Table 5 Medium Instances' results Prob... | Emerald Publishing

Table 5

Medium Instances' results

Prob	ALNSx//MDLS							ALNS							AUGMECON
Prob	Obj1	GAP	Obj2	GAP	Obj3	GAP	Time	Obj1	GAP	Obj2	GAP	Obj3	GAP	Time	Obj1	Obj2	Obj3	Time
M1	1.022	0	1,360	0	3.1	0	4.9	1.022	0	1,360	0	3.1	0	4.5	1.022	1,360	3.1	422
	1.17	0	350	0	3.45	0	9.7	1.17	0	350	0	3.45	0	8.4	1.17	350	3.45	1,200
	1.21	0	0	0	3.42	0	12.4	1.21	0	0	0	3.42	0	10	1.21	0	3.42	1,642
M2	1.602	0	2,648	0	4.68	0	11.4	1.602	0	2,648	0	4.68	0	10.6	1.602	2,648	4.68	1947
	1.791	0	1,682	0	5.01	0	13.7	1.791	0	1,682	0	5.01	0	12.8	1.791	1,682	5.01	2,461
	1.84	0	0	0	5.12	0	15.4	1.84	0	0	0	5.12	0	14.6	1.84	0	5.12	2,867
M3	1.61	0	1,615	0	3.79	0	7.3	1.61	0	1,615	0	3.79	0	7.03	1.61	1,615	3.79	723
	1.78	0	2,350	0	4.25	0	9.7	1.78	0	2,350	0	4.25	0	9.04	1.78	2,350	4.25	1,345
	1.89	0	2,100	0	4.86	0	10.1	1.88	0.06	2,132	0.15	4.9	0.1	9.7	1.89	2,100	4.86	1974

Prob	ALNSx//MDLS							ALNS							AUGMECON
Prob	Obj1	GAP	Obj2	GAP	Obj3	GAP	Time	Obj1	GAP	Obj2	GAP	Obj3	GAP	Time	Obj1	Obj2	Obj3	Time
M1	1.022	0	1,360	0	3.1	0	4.9	1.022	0	1,360	0	3.1	0	4.5	1.022	1,360	3.1	422
	1.17	0	350	0	3.45	0	9.7	1.17	0	350	0	3.45	0	8.4	1.17	350	3.45	1,200
	1.21	0	0	0	3.42	0	12.4	1.21	0	0	0	3.42	0	10	1.21	0	3.42	1,642
M2	1.602	0	2,648	0	4.68	0	11.4	1.602	0	2,648	0	4.68	0	10.6	1.602	2,648	4.68	1947
	1.791	0	1,682	0	5.01	0	13.7	1.791	0	1,682	0	5.01	0	12.8	1.791	1,682	5.01	2,461
	1.84	0	0	0	5.12	0	15.4	1.84	0	0	0	5.12	0	14.6	1.84	0	5.12	2,867
M3	1.61	0	1,615	0	3.79	0	7.3	1.61	0	1,615	0	3.79	0	7.03	1.61	1,615	3.79	723
	1.78	0	2,350	0	4.25	0	9.7	1.78	0	2,350	0	4.25	0	9.04	1.78	2,350	4.25	1,345
	1.89	0	2,100	0	4.86	0	10.1	1.88	0.06	2,132	0.15	4.9	0.1	9.7	1.89	2,100	4.86	1974