Using Economic Indicators in Analysing Financial Markets

Using Economic Indicators in Analysing Financial Markets

By

Bernd Krampen

United Kingdom – North America – Japan – India – Malaysia – China

Emerald Publishing Limited

Howard House, Wagon Lane, Bingley BD16 1WA, UK

First edition 2023

Copyright © 2023 Bernd Krampen.

Published under exclusive licence by Emerald Publishing Limited.

Reprints and permissions service

No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without either the prior written permission of the publisher or a licence permitting restricted copying issued in the UK by The Copyright Licensing Agency and in the USA by The Copyright Clearance Center. Any opinions expressed in the chapters are those of the authors. Whilst Emerald makes every effort to ensure the quality and accuracy of its content, Emerald makes no representation implied or otherwise, as to the chapters' suitability and application and disclaims any warranties, express or implied, to their use.

British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

ISBN: 978-1-80455-325-1 (Print)

ISBN: 978-1-80455-324-4 (Online)

ISBN: 978-1-80455-326-8 (Epub)

Part I 
Chapter 2 
Figure 1.Use of Different Signals by Type of Analysis Depending on the Time Horizon.
Figure 2.Overview of Interactions in Economic Activity, Market Developments and Government Influence.
Figure 3.Leading Indicators and Lagging Indicators.
Figure 4.Economic Indicators Worldwide Most Sensitive to Stocks, Bonds, Currencies in the Monthly Schedule.
Part II 
Chapter 3 
Figure 5.USA: GDP Growth and Leading Indicators.
Figure 6.ISM® PMI vs. Philadelphia Fed and NY Empire State.
Figure 7.Non-farm Payrolls vs. Unemployment Rate.
Figure 8.Durables and Aircraft Order Intake at Boeing.
Chapter 4 
Figure 9.China: GDP Growth and Leading Indicators.
Figure 10.Japan: GDP Growth and Leading Indicators.
Chapter 5 
Figure 11.Germany: GDP Growth and Leading Indicators.
Figure 12.Ifo Business Expectations and ZEW Economic Expectations.
Figure 13.Ifo Business Assessment and ZEW Economic Situation.
Part III 
Chapter 6 
Figure 14.USA: GDP Growth Contribution Consumption and GDP Growth.
Figure 15.USA: GDP Growth Contribution Consumption and Explanatory Time Series.
Figure 16.USA: GDP Growth Contribution Structures and Explanatory Time Series.
Figure 17.USA: GDP Growth Contribution Equipment and Software and Explanatory Time Series.
Figure 18.USA: GDP Growth Contribution Residential Investment and Explanatory Time Series.
Figure 19.USA: BIP GDP Growth Contribution Inventories and Explanatory Time Series.
Figure 20.USA: GDP Growth Contribution Net Exports and Explanatory Time Series.
Chapter 7 
Figure 21.GDP Growth and New York Empire State Survey (3 Months Ahead).
Figure 22.GDP Growth and Philadelphia Fed (3 Months Ahead).
Figure 23.GDP Growth and ISM® Services PMI (3 Months Ahead).
Figure 24.GDP Growth and ISM® PMI (5 Months Ahead).
Figure 25.GDP Growth and Personal Spending (3 Months Ahead).
Figure 26.GDP Growth and Rail Freight Transport (3 Months Ahead).
Figure 27.GDP Growth and Building Permits (4 Months Ahead).
Figure 28.GDP Growth and Aruoba Diebold Scotty Index (4 Months Ahead).
Figure 29.GDP Growth and Money Supply M1 (7 Months Ahead).
Figure 30.GDP Growth and Stock Market (6 Months Ahead).
Figure 31.GDP Growth and Real Interest Rate (9 Months Ahead).
Figure 32.GDP Growth and Yield Curve (18 Months Ahead).
Figure 33.GDP Growth and Oil WTI.
Figure 34.GDP Growth and Gold and Silver.
Figure 35.GDP Growth and Copper and Aluminium (2 months ahead).
Figure 36.CPI Food versus PPI Crude Food and S&P GSCI Agriculture Index®.
Figure 37.CPI Energy versus Oil Price WTI and Gasoline Price.
Figure 38.CPI Housing and CPU Shelter versus Housing Prices.
Figure 39.CPI Used Car & Trucks versus Mannheim Auctions Used Car Value Index.
Figure 40.CPI Clothing versus Cotton Price.
Figure 41.CPI Core Versus NFIB ‘Higher Prices’.
Figure 42.CPI Core Versus Wage Growth (Hourly Earnings and Personal Income Compensation).
Chapter 8 
Figure 43.Possible Causes for Recessions.
Figure 44.Recessions and Yield Curve (10Y–2Y).
Figure 45.Recessions and ISM® PMI.
Figure 46.Recessions and Unemployment Rate.
Figure 47.Recessions and the Change in the Unemployment Rate.
Figure 48.Recessions and Conference Board® Consumer Confidence®.
Figure 49.Recessions and Personal Spending.
Figure 50.Recessions and Duncan Leading Indicator.
Figure 51.Recessions and the Stock Market S&P 500®.
Part IV 
Chapter 9 
Figure 52.NAHB and University of Michigan Buying Conditions for Houses (BCH).
Figure 53.NAHB and Real Estate Prices.
Figure 54.NAHB and Building Permits, Housing Starts.
Chapter 10 
Figure 55.Multiple Interdependencies in the Financial Markets.
Figure 56.Main Topics of Behavioural Finance.
Figure 57.Different Assessment of Risk in the Loss Area and in the Profit Area.
Part I 
Chapter 2 
Table 1.Criteria for the Relevance of Business Cycle Indicators in the Financial Markets.
Part II 
Chapter 3 
Table 2.Overview of US Economic Data by Segment.
Table 3.Monthly Schedule of US Economic Data Releases.
Table 4.Daily Schedule of US Economic Data Releases.
Table 5.US GDP Growth Release Dates.
Chapter 4 
Table 6.Monthly Schedule of Other Economic Data Releases.
Table 7.Daily Schedule of Other Economic Data Releases.
Part III 
Chapter 6 
Table 8.Overview of Relevant Indicators for GDP Growth Contributions.
Chapter 7 
Table 9.Overview of Leading Indicators for Economic Activity (GDP Growth).
Table 10.Overview of Leading Indicators for CPI Components (Inflation).
Chapter 8 
Table 11.Selection of Indicators for a Possible Upcoming Recession.
Part IV 
Chapter 10 
Table 12.Growth and Disintegration of (Opinion) Parties.
Page
USA GDP growth23
 National Business SurveysISM® PMI29
 ISM® Services PMI34
 IHS Markit® PMI37
 NFIB Small Business Optimism40
 Regional Business SurveysPhiladelphia Fed43
 NY Empire Survey47
 MNI Chicago Business Barometer49
 Labour MarketNon-farm payrolls53
 Unemployment rate57
 Average hourly earnings61
 Average weekly hours64
 Initial claims65
 Job openings68
 ADP employment70
 ManufacturingIndustrial production72
 Capacity utilisation76
 Durable goods orders78
 Private ConsumptionRetail sales83
 Personal spending87
 Personal income89
 Consumer SurveysUniversity of Michigan consumer confidence92
 Conference Board® Consumer Confidence®95
 Real Estate MarketNAHB Index99
 Building permits102
 Housing starts104
 Other Macro DataTrade balance of goods and services106
 PricesConsumer prices (CPI)109
 Producer prices (PPI)113
 Import Prices115
 PCE price deflator116
 GDP price deflator118
China GDP growth124
 CFLP PMI127
 Caixin PMI130
Japan GDP growth134
 Tankan business conditions135
Germany GDP growth139
 ifo Index142
 ZEW survey149
 Sentix® economic indices152
Belgium Business conditions155
Euroland Economic sentiment156

Bernd Krampen has studied economics at the universities of Kiel (Germany) and Swansea (United Kingdom). Since 1997 he has worked as financial analyst and economist for Norddeutsche Landesbank in Hanover (Germany). He is responsible for assessing and forecasting economic activity, inflation, interest rates and exchange rates for various countries. His focus lies on fundamental economic analysis, but he also examines behavioural aspects. He also has gained some relevant experience teaching financial economics in educational institutions (e.g. Sparkassenakademie Niedersachsen). His publications include contributions to peer-reviewed journals such as the German Journal of Risk and Insurance. He lives in Barsinghausen near Hanover with his wife Sandra and their daughters Alessia and Noelia.

Research is formalized curiosity. It is poking and prying with a purpose.

(Zora Neale Hurston)

Imagination is the highest form of research.

(Albert Einstein)

Where are the economy and the financial markets heading? What is the outlook for growth, and what are the growth drivers? What does this mean for the expected trends on the financial markets? These questions, which at first glance seem rather academic, can mean hard cash – with the right investments on the financial markets. After all, economic developments have a significant influence on financial market variables such as interest rates, exchange rates and shares. Correct positioning on the financial markets can actually generate profits for one's own investments when macroeconomic trends materialise. In this respect, the question of the economy is not merely an academic-sporting exercise, but creates advantages for one's own wallet.

More than 2 ½ decades of working as an economist in a bank have provided a wealth of experience on how capital markets work and how they can react to new news. Which moods of people, impulses from politics and other (unexpected) influences cause which market movements? Such a wealth of experience is accumulated quasi incidentally over time. Theories and models learned at University have to be compared with experienced reality again and again and can then be considered useful or less useful. Obviously, some of the experiences and insights gained are of interest and of added value.

The main point of this book is to recognise that business cycle analysis is firstly complex, secondly affected by many interdependencies, and thirdly that a forecast of future development should not be overrated. For although there are a large number of indicators that show good tendencies, one problem of analysis is that they often go in different directions. This also explains the differing opinions of economists and analysts when it comes to the future. The weighing of the different indicators is decisive. Unfortunately, however, there is not even agreement on the effects and developments either to the present or the past. One of the intentions of this book is to make readers pause, question, reflect and look critically at many things when connections are all too clear. Things are not always as they – simplistically – appear. Business cycle analysis and economics are not sciences, but applied theories that are supposed to describe the summed actions of many people as a result.

The first step in the analysis to assess the economic development and the implications for the financial markets should be to correctly evaluate the new news flying in every day. It is important to be able to classify the publications of economic data. What do the indicators contain, which are relevant to the market, how to forecast them? Part II deals with the most market-relevant indicators from the major regions.

Analysts want to get an assessment for the coming months to several years. The tools that can be used for this are discussed in Part III. Basically, the aim is to identify the trends for GDP growth and inflation in the next quarters with the help of the economic data available on a monthly basis. The focus is on growth contributions, leading indicators and forecasting recessions. The good forecast properties of sentiment indicators, the NAHB index as an example for the real estate market and an introduction into psychology in analysing financial markets will be discussed in Part IV.