Evaluation of supply chain resilience enablers to achieve performance
| Author (Year) | Independent variable components | Dependent variable components | Research methodology | SCR/Performance | Industry | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E.S | T.M. | C.S | Other | |||||
| Belhadi et al. (2024) | Adaptive capabilities, SC collaboration and artificial intelligence | well prepared to face constraints of disruptions, rapidly plan and execute contingency plans, adequately respond to unexpected disruptions, swiftly return to original state and gain superior state post disruption | ✓ | |||||
| Acar et al. (2021) | Organisational learning culture and supplier trust | Material flow would be quickly restored, not take long to recover to normal operating performance, SC would easily recover to original state and disruption will be dealt quickly | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Ju et al. (2021) | Integration quality and value-co-creation | Resistance and recovery ability | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Logistics service supply chain | |||
| Piprani et al. (2022) | Flexibility (product development flexibility, production flexibility, logistics flexibility, supply base flexibility and supplier’s flexibility) | Prepared for unexpected events, respond to unexpected disruptions by restoring operations, connectedness among members during disruptions and control over structure and functions | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Manufacturing | |||
| Scholten and Schilder (2015) | Supply chain collaboration | Visibility, velocity and flexibility | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Tan et al. (2022) | Information sharing effectiveness, organisational ethical and information security culture | Visibility, velocity and flexibility | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Manufacturing | |||
| Mandal et al. (2017) | Supply competence and demand competence | Revert to normal operating conditions in the face of disruption, capacity to optimally deal with losses, migrate to optimal state of performance post disruption and use disruptions to gain competitive advantage | ✓ | Operational and relational performance | Manufacturing | |||
| Pettit et al. (2013) | S.C. Capabilities | Balance between S.C. capabilities and S.C vulnerabilities | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| da Silva Poberschnigg et al. (2020) | Cross-functional integration | Collaboration, visibility, agility, adaptability and flexibility | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Automotive parts supplier | |||
| Um and Han (2021) | Agility, collaboration, information sharing, risk sharing, trust, visibility, risk management culture, adaptive capability, structure and technological capability | Not affected by disruptions/risks related to your suppliers or customers and not affected by disruptions/risks related to your company’s operations | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple (manufacturing) | |||
| Laguir et al. (2022) | Analytics capability of organisation and SC disruption orientation | Increase in the amount of goods delivered on time; decrease in inventory; decrease in scrap rate; promotion of product quality and improved capacity utilisation | ✓ | Operational performance | Multiple | |||
| Bag et al. (2019) | Dynamic remanufacturing capability, control orientation and flexible orientation | Anticipate and overcome disruptions, reconfigure resources and re-establish usual operations, operations continue after disruptions, able to meet customer demand and performance don’t diverge significantly from normal | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Scholten et al. (2019) | SC capabilities and learning mechanisms | Adaptive disruption capability | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Kumar and Anbanandam (2019) | SC flexibility components such as sourcing, manufacturing and logistic flexibility | Supply chain resilience index | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Manufacturing | |||
| Belhadi et al. (2021) | Adaptive capabilities and SC Collaboration | Prepared to face constraints of SC disruptions, rapidly plan and execute contingency plans; adequately respond to unexpected disruptions by quickly restoring its product flow; swiftly return to its original state; gain a superior state compared to its original state; order fill rate, on-time delivery, lead time and unit cost | ✓ | SC Resilience; SC Performance | Multiple | |||
| Aslam et al. (2020) | Supply chain adaptability and supply chain agility | Anticipate and overcome disruptions, reconfigure resources and re-establish usual operations, operations continue after disruptions, able to meet customer demand and performance don’t diverge significantly from normal | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Jafarnejad et al. (2019) | Agility, collaboration, sharing of information, trust, explicitness of supply chain, risk management culture, adaptability, structure, funding and environment conditions | System dynamics model between the enablers during disruption period | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Medical equipment | |||
| Wieland and Wallenburg (2013) | Communications, cooperation and integration | Agility and robustness | ✓ | Supply chain customer’s value | Manufacturing | |||
| Abeysekara et al. (2019) | Risk management culture | Re-engineering, agility and collaboration | ✓ | Competitive advantage, firm performance | Apparel | |||
| Treiblmaier (2018) | Centralisation and decentralisation | fast reactions to unforeseen disturbances, reducing the number of negative external forces, reducing the impact of negative external forces and quick return to normal operating processes | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Adobor and McMullen (2018) | Efficiency based capabilities, adaptive capability and collaborative | Engineering resilience, ecological resilience and evolutionary resilience | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Jain et al. (2017) | Supply chain resilience enablers | Supply chain resilience index | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | |||
| Liu et al. (2018) | Risk management culture | Agility, integration and re-engineering | ✓ | Risk mgmt, firm performance | Multiple | |||
| Author (Year) | Independent variable components | Dependent variable components | Research methodology | SCR/Performance | Industry | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E.S | T.M. | C.S | Other | |||||
| Adaptive capabilities, SC collaboration and artificial intelligence | well prepared to face constraints of disruptions, rapidly plan and execute contingency plans, adequately respond to unexpected disruptions, swiftly return to original state and gain superior state post disruption | ✓ | ||||||
| Organisational learning culture and supplier trust | Material flow would be quickly restored, not take long to recover to normal operating performance, SC would easily recover to original state and disruption will be dealt quickly | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Integration quality and value-co-creation | Resistance and recovery ability | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Logistics service supply chain | ||||
| Flexibility (product development flexibility, production flexibility, logistics flexibility, supply base flexibility and supplier’s flexibility) | Prepared for unexpected events, respond to unexpected disruptions by restoring operations, connectedness among members during disruptions and control over structure and functions | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Manufacturing | ||||
| Supply chain collaboration | Visibility, velocity and flexibility | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Information sharing effectiveness, organisational ethical and information security culture | Visibility, velocity and flexibility | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Manufacturing | ||||
| Supply competence and demand competence | Revert to normal operating conditions in the face of disruption, capacity to optimally deal with losses, migrate to optimal state of performance post disruption and use disruptions to gain competitive advantage | ✓ | Operational and relational performance | Manufacturing | ||||
| S.C. Capabilities | Balance between S.C. capabilities and S.C vulnerabilities | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Cross-functional integration | Collaboration, visibility, agility, adaptability and flexibility | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Automotive parts supplier | ||||
| Agility, collaboration, information sharing, risk sharing, trust, visibility, risk management culture, adaptive capability, structure and technological capability | Not affected by disruptions/risks related to your suppliers or customers and not affected by disruptions/risks related to your company’s operations | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple (manufacturing) | ||||
| Analytics capability of organisation and SC disruption orientation | Increase in the amount of goods delivered on time; decrease in inventory; decrease in scrap rate; promotion of product quality and improved capacity utilisation | ✓ | Operational performance | Multiple | ||||
| Dynamic remanufacturing capability, control orientation and flexible orientation | Anticipate and overcome disruptions, reconfigure resources and re-establish usual operations, operations continue after disruptions, able to meet customer demand and performance don’t diverge significantly from normal | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| SC capabilities and learning mechanisms | Adaptive disruption capability | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| SC flexibility components such as sourcing, manufacturing and logistic flexibility | Supply chain resilience index | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Manufacturing | ||||
| Adaptive capabilities and SC Collaboration | Prepared to face constraints of SC disruptions, rapidly plan and execute contingency plans; adequately respond to unexpected disruptions by quickly restoring its product flow; swiftly return to its original state; gain a superior state compared to its original state; order fill rate, on-time delivery, lead time and unit cost | ✓ | SC Resilience; SC Performance | Multiple | ||||
| Supply chain adaptability and supply chain agility | Anticipate and overcome disruptions, reconfigure resources and re-establish usual operations, operations continue after disruptions, able to meet customer demand and performance don’t diverge significantly from normal | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Agility, collaboration, sharing of information, trust, explicitness of supply chain, risk management culture, adaptability, structure, funding and environment conditions | System dynamics model between the enablers during disruption period | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Medical equipment | ||||
| Communications, cooperation and integration | Agility and robustness | ✓ | Supply chain customer’s value | Manufacturing | ||||
| Risk management culture | Re-engineering, agility and collaboration | ✓ | Competitive advantage, firm performance | Apparel | ||||
| Centralisation and decentralisation | fast reactions to unforeseen disturbances, reducing the number of negative external forces, reducing the impact of negative external forces and quick return to normal operating processes | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Efficiency based capabilities, adaptive capability and collaborative | Engineering resilience, ecological resilience and evolutionary resilience | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Supply chain resilience enablers | Supply chain resilience index | ✓ | Supply chain resilience | Multiple | ||||
| Risk management culture | Agility, integration and re-engineering | ✓ | Risk mgmt, firm performance | Multiple | ||||
Source(s): Table created by authors
Sharing content requires targeting cookies to be enabled. Please update your cookie preferences to use this feature.