Figure 3
The multi-panel layout shows seven scatter plots arranged across two rows, each panel consisting of a square grid with both horizontal and vertical axes ranging from 0.0 to 1.0 with an interval of 0.1. A diagonal reference line extends from the lower-left corner (0, 0) to the upper-right corner (1, 1) in every panel. Blue circular markers represent data points, forming dense vertical clusters near low horizontal values and spreading upward across the vertical axis. Each panel includes a control section on the left with labels “Y Axis: C S C” and a specific “X Axis” model, along with a “Case I D Column”, a “Plot” button, and a “Zoom” checkbox. Below, two lines display “Consistency X less than or equal to Y” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y”. In the first panel labeled “A D asterisk tilde C C asterisk tilde I O T asterisk tilde I S asterisk tilde S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 1” is selected. Points form a dense vertical cluster between x equals 0.0 and 0.2, with vertical spread from about 0.1 to near 1.0. Additional points appear around x equals 0.4 to 0.6. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.87234” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to: 0.19185”. In the second panel labeled “tilde C C asterisk tilde C L asterisk tilde I O T asterisk I S asterisk tilde P R asterisk tilde S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 2” is selected. Points are concentrated below x equals 0.2 with vertical values from about 0.1 to 0.95, and a few points extend toward x equals 0.5. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.854377” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y: 0.152678”. In the third panel labeled “A D asterisk C L asterisk tilde I O T asterisk tilde I S asterisk tilde P R asterisk tilde S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 3” is selected. Points are distributed between x equals 0.0 and 0.4 with vertical spread up to about 0.95, and a few points appear near x equals 0.5. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.882789” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y: 0.179001”. In the fourth panel labeled “A D asterisk C C asterisk tilde C L asterisk tilde I O T asterisk tilde I S asterisk S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 4” is selected. A dense cluster appears near x less than 0.2 with several points reaching vertical values close to 1.0, along with scattered points between x equals 0.3 and 0.5. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.911064” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y: 0.195698”. In the fifth panel labeled “tilde A D asterisk tilde C C asterisk C L asterisk tilde I S asterisk P R asterisk S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 5” is selected. Points cluster between x equals 0.0 and 0.3 with vertical values from about 0.1 to 0.95, and a few points extend toward x equals 0.5. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.880783” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y: 0.223375”. In the sixth panel labeled “tilde A D asterisk C C asterisk tilde C L asterisk tilde I O T asterisk tilde I S asterisk tilde P R asterisk tilde S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 6” is selected. Most points lie below x equals 0.2, with vertical spread up to about 0.95, and sparse points appear near x equals 0.4 to 0.5. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.890583” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y: 0.149368”. In the seventh panel labeled “tilde A D asterisk tilde C C asterisk tilde C L asterisk I O T asterisk I S asterisk P R asterisk tilde S G O”, the “X Axis: Model 7” is selected. Points cluster near x less than 0.3 with vertical values up to near 1.0, and a few points extend toward x equals 0.5. The values shown are “Consistency X less than or equal to Y: 0.885694” and “Consistency X greater than or equal to Y: 0.189982”. Note: All numerical data values are approximated.Fuzzy-plot of models for high CSC (from Table 9) using data from the holdout sample