Table 2 Common method bias (CMB)...

Table 2

Common method bias (CMB) analysis with PLS

Construct	Item	Substantive factor loading (R1)	R1²	Method factor loading (R2)	R2²
Argument quality (AQ)	AQ1	0.911***	0.830	−0.040	0.002
	AQ2	0.858***	0.736	0.036	0.001
	AQ3	0.813***	0.661	0.015	0.000
	AQ4	0.853***	0.728	−0.012	0.000
Information quantity (IQ)	IQ1	0.861***	0.741	−0.057*	0.003
	IQ2	0.855***	0.731	−0.06*	0.004
	IQ3	0.756***	0.572	0.057	0.003
	IQ4	0.824***	0.679	−0.017	0.000
	IQ5	0.730***	0.533	0.079*	0.006
Cognitive response (CR)	CR1	0.914***	0.835	−0.082**	0.007
	CR2	0.844***	0.712	0.024	0.001
	CR3	0.854***	0.729	0.030	0.001
	CR4	0.864***	0.746	0.024	0.001
Affective response (AR)	AR1	0.900***	0.810	−0.018	0.000
	AR2	0.861***	0.741	0.035	0.001
	AR3	0.896***	0.803	−0.017	0.000
University reputation (UR)	UR1	0.913***	0.834	−0.050	0.003
	UR2	0.915***	0.837	−0.056	0.003
	UR3	0.866***	0.750	−0.019	0.000
	UR4	0.750***	0.563	0.124**	0.015
Development (COD)	COD1	0.865***	0.748	0.039	0.002
	COD2	0.852***	0.726	0.056*	0.003
	COD3	0.935***	0.874	−0.098***	0.010
Feedback (COF)	COF1	0.943***	0.889	−0.077***	0.006
	COF2	0.874***	0.764	0.032	0.001
	COF3	0.872***	0.760	0.042*	0.002
Advocacy (COA)	COA1	0.851***	0.724	0.006	0.000
	COA2	0.868***	0.753	0.022	0.000
	COA3	0.863***	0.745	−0.021	0.000
	COA4	0.876***	0.767	−0.008	0.000
Helping (COH)	COH1	0.893***	0.797	0.001	0.000
	COH2	0.894***	0.799	−0.004	0.000
	COH3	0.887***	0.787	0.003	0.000
Average		0.864		0.000

Construct	Item	Substantive factor loading (R1)	R1²	Method factor loading (R2)	R2²
Argument quality (AQ)	AQ1	0.911***	0.830	−0.040	0.002
	AQ2	0.858***	0.736	0.036	0.001
	AQ3	0.813***	0.661	0.015	0.000
	AQ4	0.853***	0.728	−0.012	0.000
Information quantity (IQ)	IQ1	0.861***	0.741	−0.057*	0.003
	IQ2	0.855***	0.731	−0.06*	0.004
	IQ3	0.756***	0.572	0.057	0.003
	IQ4	0.824***	0.679	−0.017	0.000
	IQ5	0.730***	0.533	0.079*	0.006
Cognitive response (CR)	CR1	0.914***	0.835	−0.082**	0.007
	CR2	0.844***	0.712	0.024	0.001
	CR3	0.854***	0.729	0.030	0.001
	CR4	0.864***	0.746	0.024	0.001
Affective response (AR)	AR1	0.900***	0.810	−0.018	0.000
	AR2	0.861***	0.741	0.035	0.001
	AR3	0.896***	0.803	−0.017	0.000
University reputation (UR)	UR1	0.913***	0.834	−0.050	0.003
	UR2	0.915***	0.837	−0.056	0.003
	UR3	0.866***	0.750	−0.019	0.000
	UR4	0.750***	0.563	0.124**	0.015
Development (COD)	COD1	0.865***	0.748	0.039	0.002
	COD2	0.852***	0.726	0.056*	0.003
	COD3	0.935***	0.874	−0.098***	0.010
Feedback (COF)	COF1	0.943***	0.889	−0.077***	0.006
	COF2	0.874***	0.764	0.032	0.001
	COF3	0.872***	0.760	0.042*	0.002
Advocacy (COA)	COA1	0.851***	0.724	0.006	0.000
	COA2	0.868***	0.753	0.022	0.000
	COA3	0.863***	0.745	−0.021	0.000
	COA4	0.876***	0.767	−0.008	0.000
Helping (COH)	COH1	0.893***	0.797	0.001	0.000
	COH2	0.894***	0.799	−0.004	0.000
	COH3	0.887***	0.787	0.003	0.000
Average		0.864		0.000

Note(s): *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001

Source(s): Table by authors

Sharing Unavailable