Table 2

Codes definition

VariablesDefinitionSource
Adopted I4.0 technologiesAdopted Industry 4.0 technologiesIndustrial Internet of Things, Industrial Analytics, Advanced Human–Machine Interface, Cloud Manufacturing, Additive Manufacturing, Advanced Automation (Tortorella and Fettermann, 2018)Tortorella and Fetterman (2018) 
Industry 4.0 technologies maturityMonitoring, Control, Optimization, AutonomyFettermann et al. (2018) 
Drivers for I4.0 investmentsIndustry 4.0 target areasProcessing, Assembly, Logistics and Product developmentSlack et al. (2013) 
Industry 4.0 investment driversIncreasing production capacity, Outdated machinery substitution, Governmental incentives, Improving waste detection, and Enhancing data availabilityWithin case
Expected Industry 4.0 performance improvementProductivity (Parham, 2002), Efficiency (Lee and Johnson, 2013), Quality (Chandrupatla, 2009), Time (Bayo-Moriones and De-Cerio, 2002), Flexibility (Gerwin, 1987)Within case



Slack et al. (2013) 
Magnitude of I4.0 investmentsIndustry 4.0 investments pay-back timeLong pay-back time (higher than 3 years), Medium pay-back time (ranging from 2 to 3 years), Short pay-back time (lower than 2 years), Not availableWithin case
Industry 4.0 width of interventionLocalized (small interventions areas) and Extensive (wider interventions areas, e.g. an entire production department or the whole plant)Within case
People and I4.0Role and task evolutionSubstitution (replacement of operators), Control (control of operations), No major changes, Support (ease activities for operators), Enhancement (operators become in charge of making decisions and performing basic problem-solving activities on data)Within case. Marengo (2019); Flores et al. (2020) 
Competences evolutionIT skills, Technical skills, Problem-solving, Learning capacity, Responsibility, Teamwork, No major changesMotyl et al. (2017) 

or Create an Account

Close subscription notice
Close access options