Figure 3
The graph plots M A P E against generation from 1 to 25 for repetitions 1 to 10. Repetition 6 peaks near 59 at generation 2, and repetition 2 peaks near 47 at generation 2 and near 17 at generation 4. Repetition 8 reaches about 20 at generation 3 and then stays near 8 to 12. Several other repetitions fluctuate below about 16 before decreasing. The enlarged view from generations 22 to 25 shows most values staying below 1.MAPE - generation graph for model 2014