Comparison of the developed algorithms for the continuous berthing layout case
| Inst. | WL | A | MA-DPC | MA | EA | SA | VNS | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | |||
| R13 | [WL1] | [A1] | 384.09 | 275.45 | 438.96 | 271.30 | 446.58 | 258.58 | 444.93 | 108.34 | 424.17 | 198.22 |
| R14 | [WL1] | [A2] | 307.86 | 205.80 | 332.64 | 202.12 | 335.80 | 192.03 | 334.65 | 86.20 | 333.98 | 162.93 |
| R15 | [WL1] | [A3] | 254.32 | 235.28 | 284.13 | 227.79 | 294.96 | 214.81 | 295.00 | 75.45 | 294.48 | 141.97 |
| R16 | [WL1] | [A4] | 221.03 | 179.52 | 238.71 | 178.03 | 248.63 | 169.94 | 248.29 | 64.52 | 248.16 | 125.36 |
| R17 | [WL2] | [A1] | 351.82 | 287.87 | 365.77 | 287.58 | 377.53 | 268.91 | 377.02 | 132.11 | 364.87 | 208.84 |
| R18 | [WL2] | [A2] | 268.45 | 217.51 | 278.29 | 218.38 | 280.83 | 204.35 | 281.02 | 108.89 | 278.85 | 173.45 |
| R19 | [WL2] | [A3] | 238.11 | 250.80 | 244.70 | 246.65 | 248.32 | 230.60 | 251.73 | 94.08 | 249.43 | 155.74 |
| R20 | [WL2] | [A4] | 195.29 | 197.25 | 200.71 | 190.64 | 203.25 | 179.76 | 203.41 | 81.25 | 202.64 | 133.70 |
| R21 | [WL3] | [A1] | 290.99 | 305.12 | 297.38 | 302.01 | 301.59 | 286.26 | 302.30 | 159.34 | 299.93 | 227.12 |
| R22 | [WL3] | [A2] | 232.78 | 229.94 | 236.65 | 226.41 | 237.99 | 218.81 | 237.89 | 130.14 | 238.34 | 193.33 |
| R23 | [WL3] | [A3] | 227.50 | 255.27 | 233.00 | 259.13 | 234.92 | 245.67 | 236.39 | 115.99 | 236.24 | 168.47 |
| R24 | [WL3] | [A4] | 148.01 | 195.53 | 149.78 | 196.97 | 150.06 | 188.36 | 150.59 | 96.39 | 150.75 | 145.68 |
| Average: | 260.02 | 236.28 | 275.06 | 233.92 | 280.04 | 221.51 | 280.27 | 104.39 | 276.82 | 169.57 | ||
| Inst. | WL | A | MA-DPC | MA | EA | SA | VNS | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | Z, 106 US$ | CPU, s | |||
| R13 | [WL1] | [A1] | 384.09 | 275.45 | 438.96 | 271.30 | 446.58 | 258.58 | 444.93 | 108.34 | 424.17 | 198.22 |
| R14 | [WL1] | [A2] | 307.86 | 205.80 | 332.64 | 202.12 | 335.80 | 192.03 | 334.65 | 86.20 | 333.98 | 162.93 |
| R15 | [WL1] | [A3] | 254.32 | 235.28 | 284.13 | 227.79 | 294.96 | 214.81 | 295.00 | 75.45 | 294.48 | 141.97 |
| R16 | [WL1] | [A4] | 221.03 | 179.52 | 238.71 | 178.03 | 248.63 | 169.94 | 248.29 | 64.52 | 248.16 | 125.36 |
| R17 | [WL2] | [A1] | 351.82 | 287.87 | 365.77 | 287.58 | 377.53 | 268.91 | 377.02 | 132.11 | 364.87 | 208.84 |
| R18 | [WL2] | [A2] | 268.45 | 217.51 | 278.29 | 218.38 | 280.83 | 204.35 | 281.02 | 108.89 | 278.85 | 173.45 |
| R19 | [WL2] | [A3] | 238.11 | 250.80 | 244.70 | 246.65 | 248.32 | 230.60 | 251.73 | 94.08 | 249.43 | 155.74 |
| R20 | [WL2] | [A4] | 195.29 | 197.25 | 200.71 | 190.64 | 203.25 | 179.76 | 203.41 | 81.25 | 202.64 | 133.70 |
| R21 | [WL3] | [A1] | 290.99 | 305.12 | 297.38 | 302.01 | 301.59 | 286.26 | 302.30 | 159.34 | 299.93 | 227.12 |
| R22 | [WL3] | [A2] | 232.78 | 229.94 | 236.65 | 226.41 | 237.99 | 218.81 | 237.89 | 130.14 | 238.34 | 193.33 |
| R23 | [WL3] | [A3] | 227.50 | 255.27 | 233.00 | 259.13 | 234.92 | 245.67 | 236.39 | 115.99 | 236.24 | 168.47 |
| R24 | [WL3] | [A4] | 148.01 | 195.53 | 149.78 | 196.97 | 150.06 | 188.36 | 150.59 | 96.39 | 150.75 | 145.68 |
| Average: | 260.02 | 236.28 | 275.06 | 233.92 | 280.04 | 221.51 | 280.27 | 104.39 | 276.82 | 169.57 | ||
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.