Measuring Executive Agency Ideology Using Large Language Models Available to Purchase

I scale executive agencies along a liberal-conservative dimension using ChatGPT, a large language model, to produce both static measures of executive agency ideology and dynamic measures spanning 1949-2020, almost five decades more coverage than existing dynamic measures. My measure correlates strongly with existing measures although does not perfectly replicate them, indicating the measure is not simply regurgitating existing ones. In addition, the new measure predicts congressional delegation to agencies from 1949 to 2018 consistent with the “ally principle” that political actors delegate to agents closest to them in ideological space. The approach adopted here has an advantage over existing ones because my approach produces measures that are cheaper (~$50) and faster (~4 hours of computing time) to produce, that go back four decades earlier than existing measures, and that can easily be scaled up to include more agencies or time periods without much added cost.