Table 1

Selected studies of I4.0 MMs

MetricMM development methods
MM no.ReferenceAssess domainSubdomainLevel of maturityLiterature reviewSurveyWorkshopConceptual modellingQA-score
MM-01Bechthold and Lauenstein (2014) 497 X X6.25
MM-02Rockwell Automation (2014) 4–5  X 5.42
MM-03Lichtblau et al. (2015) 6186 XXX8.13
MM-04Geissbauer et al. (2016) 6–4 X X5.42
MM-05Schumacher et al. (2016) 965X  X7.50
MM-06VDMA Industrie 4.0 Forum (2016) 1225X  X7.50
MM-07Bauer et al. (2016) 826– X X6.88
MM-08Agca et al. (2017) 6374 X X6.46
MM-09EDB (2017) 16–6XXXX6.67
MM-10German Innovation Centre for Industry 4.0 (2018) 42110XXXX5.42
MM-11MITI (2018) 21–5X  X7.08
MM-12Colli et al. (2019) 5–6XXXX7.71
MM-13MOI (2018) 5175X  X7.29
MM-14Sony and Naik (2019) 617–X  X5.63
MM-15Calabrese et al. (2020) 921– X X7.92
MM-16Garzoni et al. (2020) ––4X  X6.25
MM-17Santos and Martinho (2020) 5–6XXXX8.54
MM-18Schuh et al. (2020) 486X  X8.13
MM-19Tripathi and Gupta (2021) 7172X  X8.54
MM-20Wagire et al. (2021) 73824 X X7.71
MM-21Gökalp et al. (2019) 5–5X  X5.83
MM-22Leyh et al. (2016) 4–5X   6.67
MM-23Akdil et al. (2018) 334XX X7.50
MM-24Scremin et al. (2018) 3–5XX X8.33
MM-25Jung et al. (2016) 4–6   X6.88
MM-26Ganzarain and Errasti (2016) 3–5 X X6.04
MM-27Lee et al. (2017) 4103   X7.71
MM-28Fantini et al. (2020) 6–3 to 7XX X6.88
MM-29Frank et al. (2019) 5–3 to 4X  X5.83
MM-30De Carolis et al. (2017) 5–5   X7.08

Source(s): Authors’ work

[ViewLarge]
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal