Figure A1 The table consists of 9...

Figure A1

A table details the results of a study on Second-order themes and their relationship to firms and to each other.

The table consists of 9 columns and 26 rows. Columns 2 to 9 represent Abstract Domains. Columns 2 to 9 are as follows: A 1, A 2, A 3, A 4, A 5, A 6, A 7. The first is labeled Firm. A 1 is subdivided into S 1, S 2, and S 3. A 2 is subdivided into S 4, S 5, S 6, and S 7. A 3 is subdivided into S 8, S 9, S 10, and S 11. A 4 is subdivided into S 12, S 13, and S 14. A 5 is subdivided into S 15 and S 16. A 6 is subdivided into S 17 and S 18. The sub columns represent Second-order Themes. The row entries are as follows. Row 1: Firm: F 1. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: X. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 2: Firm: F 2. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 3: Firm: F 3. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 5. Row 4: Firm: F 4. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 6. Row 5: Firm: F 5. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: x. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 8. Row 6: Firm: F 6. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 7. Row 7: Firm: F 7. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 4. Row 8: Firm: F 8. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 9: Firm: F 9. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, x: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: x. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 8. Row 10: Firm: F 10. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 4. Row 11: Firm: F 11. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: x. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 6. Row 12: Firm: F 12. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: x. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 5. Row 13: Firm: F 13. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 14: Firm: F 14. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: x. No. of challenges: 4. Row 15: Firm: F 15. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 7. Row 16: Firm: F 16. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 17: Firm: F 17. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 7. Row 18: Firm: F 18. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 6. Row 19: Firm: F 19. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 3. Row 20: Firm: F 20. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 21: Firm: F 21. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 6. Row 22: Firm: F 22. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: x. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 7. Row 23: Firm: F 23. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: x. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 4. Row 24: Firm: F 24. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: x. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 5. Row 25: Firm: F 25. Second-order theme: Abstract Domains A 1, S 1: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 2: null. Abstract Domains A 1, S 3: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 4: x. Abstract Domains A 2, S 5: null. Abstract Domains A 2, S 6: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 7: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 8: x. Abstract Domains A 3, S 9: null. Abstract Domains A 3, S 10: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 11: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 12: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 13: null. Abstract Domains A 4, S 14: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 15: null. Abstract Domains A 5, S 16: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 17: null. Abstract Domains A 6, S 18: null. No. of challenges: 3. The last row, 26, shows the number of occurrences as follows: Row 26: S 1: 16. S 2: 11. S 3: 10. S 4: 11. S 5: 4. S 6: 13. S7: 6. S 8: 5. S 9: 4. S 10: 6. S 11: 7. S 12: 6. S 13: 4. S 14: 8. S 15: 7. S 16: 2. S 17: 2. S 18: 7. Total challenges: 129.

Second-order themes across firms F1–F30; “X” marks presence. Source: Authors' own work

Sharing Unavailable