Figure 1
A flowchart illustrating the process of identifying studies via Scopus database. The flowchart is divided into four main sections: Identification, Screening, Eligibility, and Included. In the Identification section, documents are identified from Scopus databases totaling 2813. No records are removed before screening. In the Screening section, 495 documents are screened, and 244 are excluded based on obvious irrelevance and the quality of the journal. 158 titles and abstracts are read for screening, and 43 studies are excluded for not aligning fully with the research topic, 4 for limited research rigor, 16 for being out of scope, and 5 for being literature review papers. 90 documents are sought for retrieval, and none are not retrieved. In the Eligibility section, 90 full-text articles are assessed for eligibility, and 31 are excluded: 12 for not serving the purpose of the review and 19 for findings not relevant to the research questions.PRISMA flowchart. Source: Authors’ own work