Table 7 Existing CE framework for CDWM... | Emerald Publishing

Table 7

Existing CE framework for CDWM

Authors	Field	Key objectives	Practicality	Effectiveness	Usability	Limitations
Han et al. (2024)	Demolition	Facilitate sustainability-oriented decision-making at the planning stage of demolition activities	The BIM-based framework accommodates inventory analysis using MCDA algorithms to manage demolition waste	Quantifies and visualizes the recycling value of building components	Integrates BIM, inventory analysis tools, and MCDA algorithms for planning demolition activities	Developed based on Chinese culture, requiring a digital database for adoption
Herrador (2024)	Construction and Demolition	Explore CE policy framework in the C&D sector to guide the waste transition	Evaluates and monitors CDW in the Cambodian construction sector	Engages multiple mechanisms and actors to improve CDW collection and recycling services	Optimizes CDW management practices and promotes sustainable landfill operations	Developed using only policies and barriers of the Cambodian construction sector
Nie et al. (2024)	Construction and Demolition	Explore transition towards CDW management in the pre-construction stage	Enforces the adoption of strategies, policies, and CDW management plans in the pre-construction stage	Discusses the five life cycle stages of construction and associated strategies	Provides suggestions to develop strategies, adopt policies, focus on circular design, and CDW management plan	Specific to the pre-construction stage, lacking broader application
Saeed et al. (2023)	Construction	Develop a framework for building construction waste management	Uses multi-objective optimization to determine the optimal material quantity	Monetizes environmental savings and determines the optimal material quantity	Demonstrates how this framework can divert construction waste from landfills	Requires parametric weights to consider stakeholder preferences for determining material quantity
Alite et al. (2023)	Construction and Demolition	Assess current practices and operations to manage CDW	Proposes a system integrating policies and instruments to manage CDW	Discusses different CDW phases and their relevant activities with legislation	Guides the adoption of policies and legislation developed by the government	Does not discuss the different phases of CE and its integration with the CDW framework
HaitherAli and Anjali (2023)	Construction and Demolition	Develop a six-stage framework to achieve CE in CDW management	Provides a structure to manage CDW in the Indian construction sector	Discusses six different phases to achieve CE in CDW management	Stages include set targets, establish infrastructure, enact regulations, enforce and implement, monitor and control, analyze and improve to achieve CE	Lacks systematic and structured guidelines to implement CE in the construction sector to manage CDW.
RİGİLLO et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Extend the scope of CDW through reuse in diversified fields	Helps in reusing the CDW for non-standard manufactures and components	Governs the use of recycled aggregates for building components production	Reuses C&D waste materials through the concept of file-to-factory process	The framework’s nature is deterministic
Shooshtarian et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Provide practical solutions to overcome barriers for market development of CDW	Supports CDW market development in the Australian construction sector	Establishes four groups of barriers and enablers to create a market for CDW	Provides solutions for challenges associated with CDW market development	Developed based on barriers and enablers influencing the Australian CDW market development
Jahan et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Propose a theoretical framework for life cycle stages of CDW management	Guides how to manage wood waste in the construction sector	Presents six stages of CDW management plans in circular ways	Provides theoretical guidelines to manage wood waste in the construction sector	The framework is specifically provided for wood waste
Sharma et al. (2022)	Demolition	Provide knowledge about the lifecycle of buildings from a CE perspective	Guides how to handle and manage demolition waste	Discusses lifecycle phases of building demolition activities	Provides guidelines about the lifecycle stages of building demolition activities	Relies on building demolition activities only
Maury-Ramírez et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Develop a CE-based framework for CDW material management	Helps manage CDW in Colombia	Discusses four different phases to adopt CE for CDW management	Phases include raw material extraction, production, construction, use and operation, and end of life to adopt CE	Lacks structured guidelines to adopt CE in the construction sector
Superti et al. (2021)	Construction and Demolition	Develop CE framework for CDW management	Helps manage CDW in Switzerland	Discusses four different phases to adopt CE for CDW management	Phases include Research and Realize, Implement, Support, and Enable to adopt CE	Lacks an adoption process
Lu et al. (2021)	Construction and Demolition	Develop an analytical framework of “zero waste construction site”	Helps manage CDW in China	Explores the CDW materials circularity process using the 3R concept	Reuse, reduce, and recycle approaches applied to prepare an analytical framework for a zero-waste site	Lacks tools, techniques, and other internal requirements
Ruiz et al. (2020)	Construction	Provide knowledge about the construction stages and waste management	Guides how to handle and manage construction waste	Discusses waste management within construction activities	Provides guidelines about building construction lifecycle stages and waste management activities	Relies on building construction waste management activities only

Authors	Field	Key objectives	Practicality	Effectiveness	Usability	Limitations
Han et al. (2024)	Demolition	Facilitate sustainability-oriented decision-making at the planning stage of demolition activities	The BIM-based framework accommodates inventory analysis using MCDA algorithms to manage demolition waste	Quantifies and visualizes the recycling value of building components	Integrates BIM, inventory analysis tools, and MCDA algorithms for planning demolition activities	Developed based on Chinese culture, requiring a digital database for adoption
Herrador (2024)	Construction and Demolition	Explore CE policy framework in the C&D sector to guide the waste transition	Evaluates and monitors CDW in the Cambodian construction sector	Engages multiple mechanisms and actors to improve CDW collection and recycling services	Optimizes CDW management practices and promotes sustainable landfill operations	Developed using only policies and barriers of the Cambodian construction sector
Nie et al. (2024)	Construction and Demolition	Explore transition towards CDW management in the pre-construction stage	Enforces the adoption of strategies, policies, and CDW management plans in the pre-construction stage	Discusses the five life cycle stages of construction and associated strategies	Provides suggestions to develop strategies, adopt policies, focus on circular design, and CDW management plan	Specific to the pre-construction stage, lacking broader application
Saeed et al. (2023)	Construction	Develop a framework for building construction waste management	Uses multi-objective optimization to determine the optimal material quantity	Monetizes environmental savings and determines the optimal material quantity	Demonstrates how this framework can divert construction waste from landfills	Requires parametric weights to consider stakeholder preferences for determining material quantity
Alite et al. (2023)	Construction and Demolition	Assess current practices and operations to manage CDW	Proposes a system integrating policies and instruments to manage CDW	Discusses different CDW phases and their relevant activities with legislation	Guides the adoption of policies and legislation developed by the government	Does not discuss the different phases of CE and its integration with the CDW framework
HaitherAli and Anjali (2023)	Construction and Demolition	Develop a six-stage framework to achieve CE in CDW management	Provides a structure to manage CDW in the Indian construction sector	Discusses six different phases to achieve CE in CDW management	Stages include set targets, establish infrastructure, enact regulations, enforce and implement, monitor and control, analyze and improve to achieve CE	Lacks systematic and structured guidelines to implement CE in the construction sector to manage CDW.
RİGİLLO et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Extend the scope of CDW through reuse in diversified fields	Helps in reusing the CDW for non-standard manufactures and components	Governs the use of recycled aggregates for building components production	Reuses C&D waste materials through the concept of file-to-factory process	The framework’s nature is deterministic
Shooshtarian et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Provide practical solutions to overcome barriers for market development of CDW	Supports CDW market development in the Australian construction sector	Establishes four groups of barriers and enablers to create a market for CDW	Provides solutions for challenges associated with CDW market development	Developed based on barriers and enablers influencing the Australian CDW market development
Jahan et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Propose a theoretical framework for life cycle stages of CDW management	Guides how to manage wood waste in the construction sector	Presents six stages of CDW management plans in circular ways	Provides theoretical guidelines to manage wood waste in the construction sector	The framework is specifically provided for wood waste
Sharma et al. (2022)	Demolition	Provide knowledge about the lifecycle of buildings from a CE perspective	Guides how to handle and manage demolition waste	Discusses lifecycle phases of building demolition activities	Provides guidelines about the lifecycle stages of building demolition activities	Relies on building demolition activities only
Maury-Ramírez et al. (2022)	Construction and Demolition	Develop a CE-based framework for CDW material management	Helps manage CDW in Colombia	Discusses four different phases to adopt CE for CDW management	Phases include raw material extraction, production, construction, use and operation, and end of life to adopt CE	Lacks structured guidelines to adopt CE in the construction sector
Superti et al. (2021)	Construction and Demolition	Develop CE framework for CDW management	Helps manage CDW in Switzerland	Discusses four different phases to adopt CE for CDW management	Phases include Research and Realize, Implement, Support, and Enable to adopt CE	Lacks an adoption process
Lu et al. (2021)	Construction and Demolition	Develop an analytical framework of “zero waste construction site”	Helps manage CDW in China	Explores the CDW materials circularity process using the 3R concept	Reuse, reduce, and recycle approaches applied to prepare an analytical framework for a zero-waste site	Lacks tools, techniques, and other internal requirements
Ruiz et al. (2020)	Construction	Provide knowledge about the construction stages and waste management	Guides how to handle and manage construction waste	Discusses waste management within construction activities	Provides guidelines about building construction lifecycle stages and waste management activities	Relies on building construction waste management activities only

Source(s): Table created by authors