Table 4 Rolling stock purchase... | Emerald Publishing

Table 4

Rolling stock purchase directions

Tender no	Evaluation criteria	Country	Year	Specificity
2015/S 132–243424	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	Germany	2015	contracting authority requested that the contractor should constantly maintain readiness to use the basic rolling stock, but also a maintenance reserve
2015/S 068–122520	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 50% 2. Qualitative criterion 2: life cycle cost: 5% 3. Price: 45%	France	2015	a procedure for the rolling stock supply
2016/S 179–320954	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	Germany	2016	the system of qualifying suppliers for the purchase of new railway vehicles for use in local public transport, the supply of spare parts and, if necessary, additional maintenance by the manufacturer
2016/S 190–340512	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 50% 2. Price: 50%”	France	2016	a procedure for the supply
2017/S 073–140212	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 70% 2. Price: 50%”	Italy	2017	supplier qualification system • delivery of new rolling stock, including certificates, approvals, commissioning and technical acceptance, for various types of rolling stock and • full service, first and second level, for newly delivered rolling stock, for various categories of rolling stock
2017/S 093–182702	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 70% 2. Price: 30%	Italy	2017	a procedure for the supply, including full technical service
2017/S 052–096648	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	Germany	2017	a procedure for the supply
2017/S 143–295536	Price 100%	Poland	2017	a procedure for the supply
2017/S 047–086799	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 40% 2. Qualitative criterion 2: life cycle cost: 30% 3. Price: 30%	Germany	2017	a procedure for the supply
2018/S 120–274586	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	France	2018	a procedure for the supply
2018/S 247–571258	1. delivery terms - 28% 2. maintenance conditions - 4% 3. maintenance conditions: documentation, resources and training plan - 8%. The remaining 60% was the price evaluation	Spain	2018	a procedure for the rolling stock supply
2019/S 031–070567	1. delivery terms - 28% 2. maintenance conditions - 4% 3. maintenance conditions: documentation, resources and training plan - 8%. The remaining 60% was the price evaluation	Spain	2019	procedure for the supply of trains along with maintenance services

Tender no	Evaluation criteria	Country	Year	Specificity
2015/S 132–243424	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	Germany	2015	contracting authority requested that the contractor should constantly maintain readiness to use the basic rolling stock, but also a maintenance reserve
2015/S 068–122520	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 50% 2. Qualitative criterion 2: life cycle cost: 5% 3. Price: 45%	France	2015	a procedure for the rolling stock supply
2016/S 179–320954	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	Germany	2016	the system of qualifying suppliers for the purchase of new railway vehicles for use in local public transport, the supply of spare parts and, if necessary, additional maintenance by the manufacturer
2016/S 190–340512	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 50% 2. Price: 50%”	France	2016	a procedure for the supply
2017/S 073–140212	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 70% 2. Price: 50%”	Italy	2017	supplier qualification system• delivery of new rolling stock, including certificates, approvals, commissioning and technical acceptance, for various types of rolling stock and • full service, first and second level, for newly delivered rolling stock, for various categories of rolling stock
2017/S 093–182702	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 70% 2. Price: 30%	Italy	2017	a procedure for the supply, including full technical service
2017/S 052–096648	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	Germany	2017	a procedure for the supply
2017/S 143–295536	Price 100%	Poland	2017	a procedure for the supply
2017/S 047–086799	1. Quality criterion 1: technical quality: 40% 2. Qualitative criterion 2: life cycle cost: 30% 3. Price: 30%	Germany	2017	a procedure for the supply
2018/S 120–274586	Price is not the only award criterion; all criteria are mentioned only in the procurement documents ”	France	2018	a procedure for the supply
2018/S 247–571258	1. delivery terms - 28% 2. maintenance conditions - 4% 3. maintenance conditions: documentation, resources and training plan - 8%. The remaining 60% was the price evaluation	Spain	2018	a procedure for the rolling stock supply
2019/S 031–070567	1. delivery terms - 28% 2. maintenance conditions - 4% 3. maintenance conditions: documentation, resources and training plan - 8%. The remaining 60% was the price evaluation	Spain	2019	procedure for the supply of trains along with maintenance services

Source(s): Authors’ own elaboration based on Innorail Project