CEC-2022 experimental results
| Function | SBOA | GWO | WOA | DBO | NGO | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| f1 | Worst | 1399.95 | 21414.23 | 66109.62 | 46153.00 | 8573.62 |
| Best | 336.33 | 2975.41 | 10009.81 | 14210.72 | 3052.88 | |
| Mean | 675.10 | 13175.33 | 26279.59 | 23774.03 | 4791.89 | |
| STD | 320.78 | 4668.00 | 16041.58 | 9001.64 | 1683.63 | |
| f2 | Worst | 475.64 | 588.09 | 682.55 | 587.09 | 473.73 |
| Best | 429.20 | 459.46 | 459.15 | 449.11 | 449.08 | |
| Mean | 456.83 | 505.34 | 578.86 | 493.64 | 456.21 | |
| STD | 15.59 | 45.33 | 75.82 | 40.79 | 11.31 | |
| f3 | Worst | 600.04 | 619.02 | 684.41 | 652.85 | 629.06 |
| Best | 600.00 | 601.70 | 657.84 | 609.09 | 600.57 | |
| Mean | 600.02 | 606.88 | 668.63 | 635.71 | 609.79 | |
| STD | 0.01 | 5.73 | 8.87 | 13.49 | 8.67 | |
| f5 | Worst | 977.0319 | 1557.2075 | 6435.0057 | 2750.3329 | 1933.015 |
| Best | 900.0895 | 956.8755 | 2225.0484 | 1056.1964 | 1175.8752 | |
| Mean | 914.1572 | 1211.5993 | 4081.8326 | 1838.3178 | 1534.7314 | |
| STD | 23.0222 | 203.55 | 1204.2058 | 523.1733 | 209.3676 |
| Function | SBOA | GWO | WOA | DBO | NGO | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| f1 | Worst | 1399.95 | 21414.23 | 66109.62 | 46153.00 | 8573.62 |
| Best | 336.33 | 2975.41 | 10009.81 | 14210.72 | 3052.88 | |
| Mean | 675.10 | 13175.33 | 26279.59 | 23774.03 | 4791.89 | |
| STD | 320.78 | 4668.00 | 16041.58 | 9001.64 | 1683.63 | |
| f2 | Worst | 475.64 | 588.09 | 682.55 | 587.09 | 473.73 |
| Best | 429.20 | 459.46 | 459.15 | 449.11 | 449.08 | |
| Mean | 456.83 | 505.34 | 578.86 | 493.64 | 456.21 | |
| STD | 15.59 | 45.33 | 75.82 | 40.79 | 11.31 | |
| f3 | Worst | 600.04 | 619.02 | 684.41 | 652.85 | 629.06 |
| Best | 600.00 | 601.70 | 657.84 | 609.09 | 600.57 | |
| Mean | 600.02 | 606.88 | 668.63 | 635.71 | 609.79 | |
| STD | 0.01 | 5.73 | 8.87 | 13.49 | 8.67 | |
| f5 | Worst | 977.0319 | 1557.2075 | 6435.0057 | 2750.3329 | 1933.015 |
| Best | 900.0895 | 956.8755 | 2225.0484 | 1056.1964 | 1175.8752 | |
| Mean | 914.1572 | 1211.5993 | 4081.8326 | 1838.3178 | 1534.7314 | |
| STD | 23.0222 | 203.55 | 1204.2058 | 523.1733 | 209.3676 |
Source(s): Authors’ own work
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.