Table 5. Summary of the validation of... | Emerald Publishing

Table 5.

Summary of the validation of the hypotheses

Hypothesis	Productivity		Market share
	With R&D	Without R&D	With R&D	Without R&D
H1a: Manufacturing firms that implement product innovation have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	YES	YES
H1b: Manufacturing firms that implement service innovation have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	NO	YES
H1c: Manufacturing firms that implement process innovation (production method) have positive effects on their performance	YES	YES	NO	YES
H1c: Manufacturing firms that implement process innovation (logistic method) have positive effects on their performance	YES	NO	NO	NO
H1c: Manufacturing firms that implement process innovation (acquisition of machinery) have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	NO	NO
H2a: Manufacturing firms that implement organizational innovation have positive effects on their performance	YES	YES	NO	NO
H2b: Manufacturing firms that implement marketing innovation have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	NO	YES
H3a: Manufacturing firms with R&D have a greater positive effect on the relationship between innovation outcomes and productivity than manufacturing firms without R&D	YES	N.A	N.A
H3b: Manufacturing firms with R&D have a greater positive effect on the relationship between innovation outcomes and market shares than manufacturing firms without R&D	N.A	N.A	NO

Hypothesis	Productivity		Market share
	With R&D	Without R&D	With R&D	Without R&D
H1a: Manufacturing firms that implement product innovation have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	YES	YES
H1b: Manufacturing firms that implement service innovation have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	NO	YES
H1c: Manufacturing firms that implement process innovation (production method) have positive effects on their performance	YES	YES	NO	YES
H1c: Manufacturing firms that implement process innovation (logistic method) have positive effects on their performance	YES	NO	NO	NO
H1c: Manufacturing firms that implement process innovation (acquisition of machinery) have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	NO	NO
H2a: Manufacturing firms that implement organizational innovation have positive effects on their performance	YES	YES	NO	NO
H2b: Manufacturing firms that implement marketing innovation have positive effects on their performance	NO	NO	NO	YES
H3a: Manufacturing firms with R&D have a greater positive effect on the relationship between innovation outcomes and productivity than manufacturing firms without R&D	YES	N.A	N.A
H3b: Manufacturing firms with R&D have a greater positive effect on the relationship between innovation outcomes and market shares than manufacturing firms without R&D	N.A	N.A	NO

Source: Own elaboration