | 0.0071*** [0.0009] | −0.0079*** [0.0014] | 0.0270*** [0.0085] |
| COVID | 0.0448*** [0.0053] | 0.0212*** [0.0070] | 0.0030*** [0.0011] | 0.1046*** [0.0075] | 0.0020** [0.0010] | −0.6440*** [0.0331] |
| RUW | 0.0134 [0.0138] | 0.0810*** [0.0179] | 0.0020 [0.0032] | 0.1109*** [0.0316] | −0.0241*** [0.0044] | 0.8672*** [0.1227] |
| South Korea | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0233*** [0.0019] | 0.0370*** [0.0021] | −0.0024*** [0.0005] | 0.0405*** [0.0013] | −0.0021*** [0.0007] | 0.0660*** [0.0063] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0325*** [0.0021] | 0.0184*** [0.0038] | 0.0125*** [0.0029] | 0.0308* [0.0167] | 0.0121 [0.0132] | 0.0430 [0.1464] |
| COVID | 0.0356*** [0.0016] | 0.0568*** [0.0019] | −0.0020*** [0.0002] | 0.0569*** [0.0040] | −0.0003 [0.0003] | −0.3741*** [0.0148] |
| RUW | 0.0031 [0.0133] | 0.0045 [0.0200] | 0.0256** [0.0096] | −0.0297 [0.0225] | 0.0059 [0.0066] | 0.5391*** [0.1744] |
| Turkey | ||||||
| FULL | −0.0097*** [0.0005] | −0.0112*** [0.0010] | 0.0032*** [0.0004] | −0.0135*** [0.0004] | 0.0026*** [0.0001] | 0.1656*** [0.0069] |
| Pre-COVID | −0.0057** [0.0028] | −0.0049*** [0.0002] | 0.0056*** [0.0004] | −0.0020** [0.0009] | 0.0083*** [0.0005] | −0.2556*** [0.0111] |
| COVID | −0.0070 [0.0069] | −0.0240*** [0.0088] | 0.0018*** [0.0004] | −0.0435*** [0.0045] | 0.0016*** [0.0002] | 0.3464*** [0.0293] |
| RUW | 0.1038*** [0.0111] | 0.1340*** [0.0119] | 0.0235*** [0.0042] | 0.1360*** [0.0260] | 0.0193** [0.0085] | −0.7501*** [0.1843] |
| Vietnam | ||||||
| FULL | 0.0499*** [0.0128] | 0.0493*** [0.0141] | 0.0000 [0.0003] | 0.0250*** [0.0033] | 0.0003*** [0.0001] | 0.0083* [0.0050] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.1137*** [0.0170] | 0.0914*** [0.0154] | 0.0088 [0.0067] | 0.0290*** [0.0047] | 0.0127*** [0.0015] | 0.0141** [0.0063] |
| COVID | 0.0393*** [0.0081] | 0.0508*** [0.0065] | 0.0001*** [0.0000] | 0.0381*** [0.0022] | 0.0035*** [0.0004] | −0.5115*** [0.0331] |
| RUW | 0.0807*** [0.0122] | 0.0908*** [0.0107] | −0.0677*** [0.0032] | 0.0912*** [0.0125] | −0.0730*** [0.0019] | 0.6002*** [0.0427] |
| Sample period | Model-1 | Model-2 | Model-3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stock market uncertainty | Stock market uncertainty | Oil (Brent) market uncertainty | Stock market uncertainty | Oil (Brent) market uncertainty | Other global uncertainties | |
| FULL | 0.0005*** [0.0001] | 0.0000 [0.0003] | 0.0030*** [0.0004] | 0.0009* [0.0005] | 0.0044*** [0.0006] | 0.0964*** [0.0064] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0071*** [0.0012] | 0.0043*** [0.0011] | 0.0153*** [0.0018] | 0.0009*** [0.0002] | 0.0154*** [0.0006] | 0.2810*** [0.0063] |
| COVID | 0.0057*** [0.0018] | 0.0091* [0.0046] | 0.0041*** [0.0010] | −0.0002 [0.0056] | 0.0046*** [0.0007] | 0.0741 [0.0591] |
| RUW | 0.0829*** [0.0076] | 0.1648*** [0.0343] | 0.1438*** [0.0139] | 0.1310*** [0.0220] | 0.0346 [0.0261] | 1.9378*** [0.5281] |
| FULL | 0.0015 [0.0010] | 0.0009 [0.0007] | 0.0003*** [0.0001] | 0.0014** [0.0006] | 0.0003* [0.0002] | 0.0394*** [0.0149] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0017* [0.0009] | 0.0113*** [0.0021] | 0.0064*** [0.0010] | 0.0139*** [0.0015] | 0.0058*** [0.0009] | 0.2976*** [0.0068] |
| COVID | −0.0449*** [0.0047] | −0.0603*** [0.0053] | −0.0020*** [0.0001] | −0.0473*** [0.0034] | 0.0003 [0.0003] | −0.4668*** [0.0267] |
| RUW | 0.0154 [0.0131] | 0.1377*** [0.0162] | −0.0292*** [0.0040] | 0.1617*** [0.0353] | −0.0533*** [0.0145] | 0.1540 [0.2228] |
| FULL | 0.0041*** [0.0008] | 0.0059*** [0.0011] | −0.0008** [0.0003] | 0.0031*** [0.0005] | −0.0003 [0.0003] | 0.0300*** [0.0035] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0026*** [0.0009] | 0.0066*** [0.0015] | −0.0055*** [0.0003] | 0.0099*** [0.0015] | −0.0065*** [0.0003] | 0.1285*** [0.0126] |
| COVID | −0.0200 [0.0135] | 0.0124 [0.0148] | −0.0015*** [0.0004] | −0.0528*** [0.0094] | −0.0004 [0.0010] | 0.3872*** [0.0803] |
| RUW | −0.0627 [0.0738] | 0.0822*** [0.0283] | 0.0860*** [0.0055] | −0.0167 [0.0298] | 0.0723*** [0.0050] | 0.5149*** [0.1454] |
| FULL | 0.5114*** [0.0201] | 0.5205*** [0.0206] | 0.0005*** [0.0002] | 0.5151*** [0.0205] | 0.0015*** [0.0003] | 0.1983*** [0.0096] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.5338*** [0.0275] | 0.5354*** [0.0239] | 0.0051*** [0.0011] | 0.5383*** [0.0247] | 0.0093*** [0.0023] | 0.1022*** [0.0221] |
| COVID | 0.4310*** [0.0383] | 0.4240*** [0.0392] | 0.0005 [0.0003] | 0.4177*** [0.0360] | 0.0004 [0.0004] | −0.1404** [0.0575] |
| RUW | 0.3158*** [0.0300] | 0.3587*** [0.0440] | 0.0106 [0.0125] | 0.1354*** [0.0421] | −0.0310*** [0.0047] | 2.0389*** [0.1765] |
| FULL | 0.0002 [0.0007] | −0.0004 [0.0011] | 0.0010*** [0.0001] | −0.0002 [0.0007] | 0.0009*** [0.0002] | 0.0956*** [0.0038] |
| Pre-COVID | −0.0015** [0.0006] | 0.0042*** [0.0014] | 0.0010 [0.0014] | 0.0007 [0.0015] | −0.0018* [0.0010] | 0.2155*** [0.0045] |
| COVID | −0.0207 [0.0142] | −0.0956*** [0.0162] | 0.0014*** [0.0002] | −0.0697*** [0.0157] | 0.0015*** [0.0001] | −0.0897* [0.0522] |
| RUW | 0.0529*** [0.0076] | 0.0563*** [0.0063] | −0.0139*** [0.0024] | 0.2312*** [0.0311] | −0.0365** [0.0141] | −5.4211*** [0.4801] |
| FULL | 0.0057*** [0.0004] | 0.0068*** [0.0006] | 0.0010*** [0.0003] | 0.0055*** [0.0006] | 0.0024*** [0.0004] | 0.0564*** [0.0027] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0037*** [0.0012] | 0.0063*** [0.0007] | −0.0035*** [0.0011] | 0.0071*** [0.0009] | −0.0079*** [0.0014] | 0.0270*** [0.0085] |
| COVID | 0.0448*** [0.0053] | 0.0212*** [0.0070] | 0.0030*** [0.0011] | 0.1046*** [0.0075] | 0.0020** [0.0010] | −0.6440*** [0.0331] |
| RUW | 0.0134 [0.0138] | 0.0810*** [0.0179] | 0.0020 [0.0032] | 0.1109*** [0.0316] | −0.0241*** [0.0044] | 0.8672*** [0.1227] |
| FULL | 0.0233*** [0.0019] | 0.0370*** [0.0021] | −0.0024*** [0.0005] | 0.0405*** [0.0013] | −0.0021*** [0.0007] | 0.0660*** [0.0063] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.0325*** [0.0021] | 0.0184*** [0.0038] | 0.0125*** [0.0029] | 0.0308* [0.0167] | 0.0121 [0.0132] | 0.0430 [0.1464] |
| COVID | 0.0356*** [0.0016] | 0.0568*** [0.0019] | −0.0020*** [0.0002] | 0.0569*** [0.0040] | −0.0003 [0.0003] | −0.3741*** [0.0148] |
| RUW | 0.0031 [0.0133] | 0.0045 [0.0200] | 0.0256** [0.0096] | −0.0297 [0.0225] | 0.0059 [0.0066] | 0.5391*** [0.1744] |
| FULL | −0.0097*** [0.0005] | −0.0112*** [0.0010] | 0.0032*** [0.0004] | −0.0135*** [0.0004] | 0.0026*** [0.0001] | 0.1656*** [0.0069] |
| Pre-COVID | −0.0057** [0.0028] | −0.0049*** [0.0002] | 0.0056*** [0.0004] | −0.0020** [0.0009] | 0.0083*** [0.0005] | −0.2556*** [0.0111] |
| COVID | −0.0070 [0.0069] | −0.0240*** [0.0088] | 0.0018*** [0.0004] | −0.0435*** [0.0045] | 0.0016*** [0.0002] | 0.3464*** [0.0293] |
| RUW | 0.1038*** [0.0111] | 0.1340*** [0.0119] | 0.0235*** [0.0042] | 0.1360*** [0.0260] | 0.0193** [0.0085] | −0.7501*** [0.1843] |
| FULL | 0.0499*** [0.0128] | 0.0493*** [0.0141] | 0.0000 [0.0003] | 0.0250*** [0.0033] | 0.0003*** [0.0001] | 0.0083* [0.0050] |
| Pre-COVID | 0.1137*** [0.0170] | 0.0914*** [0.0154] | 0.0088 [0.0067] | 0.0290*** [0.0047] | 0.0127*** [0.0015] | 0.0141** [0.0063] |
| COVID | 0.0393*** [0.0081] | 0.0508*** [0.0065] | 0.0001*** [0.0000] | 0.0381*** [0.0022] | 0.0035*** [0.0004] | −0.5115*** [0.0331] |
| RUW | 0.0807*** [0.0122] | 0.0908*** [0.0107] | −0.0677*** [0.0032] | 0.0912*** [0.0125] | −0.0730*** [0.0019] | 0.6002*** [0.0427] |
Note(s): The figures in each cell are the estimated coefficient with their corresponding standard errors in square brackets. The ***, ** and * denote statistical significance at 1%, 5% and 10%, respectively
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.