Phase 1: identify information and stakeholders
| Phase 1: Identify information and stakeholders | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper ID | Tot al | Elements/Steps | |||||||||||
8 | 3 | Identify | |||||||||||
60 | 6 | strategic case (why action needed) | |||||||||||
216 | 6 | clarify the question | |||||||||||
97 | 5 | problem structuring | |||||||||||
81 | 6 | perspective (who to include) | |||||||||||
230 | 5 | identify stakeholders | |||||||||||
14 + 41+257 | 8 | initial preparation | groundwork for BC | ||||||||||
249 | 5 | system impact | transition impact | ||||||||||
95 | 5 | drivers & business needs | preliminary & prefeasibility analysis | ||||||||||
82 | 6 | mapping outcomes* | scope and key stakeholders* | ||||||||||
158 | 5 | business needs and desired outcomes | preliminary options analysis | ||||||||||
166 | 4 | market consortium* | stakeholder group* | ||||||||||
191 | 9 | problem and hypothesis potential solutions | key administrators | ||||||||||
48 | 7 | purpose | strategic priorities | options | |||||||||
80 | 4 | triple bottom line impacts | categories of metrics | stakeholders | |||||||||
132 | 5 | identify (what problems can it solve) | potential customers | customer needs | |||||||||
187 | 6 | business needs and proposed intervention | measurable objectives, benefits, success factors | process for introducing/managing recommended option, affected personnel, etc.* | |||||||||
263 | 5 | motivation and objectives | benefits, measures, and owners + structure benefits | ||||||||||
290 | Determine possible alternatives | Determine criteria | Determine weights | ||||||||||
115 | 7 | needs assessment | fit mission, vision, priorities | build team | intervention plan | ||||||||
33 | 5 | desired outcomes (WHAT) | Importance, capability gap | indicators (HOW) | interrelation ship matrix HOW- WHAT | ||||||||
| Phase 1: Identify information and stakeholders | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper ID | Tot al | Elements/Steps | |||||||||||
8 | 3 | Identify | |||||||||||
60 | 6 | strategic case (why action needed) | |||||||||||
216 | 6 | clarify the question | |||||||||||
97 | 5 | problem structuring | |||||||||||
81 | 6 | perspective (who to include) | |||||||||||
230 | 5 | identify stakeholders | |||||||||||
14 + 41+257 | 8 | initial preparation | groundwork for BC | ||||||||||
249 | 5 | system impact | transition impact | ||||||||||
95 | 5 | drivers & business needs | preliminary & prefeasibility analysis | ||||||||||
82 | 6 | mapping outcomes* | scope and key stakeholders* | ||||||||||
158 | 5 | business needs and desired outcomes | preliminary options analysis | ||||||||||
166 | 4 | market consortium* | stakeholder group* | ||||||||||
191 | 9 | problem and hypothesis potential solutions | key administrators | ||||||||||
48 | 7 | purpose | strategic priorities | options | |||||||||
80 | 4 | triple bottom line impacts | categories of metrics | stakeholders | |||||||||
132 | 5 | identify (what problems can it solve) | potential customers | customer needs | |||||||||
187 | 6 | business needs and proposed intervention | measurable objectives, benefits, success factors | process for introducing/managing recommended option, affected personnel, etc.* | |||||||||
263 | 5 | motivation and objectives | benefits, measures, and owners + structure benefits | ||||||||||
290 | Determine possible alternatives | Determine criteria | Determine weights | ||||||||||
115 | 7 | needs assessment | fit mission, vision, priorities | build team | intervention plan | ||||||||
33 | 5 | desired outcomes (WHAT) | Importance, capability gap | indicators (HOW) | interrelation ship matrix HOW- WHAT | ||||||||
121 | 7 | metrics & measurement | shared values | shared vision | shared definition | ||||||||||||
130 | 9 | BC objectives | technological requirements | supplier options | stakeholders* | ||||||||||||
148+267 | 6 | business drivers and investment objectives | benefits measures objectives | structure benefits | organizational changes to achieve benefits | ||||||||||||
55 | 7 | define problem | solution | research concept | case studies | detail solution | |||||||||||
35 | 7 | impact of context | perspective | study design | relevant decision makers | time horizon | |||||||||||
23 | 8 | problem and objectives | rough alternatives | constrain alternatives | identify & define criteria | stakeholders | |||||||||||
195 | 11 | determine perspective | design the study* | describe the intervention | effects of intervention on quality* | effects capacity constraints* | time horizon* | ||||||||||
228 | 10 | Conditions of participation | Relevance to mission | impact on internal culture | alignment specific performance incentives | image, reputation | key stakeholders | strategic positioning | |||||||||
221 | 14 | Choose a business problem | current performance gaps | place problem in strategic context | clarify problem, identify initiatives to address it* | relationships initiatives, performance, objectives | measures towards objectives* | assess contribution | tools to implement | action plan and resources | |||||||
62 | 19 | need/ problem | strategic impact | situation analyses | objectives/base line solution | alternative solutions | measurement criteria + success factors + non-financial elements | stakeholders | assumptions + deliverables | dependencies + activities | time scale | ||||||
Note(s): * order of this step was changed to original paper | |||||||||||||||||
121 | 7 | metrics & measurement | shared values | shared vision | shared definition | ||||||||||||
130 | 9 | BC objectives | technological requirements | supplier options | stakeholders* | ||||||||||||
148+267 | 6 | business drivers and investment objectives | benefits measures objectives | structure benefits | organizational changes to achieve benefits | ||||||||||||
55 | 7 | define problem | solution | research concept | case studies | detail solution | |||||||||||
35 | 7 | impact of context | perspective | study design | relevant decision makers | time horizon | |||||||||||
23 | 8 | problem and objectives | rough alternatives | constrain alternatives | identify & define criteria | stakeholders | |||||||||||
195 | 11 | determine perspective | design the study* | describe the intervention | effects of intervention on quality* | effects capacity constraints* | time horizon* | ||||||||||
228 | 10 | Conditions of participation | Relevance to mission | impact on internal culture | alignment specific performance incentives | image, reputation | key stakeholders | strategic positioning | |||||||||
221 | 14 | Choose a business problem | current performance gaps | place problem in strategic context | clarify problem, identify initiatives to address it* | relationships initiatives, performance, objectives | measures towards objectives* | assess contribution | tools to implement | action plan and resources | |||||||
62 | 19 | need/ problem | strategic impact | situation analyses | objectives/base line solution | alternative solutions | measurement criteria + success factors + non-financial elements | stakeholders | assumptions + deliverables | dependencies + activities | time scale | ||||||
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.