Table 1 Validity test of expert...

Table 1

Validity test of expert assignment of a single indicator

	Expert 1	Expert 2	Expert 3	Expert 4	Expert 5	Expert 6	Expert 7	Expert 8	Expert 9	Expert 10
GDP per capita	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Consumer price Index	1.2139	0.9026	0.9026	0.5914	0.5914	0.2801	−0.9649	−0.9649	−1.2761	−1.2761
Natural population growth rate	1.1212	1.1212	0.2587	0.2587	0.2587	0.2587	0.2587	−0.6037	−0.6037	−2.3286
Urbanization rate	1.2176	1.2176	1.2176	0.9585	−0.5958	−0.5958	−0.8549	−0.8549	−0.8549	−0.8549
Social endowment insurance coverage	1.9378	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	−1.5855	−1.5855
Energy consumption per unit of GDP	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
The intensity of R&D expenditure input	1.3393	1.0603	1.0603	0.5022	0.5022	−0.3348	−0.8929	−0.8929	−1.1719	−1.1719
GOP/GDP	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
The value of marine emerging industries /GOP	1.0279	1.0279	1.0279	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−2.3984
Growth rate of gross marine product	1.1619	1.1619	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	−1.7428	−1.7428
The value of marine tertiary industry/GOP	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Elasticity coefficient of marine tertiary industry	0.7591	0.7591	0.7591	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	−2.6913
Marine productivity	1.4643	1.1931	1.1931	0.6508	−0.4339	−0.7050	−0.7050	−0.7050	−0.9762	−0.9762
Dependence on foreign trade	1.8974	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	−1.2649	−1.2649	−1.2649
Contribution of marine technological	1.8974	1.8974	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743
Marine technological achievements output	2.1118	1.1062	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050
Undertaking marine research projects per capita	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
Ocean technology patents authorized	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
Marine technology papers published	1.3506	1.3506	1.0570	0.7634	−0.4111	−0.7047	−0.7047	−0.7047	−0.9983	−0.9983
Per capita funds for technological activities	1.9378	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	−1.5855	−1.5855
Per capita marine education input	1.3059	1.3059	0.2176	0.2176	0.2176	0.2176	0.2176	−0.8706	−0.8706	−1.9588
Intensity of offshore oil production	1.1062	1.1062	1.1062	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	−0.9050	−0.9050	−1.9106
Intensity of marine fishing	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Intensity of direct economic losses	1.8974	1.8974	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743
Intensity of sewage discharge from sea pollution	2.2883	0.8581	0.8581	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721
Investment in environmental governance	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Pollution control projects	2.1118	1.1062	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050

	Expert 1	Expert 2	Expert 3	Expert 4	Expert 5	Expert 6	Expert 7	Expert 8	Expert 9	Expert 10
GDP per capita	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Consumer price Index	1.2139	0.9026	0.9026	0.5914	0.5914	0.2801	−0.9649	−0.9649	−1.2761	−1.2761
Natural population growth rate	1.1212	1.1212	0.2587	0.2587	0.2587	0.2587	0.2587	−0.6037	−0.6037	−2.3286
Urbanization rate	1.2176	1.2176	1.2176	0.9585	−0.5958	−0.5958	−0.8549	−0.8549	−0.8549	−0.8549
Social endowment insurance coverage	1.9378	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	−1.5855	−1.5855
Energy consumption per unit of GDP	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
The intensity of R&D expenditure input	1.3393	1.0603	1.0603	0.5022	0.5022	−0.3348	−0.8929	−0.8929	−1.1719	−1.1719
GOP/GDP	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
The value of marine emerging industries /GOP	1.0279	1.0279	1.0279	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−0.1142	−2.3984
Growth rate of gross marine product	1.1619	1.1619	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	0.1936	−1.7428	−1.7428
The value of marine tertiary industry/GOP	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Elasticity coefficient of marine tertiary industry	0.7591	0.7591	0.7591	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	0.0690	−2.6913
Marine productivity	1.4643	1.1931	1.1931	0.6508	−0.4339	−0.7050	−0.7050	−0.7050	−0.9762	−0.9762
Dependence on foreign trade	1.8974	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	0.3162	−1.2649	−1.2649	−1.2649
Contribution of marine technological	1.8974	1.8974	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743
Marine technological achievements output	2.1118	1.1062	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050
Undertaking marine research projects per capita	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
Ocean technology patents authorized	1.5855	1.5855	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−0.1762	−1.9378
Marine technology papers published	1.3506	1.3506	1.0570	0.7634	−0.4111	−0.7047	−0.7047	−0.7047	−0.9983	−0.9983
Per capita funds for technological activities	1.9378	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	0.1762	−1.5855	−1.5855
Per capita marine education input	1.3059	1.3059	0.2176	0.2176	0.2176	0.2176	0.2176	−0.8706	−0.8706	−1.9588
Intensity of offshore oil production	1.1062	1.1062	1.1062	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	−0.9050	−0.9050	−1.9106
Intensity of marine fishing	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Intensity of direct economic losses	1.8974	1.8974	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743	−0.4743
Intensity of sewage discharge from sea pollution	2.2883	0.8581	0.8581	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721	−0.5721
Investment in environmental governance	1.5000	1.5000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	0.0000	−1.5000	−1.5000
Pollution control projects	2.1118	1.1062	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	0.1006	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050	−0.9050

[ViewLarge]