Benchmarking health and safety performance through company safety competitions

A case study is described in which an audit programme was developed as a measure of health and safety performance. The audit programme was implemented as a safety competition in a UK water utility over a period of three years with the results also used for benchmarking the company’s health and safety management system. The audit programme, which was based on the Health and Safety Executive’s guidance for effective health and safety management, was used to assess; how well health and safety management was understood; how well health and safety procedures were implemented; and accident frequency rates within the company. An important aspect of the audit programme was the inclusion of managers, supervisors, operators and examples of all operational activities in the assessment process. Weaknesses in the company’s health and safety management performance, which were identified in the benchmarking exercise, are discussed.