Summary of VV&A based on methods
| Method | Scheme | Application | Evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Similar degree method | Peng (2017) | Suitable for evaluating the credibility of simulation systems and the actual system | Only applied to the credibility evaluation of simple systems |
| Gray clustering method | Tian (2012) | Integrative Avionics System; large-scale simulations | Easy idea; need combining with the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) |
| AHP | Shangguan et al. (2014) | Cooperative vehicle infrastructure simulation system; large-scale simulations | Simple and practical; many indicators easily lead to the difficult confirmation of a judgment matrix |
| Spectral analysis | Fishman (1967) | Time-series data generated by the simulated stochastic models | To evaluate the equivalence between the simulation model and the actual system |
| The software credibility test method based on behavior declaration | Lv (2016) | The verification model of the Web software | Application scenarios are too simplistic |
| The hybrid metric design method for the application software credibility | Han et al. (2013) | Information system | Lacks in practical significance |
| The credible evaluation method based on FAHP | Qi et al. (2018) | Information system | The method constraints are complex |
| The knowledge-based approach for the validation of simulation models | Birta and Ozmizrak (1996) | Behavioral model | Enabled the application of a variety of solution-oriented techniques |
| The method is based on similarity theory and evaluates confidence level with fuzzy mathematics | Liu (2001) | A large complex simulation system | Lacking consideration of the impact in-between complex subsystems |
| The behavior validation method based on a dynamic model | Yaman Barlas (1989) | Dynamic behavioral model | Limited toward single application type |
| Method | Scheme | Application | Evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Similar degree method | Suitable for evaluating the credibility of simulation systems and the actual system | Only applied to the credibility evaluation of simple systems | |
| Gray clustering method | Integrative Avionics System; large-scale simulations | Easy idea; need combining with the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) | |
| AHP | Cooperative vehicle infrastructure simulation system; large-scale simulations | Simple and practical; many indicators easily lead to the difficult confirmation of a judgment matrix | |
| Spectral analysis | Fishman (1967) | Time-series data generated by the simulated stochastic models | To evaluate the equivalence between the simulation model and the actual system |
| The software credibility test method based on behavior declaration | The verification model of the Web software | Application scenarios are too simplistic | |
| The hybrid metric design method for the application software credibility | Han | Information system | Lacks in practical significance |
| The credible evaluation method based on FAHP | Qi | Information system | The method constraints are complex |
| The knowledge-based approach for the validation of simulation models | Behavioral model | Enabled the application of a variety of solution-oriented techniques | |
| The method is based on similarity theory and evaluates confidence level with fuzzy mathematics | Liu (2001) | A large complex simulation system | Lacking consideration of the impact in-between complex subsystems |
| The behavior validation method based on a dynamic model | Yaman | Dynamic behavioral model | Limited toward single application type |
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.